Pivotree Inc
XTSX:PVT
US |
Johnson & Johnson
NYSE:JNJ
|
Pharmaceuticals
|
|
US |
Estee Lauder Companies Inc
NYSE:EL
|
Consumer products
|
|
US |
Exxon Mobil Corp
NYSE:XOM
|
Energy
|
|
US |
Church & Dwight Co Inc
NYSE:CHD
|
Consumer products
|
|
US |
Pfizer Inc
NYSE:PFE
|
Pharmaceuticals
|
|
US |
American Express Co
NYSE:AXP
|
Financial Services
|
|
US |
Nike Inc
NYSE:NKE
|
Textiles, Apparel & Luxury Goods
|
|
US |
Visa Inc
NYSE:V
|
Technology
|
|
CN |
Alibaba Group Holding Ltd
NYSE:BABA
|
Retail
|
|
US |
3M Co
NYSE:MMM
|
Industrial Conglomerates
|
|
US |
JPMorgan Chase & Co
NYSE:JPM
|
Banking
|
|
US |
Coca-Cola Co
NYSE:KO
|
Beverages
|
|
US |
Target Corp
NYSE:TGT
|
Retail
|
|
US |
Walt Disney Co
NYSE:DIS
|
Media
|
|
US |
Mueller Industries Inc
NYSE:MLI
|
Machinery
|
|
US |
PayPal Holdings Inc
NASDAQ:PYPL
|
Technology
|
Utilize notes to systematically review your investment decisions. By reflecting on past outcomes, you can discern effective strategies and identify those that underperformed. This continuous feedback loop enables you to adapt and refine your approach, optimizing for future success.
Each note serves as a learning point, offering insights into your decision-making processes. Over time, you'll accumulate a personalized database of knowledge, enhancing your ability to make informed decisions quickly and effectively.
With a comprehensive record of your investment history at your fingertips, you can compare current opportunities against past experiences. This not only bolsters your confidence but also ensures that each decision is grounded in a well-documented rationale.
Do you really want to delete this note?
This action cannot be undone.
52 Week Range |
0.9
2.2
|
Price Target |
|
We'll email you a reminder when the closing price reaches CAD.
Choose the stock you wish to monitor with a price alert.
Johnson & Johnson
NYSE:JNJ
|
US | |
Estee Lauder Companies Inc
NYSE:EL
|
US | |
Exxon Mobil Corp
NYSE:XOM
|
US | |
Church & Dwight Co Inc
NYSE:CHD
|
US | |
Pfizer Inc
NYSE:PFE
|
US | |
American Express Co
NYSE:AXP
|
US | |
Nike Inc
NYSE:NKE
|
US | |
Visa Inc
NYSE:V
|
US | |
Alibaba Group Holding Ltd
NYSE:BABA
|
CN | |
3M Co
NYSE:MMM
|
US | |
JPMorgan Chase & Co
NYSE:JPM
|
US | |
Coca-Cola Co
NYSE:KO
|
US | |
Target Corp
NYSE:TGT
|
US | |
Walt Disney Co
NYSE:DIS
|
US | |
Mueller Industries Inc
NYSE:MLI
|
US | |
PayPal Holdings Inc
NASDAQ:PYPL
|
US |
This alert will be permanently deleted.
[Audio Gap] Before we begin, we'd like to remind listeners that certain information discussed today may be forward-looking in nature. Such forward-looking information reflects the company's current views with respect to future events. Any such information is subject to risks, uncertainties and assumptions that could cause actual results to differ materially from those projected in the forward-looking statements. For more information on the risks, uncertainties and assumptions related to forward-looking statements, please refer to Pivotree's public filings, which are available on SEDAR.During the call, we will reference certain non-IFRS financial measures. Although we believe these measures provide supplemental information about our financial performance, they're not recognized measures and do not have standardized meanings under IFRS. Please see our MD&A for additional information regarding our non-IFRS financial measures, including from reconciliations to the nearest IFRS measures.Now, I'd like to turn the call over to Pivotree's CEO, Bill Di Nardo.
