Elastic NV

NYSE:ESTC

Earnings Call Transcript 2023-Q2

[Operator]

Good day and welcome to the Elastic Second Quarter Fiscal 2023 Earnings Results Conference Call. [Operator Instructions] Please note that this event is being recorded. I would now like to turn the conference over to Mr. Nikolay Beliov, Vice President of Investor Relations. Please go ahead, sir.

[Nikolay Beliov, Vice President, Investor Relations]

Thank you. Good afternoon and thank you for joining us on today’s conference call to discuss Elastic’s second quarter fiscal 2023 financial results. On the call, we have Ash Kulkarni, Chief Executive Officer; and Janesh Moorjani, Chief Financial Officer and Chief Operating Officer. Following the prepared remarks, we will take questions. Our press release was issued today after the close of market and is posted on our website. Slides which accompany this webcast can be viewed in conjunction with live remarks and can also be downloaded at the conclusion of the webcast on the Elastic Investor Relations website, ir.elastic.co.

Our discussion will include forward-looking statements, which may include predictions, estimates, our expectations regarding the demand for our products and solutions and our future revenue and other information. These forward-looking statements are based on factors currently known to us, speak only as of the date of this call and are subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially. We disclaim any obligation to update or revise these forward-looking statements unless required by law.

Please refer to the risks and uncertainties included in the press release that we issued earlier today, included in the slides accompanying in this webcast and those more fully described in our filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission. We will also discuss certain non-GAAP financial measures. Disclosures regarding non-GAAP measures, including reconciliations with the most comparable GAAP measures can be found in the press release and slides. The webcast replay of this call will be available for the next 60 days on our company website under the Investor Relations link. Our third quarter fiscal 2023 quiet period begins at the close of business on Friday, January 13, 2023. On December 8, 2022, we will be participating in the Barclays Global Technology, Media and Telecommunications Conference.

With that, I will turn it over to Ash.

[Ash Kulkarni, Chief Executive Officer]

Thank you, Nikolay and thank you all for joining us. In Q2, revenue grew 34% year-over-year in constant currency. Elastic Cloud comprised 39% of total revenue, up from 34% in the year ago quarter and grew 52% year-over-year in constant currency. We ended the quarter with approximately 19,700 subscription customers, including over 1,050 with annual contract values of more than $100,000. I have continued confidence in our long-term market opportunity and the core fundamental strengths of our business.

During the quarter, we continued to make progress across our three key focus areas: driving durable growth, widening our competitive moat and continuing our focus on profitable growth. We also saw customers continue to show a preference for consolidation onto our platform for multiple use cases. While our differentiated platform positions us well, we have also started to experience the shift in the macroeconomic climate ourselves.

In the month of October, we began to see belt tightening and consumption slowing down in the SMB segment. We also saw increased scrutiny on deals overall, particularly in countries where the strengthening U.S. dollar has created adverse conditions. In order to help our customers through this clearly difficult environment, it is more important for us than ever before to stay close to them and help them realize the value of consolidating onto a single platform for multiple business critical use cases. That also requires us to be more focused on our coverage, our sales place, our product investments and our internal support as we drive greater operational excellence.

Looking ahead, we intend to be even more focused on those areas of our business where we see the opportunity for continued profitable growth, optimize investment in other areas and drive overall profitability in the business even faster. In challenging times, those who adapt the fastest are those who end up ahead. Towards this end, we have made the very difficult decision to reduce our workforce by 13% and to align our investments with our strategic priorities and position us for long-term success. We made this announcement earlier today within the company. This was not an easy decision and we are taking the right steps to help impacted employees and their families. We owe our success to all of them and are profoundly grateful for their hard work and contributions to Elastic.

With this decision, we are rebalancing investments across all functions in the company and we will reinvest some of the savings selectively in areas that best position us to drive profitable growth. As an example, in sales and marketing, we are going to double down on our automated low-touch approach to better address the needs of our SMB customers who generally prefer a self-service motion. This will also allow us to reposition a portion of these investments to thoughtfully increase our coverage in the Enterprise segment. In products, we will emphasize strategic areas like cloud and serverless in our future technical hiring. These actions set us on a path to deliver improved non-GAAP operating income growth in the second half of FY ‘23 and 10% non-GAAP operating margins for FY ‘24, a significant increase compared to our prior commitment. Janesh will share more details later.

Now, let me talk about the long-term durability of our growth. Over the last 90 days, I have met with more than 100 customers, including Canvas, SAP Concur, USAA, Ecolab, Westpac, Standard Chartered Bank and O2 Telefonica. We are also meeting with customers at our ElasticON events, which are driving greater awareness, fueling pipeline and reinforcing our bottom-up adoption and product-led growth. Demand for our in-person events has been strong with standing room-only crowds attending our ElasticON events in Singapore, New York and Amsterdam to hear from Elastic and some of our amazing customers, including a firm AutoZone, BMW, Booking.com, Comcast and SWIFT.

We are seeing from our customer interactions that they are continuing to invest in observability, security and search. And our platform strategy is working. Especially in the areas of observability and security, we offer an open, high-performance platform that allows customers to analyze all their data across logs, application traces, metrics and other related data with a simple consumption-based pricing model, all at a price that creates a compelling value proposition to switch from other technologies and consolidate onto our platform.

And with Elastic Cloud, expanding with Elastic to newer use cases is incredibly easy. In these times, we see a greater opportunity than ever before to lean into our platform and cost advantage and drive consolidation place onto our