Thank you, Denis, and good morning, everyone. Thanks for joining us on our first quarter 2023 conference call. It seems like it wasn't that long ago, we just did this. With me today is Mo, our Chief Financial Officer.Look, a pretty straightforward quarter. First quarter went as planned and was in line with expectations. The one thing I'm excited about is that the pieces of our strategy are coming together. We're pleased with how the business units are progressing and we're really pleased with how our products are evolving and how customers are really taking an interest in those areas that we've been working on practically since the IPO.Now again, I'm sure you're hearing it from everybody. There's the [Technical Difficulty] on the economic climate. We'll talk a little bit about that. But overall, I feel pretty good about this quarter. So revenue of $25 million, that was up 2% from Q1 of last year. And last year, we had a really strong Q1, and that was on the back of record professional service bookings. Now we've talked about this just recently. This year, we're also coming off record bookings in Q4. But as we said last quarter, a number of those bookings were much larger contracts than normal, and they're spread over multiple quarters. So these are 4 quarter, 5 quarter type deals. As a result, revenue growth is going to be modest despite the record bookings, but what we've got is better certainty on future.One of the things, again, we've talked about, I think we're seeing it and in talking to our peers, we're also hearing consistency around this, just longer timelines to get signatures on new deals. We expected this going into 2023, and I think this is going to be the new normal this year. We remain on a critical path for many of our customers and that has a lot to do with the systems that we implement for them and manage for them. It's really the backbone for their revenue and operations.Again, one of the great indicators our products are on the right track as our ARR grew 6% year-over-year. That's been pretty stable. We are transitioning project customers to recurring services. This also has a bit of an impact on signing timing. We can finish a project, we could initiate and start another project, but we have been having these conversations around converting from a project basis to more of an outcome and recurring revenue orientation. And that automatically creates a little bit more selling time. But we're excited to see that transformation. That's really been part of this transformation we've been expecting and planning for, which is that switch to more productization, more outcome orientation and less of a project orientation.I think the other thing we're benefiting from, particularly in some of our legacy businesses is long-time managed service customers have been delaying migrations from older systems to new. These tend to be bigger capital projects. And as we've talked about, those are under way more scrutiny than they used to be. And if you can find ways of saving folks some money in the short-term, you can delay even further those migrations to new initiatives.So overall, when you look at the stability on the ARR, you look at the conversations we're having with customers around converting to recurring revenue and the larger multi-quarter projects that we booked, it gives us confidence we're going to be able to execute on our profitability goal this year. And as we stated from day 1, this year is about driving consistent repeatable EBITDA. So Q1 EBITDA adjusted was almost $1 million, we had a 270 basis point improvement from last year and 300% growth year-over-year. So again, we're really, really pleased with -- we're doing what we said we were going to do. We're focusing on bottom line. We're stabilizing and helping our existing customers in a way that our revenue retention was good as well. We're having a good start to the year.Now I think one of the things I mentioned in my CEO letter, that's worth talking about, and that's just bookings because I think we refer to that quite often as a good leading indicator. And so it's helpful to explain this quarter's bookings. Last quarter, Q4, we had a record when we stated that, that record was really based on a couple of very large multi-quarter contracts. So if you take out the large multi-quarter contracts, and they're still a bit of the anomaly. I think we're seeing more of them in our pipeline, but there's more volatility around the timing of closes on those. So we kind of think about those as spikes.If you look at our rolling 4 quarter average, somewhere between 16 and $17 million, particularly when you normalize out the big. So we're quite comfortable that this quarter was right about our average. If we want to start hitting some of those growth targets that we've talked about that we're aiming for over the next 3 years, then we need to do better than our rolling 4 quarter average. And I would tell you, right now, that better is going to come from the spikes. When those spikes become the new norm, I think you'll start to see us settle into the 20s. But I wouldn't say that the 20s right now are the norm, I'd say our 16 is our rolling 4 quarter average.Pipeline is great. It's healthy as it's ever been. In fact, it's the strongest it's ever been, but we are again seeing those delays. We're seeing more scrutiny, more CFOs, CEOs. And frankly, we've seen a couple now where private equity owners and major shareholders at Board level are getting involved, particularly around capital decisions. So I expect continued volatility around bookings, but I think we've got a good healthy pipeline. I think for us, we've just got to stay diligent and honest about the quality of that pipeline. Because one of the things you will find in an economy like this is, you have customers that have the propensity to tell you, it's coming and then it just doesn't. This is where we're going to stay vigilant and make sure we look at the quality of that pipeline.Right now, we remain cautiously optimistic. Again, many of our service offerings present clients with cost savings opportunities, while advancing their digital transformation journeys. So again, one of the things we're coming through our pipeline looking at which of the initiatives and which of the opportunities actually represent cost savings for customers. We find those if they're in year, those move quicker to close. So again, a good start to the year, good signs in our pipeline, a good quarter of bookings. But I think the tale of the tape is going to be this next 2 quarters on how this year is going to shape up.So again, we've talked about this repeatedly. We've got 3 business units. They've got full leadership teams. Admittedly from an OpEx perspective, there could be some inefficiencies in running [ 3 BUs ]. We think we're getting great efficiencies from attention to detail, M&A opportunities and very specific product development initiatives that are coming from this. And we've also made them very accountable for their bottom line. So these BUs are incentivized to find synergies, to find shared resources amongst them in order to increase their delivered EBITDA back to the company. So we're seeing good operating dynamics between them. And each of these quarters, we're consistently producing EBITDA that's coming from this group operating well.We've got a couple of really good deals that have landed, that are cross business unit. This really is the definition of the future of frictionless commerce. It's not so much a BU-based approach, but more of an industry vertical approach where customers are buying a complete solution. We've had a couple now that are closed and working through, and we've got a few more very large ones in the pipeline where we're being asked to look at the entire ecosystem all at once. And again, that really bears fruit when these 3 business units behave as one with our customers.We did introduce the CaaS offering, which is Commerce as a Service, which is timely right now. We are finding that customers are looking at the potential to take project plus integrating a number of different service providers and turning that into a monthly recurring as a great way to convert capital-intensive projects to a more spread out and a longer cycle for them, which manages to their budget needs right now. So again, CAS is getting some good traction. We're getting great conversations with customers on it.Data management continues to be a clear strength. If anybody watches our social media, we had an amazing couple of weeks recently at a number of our partner conferences, winning awards with Stibo and Informatica being on stage and being able to present some of our product innovation, which is going over really well. We were really fortunate in a number of customers got on stage with us, including Psycho Bunny, Grainger, ABC Supply, all great brands and demonstrating the power of our DIVE machine learning platform.Generative AI, it's an extremely exciting technology, and I hesitate because it feels like the entire planet is now talking about Generative AI and ChatGPT in particular. What I'll tell you is we've practically applied it already now. It's in our workflows. We are using it for customer cases, and we are finding great synergies with our other machine learning. I think the difference between us and maybe some of the other people who were talking about it, we've been talking to you and our customers about machine learning and its practical application in our workflows for a couple of years now. So this is just another tool to us, and it's a tool that's synergistic with our existing tool set and our existing workflow, and we're seeing immediate efficiencies. So we're actually really excited about the potential to work that into more of our workflows. We also have a team that knows how to use it, and I think that's another important factor.This is foundational. I mean, if you look at the kind of work and the automation and the amount of time savings, quality improvement and just overall acceleration, this is going to be game changing and certainly in the data industry. And I think really all that's happening right now is while we talked about it, it was hard to explain it or demonstrate it, things like ChatGPT are just making it more accessible to the common person to see what its potential is. But I think our technology providers and our business solution providers have been using tools that aren't dissimilar and getting these kind of efficiency gains, I think the whole world sees it now and wants to take advantage of it.In supply chain, we're seeing really strong interest with our WMS. So this is our warehouse management system and our control tower. We've completed 16 of the micro services and there's another 7 coming online this year. So that product is getting really close to being fully complete. But the component parts are all sellable and we've had a number of customers now start to pilot it, along with the legacy customers, I think we've talked about this in the past. We're already running about 500 warehouses for customers. It's the new systems that we're getting more excited about the -- again, the efficiencies that they can enable.We're actually going to be hosting Product Day on May 23. We're excited to be sharing more of the developments in our IP across all of our business units and some of the interesting work we're doing with AI. So we're -- again, we're continuing to improve the way we talk about and we're really trying to shift away from tell about our products to actually be able to show them and demonstrate them and I'm excited about the progress we've made since we did the same thing last year.So overall, a great quarter. Really excited about what the team is doing on product and just cautiously optimistic I think anybody that is overly optimistic in the face of this economy would be naive. So we're trying to balance our enthusiasm and our optimism with what we think is going to be a little bit of turbulence over the next 3 quarters.With that, I will -- you know what, I'll spend 1 minute on EBITDA. I think this is one last important topic because we've talked about this for a year. We produced our first solid quarter in Q1 and in sort of Q4 and now we're doing it again in Q1. So from a capital allocation, from the work we've done over the last couple of years, you know we've added great businesses. We've done M&A well. That's converted into good revenue growth. And most importantly, that's got business units that are all contributing EBITDA. And you can kind of see the pattern, right? We bought them, we integrated them, and now we're focused on more profitability.We're going to continue to maintain our discipline around M&A because we've seen what we can do with companies to produce EBITDA. We're being really cautious about acquiring anything that would be a drag on EBITDA. And so part of the challenge in this kind of economy as well with lower valuations. If you're producing cash, you're not in a rush to sell, that's about trying to find the right balance, finding good companies either close to cash flow positive or cash flow positive that we think under our guidance can shift and start contributing to what is our growing bottom line.So I think we've positioned ourselves well for organic growth. We've got cash on the balance sheet that will allow us to buy with the EBITDA. We've also created that, again, confidence if we need to tap into our credit line, we will, but again, only for EBITDA positive or very soon to be EBITDA-positive businesses. And I think this chart really demonstrates what we've been able to do over the last couple of years.So for us, it's about creating long-term shareholder value, be managing those KPIs to consistently grow this and continue to improve our gross margins and not take on undue risk. I think this year is about the year of who blinks first. We're not going to be the ones to blink. I think we're in a great spot. We're going to do our best to take advantage of this year. Despite all the challenges, I think those challenges are going to represent opportunities for us.So I'll pass it over to Mo.
Great. Thanks, Bill. So first quarter of 2023 revenue was seasonally down from Q4 as we expected, and we had communicated in our previous call. But the impact wasn't as pronounced. We were able to offset the seasonal impact we expected by extending some of that spend to get part of the quarter. Professional services revenue declined by 4.3% year-over-year for the reasons that Bill mentioned in relation to bookings and conversion of our pipeline, which has taken in kind of form of longer cycles now.So although we're seeing some of the project revenue come to an end, we are seeing our managed services continue to extend and expand overall across our existing and new customers, which contributed to the 12% year-on-year growth. Oracle churn was less apparent in our numbers, and in some cases, continues to extend its light. That's contributed positively to our results. There were some customers coming off legacy platforms, but it was more than offset by some of the growth we're able to deliver and in managed services.Net revenue retention was 95% and greater stability in this metric is again a reflection of less legacy revenue churn and improved stability and growth we are seeing on the managed service revenue line.Moving to the next slide Bill. So on to the P&L, gross profit margins improved to 46.3% from last year's 42.6%. Managed service growth was 53% and up from 52% in the most recent quarter. So improvements on our margin across quarter-over-quarter and year-on-year on our overall business. Professional services gross profit margin was 41% versus 40% in the most recent quarter. We tracked much higher than other PS based businesses. A key factor in our gross margin to provide room for further upside is our investment in [Technical Difficulty] capacity and also the use of the Pivotree IP to further drive down the dependency on labor.Over 20% of our data projects are leveraging Pivotree IP, including those that you've heard of DIVE, Natalie Control Tower. As we continue to leverage more of our automated products and tools and manage the utilization rate and investment in bench, we see a path to improving gross margins to 50% and beyond.Our operating expense was at $12.8 million, similar to that of the most recent fourth quarter of 2022, and we plan on continuing to manage our OpEx to drive our commitment to positive EBITDA trajectory. Adjusted EBITDA was $0.8 million, improved by 270 basis points from prior year and grew more than 300%. Our adjusted free cash flow was positive $300,000 and our net loss improved by $1.9 million year-on-year.Moving on to the balance sheet and cash. The primary use of cash in Q1 was related to the working capital changes that are seasonal in nature and came in better than typical through the first quarter of the year. We had better working capital results as certain payments shifted to the second quarter for comparison. Typically, in Q1, we see a $4 million negative working capital impact, and we saw an improved $1.5 million in Q1. So with the positive EBITDA and operating cash flow improvements that you've seen, we ended the quarter with $15.8 million in cash, and we have not tapped into our $25 million credit facility.So as Bill mentioned, with the improved cash flow performance and continued focus to optimize it, we are now more than inclined to leverage our credit facility if the right asset becomes available, providing us with over $40 million of total capital available. We think our patients will continue to pay off as we pick up transformational assets like we did in 2021 and deliver compelling results of an accretion to the bottom line.I'm going to turn it back to Bill now for a closing summary.
Thanks, Mo. We had a couple of questions come in, and I don't know whether it's appropriate for me to answer, maybe I'll ask our analysts to chime in on it. But both the questions that came in were about our share price. And I'm going to avoid temptation to comment on share price because again, I can't tell you why the market does what they do. I think oversimplification is supply and demand. And if there's not enough demand, your share price doesn't go up. And if there's too much supply, your share price goes down. It's that simple.Why isn't there more demand? Why is there too much supply? That I can't answer the question for you. I think your analysts could probably give you some perspective. Being intellectually honest, I believe in this economy, in this market being a small cap, not highly profitable business or microcap to many means you're not getting a lot of attention. And so we're going to just keep our heads down, keep running the business. We believe we're creating value, and we think that value is going to manifest over the coming years.Economies will change. Demand will change as people want to put more capital to work. And so I think the market will eventually look after itself, but I don't know that anyone can give you a definitive answer why stock prices do what they do. I think they can give you directional answers. We need to be bigger. We need to be more profitable for this market to care about us. And that seems to be a lot of the message that I get from the analysts that we work with.And frankly, we're not going to let our stock price dictate how we run the business. We believe we're building a great business. We believe we have an opportunity to own the space around frictionless commerce, which we think is going to be enormous. That's what we're focused on. And the stock price will do what it does on our way to becoming a North American and world leader. So from my perspective, it's about [ patience ]. But again, I'd invite our analysts, if you care to give some of the folks on the call, some of your perspective, please feel free to opine, you see a lot more companies than I analyze on a daily basis.So let's just bring it home to thank Mo, first of all, because a lot of the benefit we're getting around our operating discipline, the improvements in EBITDA, that's Mo and his team and the General Manager. So again, thanks, Mo, for the relentless work on finding efficiencies, driving up our utilizations and delivering on our commitments to be EBITDA positive.To reiterate a bit of what he said, we entered the year with some good bookings. We entered the year with a path to profitable growth, and we're executing on that. We've got a strong backlog in bookings and a highly qualified pipeline, and we continue to add bookings at a healthy rate in a challenging environment. And I think that's really a testament to the critical role we play in our customers' revenue-generating operations. We're really excited about the progress in each of the BUs. I'm really excited about the products by seeing them in action and actually fully appreciating what they're capable of doing for our customers.And again, I believe our foundation in data, and I've been saying this for the better part of 2 years, data and automation alongside some of these accelerated advancements in AI. It's making it an incredibly exciting time to be positioned as a trusted partner in some of the world's leading B2C and B2B organizations who share our vision for frictionless commerce. So we look forward to sharing more on the exciting developments we have on product front over the coming quarters. And ultimately, the real test is when those things start showing up with expanded MRR bookings and expanded MRR overall. So I'm looking forward to the day when we show you rather than tell you.With that, I'll turn it over to our analysts for questions.
[Operator Instructions] The first question comes from Rob Young at Canaccord Genuity.
Okay. Now that I figured that out, sorry. Okay. It's been a short time since last update. So I mean, what -- is there 1 or 2 things that, I mean, you'd highlight as the biggest difference from the last update, just listen to your comments, I guess maybe a little more caution on the macro. You're saying there might be some turbulence manifests in I think maybe the pipeline or bookings? Is that the right way to think about it?
I think the pipeline -- and we had a good conversation with our board. We've got lots of experience around the boardroom who -- not to say they're old, but they've lived through some of these types of economies before and they've seen the playbook. So we've talked about pipeline. And I think pipeline, we got to be careful with. The pipeline can get misleading. When your bookings are getting delayed or pushed inevitably, your pipeline grows because people aren't taking things out of the pipeline. They're not saying no, it's just the delays in getting signatures. If those delays kick on too long, and I think one of the things we're paying really close attention to, how long are they living in the pipeline? What's the sales cycle turning into? What's the average day? We're not reporting that yet, but we're paying attention to it. I think that's the real test of it, this is a good high-quality pipeline.Right now, the indications are yes. So we believe the bookings are just slow rolling and delayed, but that will be the test. If they're sticking in the pipeline too long, then I think we'll probably have to remeasure them. It's a bit like AR, right? Like if you get into 90 and 120 days, you start worrying about collectibility, I think if you're getting into 9 and 12 months, you should start wondering whether that deal is ever going to get closed. We don't have that right now. I think that's the risk this year.
Okay. So, no cancellations. That's good to hear.
No.
Last quarter, you were talking about new [indiscernible] activity. Maybe give us a little bit of an update there. Are you still seeing the top of funnel and notwithstanding your comments about some of the longer-duration pieces in the funnel, but how is the top of the funnel looking?
Yes. And again, I think it was a bit early in the year a month or 2 ago. If you'd asked me a month or 2 ago on the team, I think they were seeing some softness. But then all of our marketing activities kicked in, all these conferences started up and we were out in front of customers demonstrating our capabilities. And I think now at the top of funnel with new logos has started to pick up. And our partners are seeing us differently. And this is the other important change. We are being invited into conversations that aren't just about the implementation of a piece of software. It's about taking advantage of that software in a different way. The automation of the data pipeline that feeds that governance software as an example. So it's different kinds of conversations at the top of the pipeline as well, and that's hard to capture simple metrics
Okay, got it. The net retention, I think quarter-over-quarter, that declined a little bit. I'm trying to understand the moving parts there. Is that a delayed shift of a delayed churn? Or is that maybe a slowdown in expansion? Like maybe just help me through the part, the pieces there.
Yes. Rob, a good portion of that was legacy hosting only not even part of any of our specific BUs that we had in the prior [indiscernible] day. So, I'd say Oracle wasn't as prominent in that metric for us this, it was more of the legacy hosting and general managed services that we had, again, infrastructure hosting services prior to the acquisitions and prior to even Pivotree existing.
Okay. And then last question for me just on gross margins, the path going forward. I'd like to see the expansion, congrats on that. The drivers going forward, I mean, I've always thought of this as mix of managed services and the growth in the quarter was great there. And then the IP mix as well. Maybe just give us a reminder on where the margins are likely to go? And what are the drivers? And then I'll pass the line to someone else.
Yes. I'm excited with what the team's doing around margins. I think some of it around our existing how we price for outcomes rather than just selling the labor. I think that's shifting. And I'm expecting there's opportunity -- upwards opportunity [indiscernible] the statement last earnings that we see a path to 50%. I mean, we're investing in a bench, and we're doing it because our pipeline is still holding strong. It's still holding at record levels for us that getting right debentures in the right [indiscernible] right decision for us. So I think some of it will tell in the next coming quarters to turn that into return, make that turn out to revenue and the margin efficiencies using our tools and solutions will continue to provide upwards on the managed services side. So I'm optimistic, and I see [Technical Difficulty] working pretty hard with real levers for us to improve those metrics.
Our next question is from Daniel Rosenberg from Paradigm Capital.
My first question was around the pipeline and some of the -- you mentioned delays in signing orders. I was curious if there was anything to say in terms of enterprise clients versus some of the larger, let's say, mid-market. Is there any discerning [ difference ] that you see between the markets?
Interesting question because I've got one in mind in particular that the direct client we're dealing with, you would probably [Technical Difficulty] a mid-market client, but their own -- there's a parent organization that really is probably more large enterprise, and it's owned by a major capital firm sitting on top of it. So is it really mid-market, it's got disciplines now that look more like large enterprise. It's a mid-market [ buyer ] but it's a capital outlay that's big by its standard. So it's getting escalated through large enterprise-type procurement.And I would say on all of the big ones. And when we talk about big ones, like we are talking about substantial contracts, now multimillion-dollar contracts, most of those are living in very large enterprise. And most of those then come with much more complex procurement, including you sign a contract and then they still kick off processes to get those things moving. So they're more complicated, they take a bit longer, but you're not renegotiating those things or you're not setting up new projects every 90 or 120 days. Once it's landed, you now have that capacity to move. So even the big ones we've signed have been slow rolling on just the nature of the kind of large enterprise.That's the one thing I think you're going to see different with us is the bigger the companies, the bigger the first projects, the slower it takes to get moving.
And then I had a follow-up on the net retention revenue. I was wondering if there was anything to say if we were to dig down deeper versus some of the newer micro services that you're launching in terms of how the spending habits are trending from a retention type point of view? I know it's early days in some of these products, but anything to say about more of the digital offerings versus some of the legacy offerings.
I think Mo probably has the best visibility into that.
Yes. No. I mean if I look at our existing customers, I mean, the ones that are contributing to expand for us are those that sign up for the outcomes and as their business grows, continue to sign a sub for additional outcome. So it's never a -- we don't have a pay per transaction type model, but we do have -- it is driven by volume and activity. So as we continue to drive efficiency improvements, especially some of our newer offerings, they continue to see the business value and the value prop and us doing it through running through our process, through our technology. They're starting to realize that there's more that they could shift towards that model and continue benefits that they can focus on there. So that's a real lever for us.I mean, you've heard kind of the data story, the [indiscernible] story, putting them through our own technology products. They continue to get to clients more exciting, especially as they continue to learn how efficient that could be versus the current approach that they're applying. Outcome base seems to have triggered some positive discussion and momentum where they don't have to worry around the variability and they're really going to tie it to their business success and growth.
Okay. My last question before passing the line was just around the seasonality. So you obviously go through it at the top of the year, but can you just remind us of the cadence or say, in a normal year, putting aside the macro environment. How does that generally flush out for the balance?
On the seasonality piece, I'd say that Q1 was -- didn't see the hit that we expected. So it was actually Q1 was better than expected. So I think we explained on the last call, Q4 to Q1, typically, we see somewhere between USD700,000 and USD900,000 reduction as I think we shared on the last call. And that didn't materialize in Q1 as customers continue to keep their volumes and levels of services that we've been running in peak season. So that's some -- that has a bit of a delayed impact for us, but we benefit from what we typically see Q4 to Q1.
And then just looking forward, is there -- could you just remind us on how that's aside from macro and being conservative, but typically in a normalized year, do you see any of those changes other than Q4 to Q1. That's really the main seasonality.
And that's the most material one, Q4 to Q1 from a managed services perspective, professional services does hit some capacity in holiday slowdown typically without to your [indiscernible] outside outlier events. So I think there's the offset managed service goes up Q4. Professional services could potentially come down unless we augment with additional labor and capacity.
Seeing one of our analysts wanted to rise to the challenge of explaining stock price, so I guess we'll let [indiscernible].
Bill, I don't see any more questions, so I'll turn it back to you.
That's great. Yes, look, we really were just here 60 days ago. I don't think things changed dramatically in 60 days. I think we've been consistent in what we've been signaling. And again, I think a real credit to the operators in the organization, they're doing what they promised, they were going to do and they're going to keep doing it. And again, I think I sense a high degree of optimism from our Board all the way down. I just got back from India from our people working on these things. They're excited about the products that are getting built. I think everyone has to recognize transforming from a professional services and managed services company to a product company, comes with some challenges, right?You changed the booking profiles and the revenue consumption profiles, but those are all positive things. If we get our folks, our customers buying these products, our margins go up, our efficiencies go up, and I think we become much more meaningful to our customers over our longer term. So we're excited about the transformation we're going through and I think the early signals are finally starting to bear out in the metrics.So yes, stay tuned. We've got a few more quarters of this. I'm excited to see how this year unfolds. Thanks, everyone, for attending today, and we'll see you in what, 90 days now.
90 days. Bye, everyone.
Thanks, everyone.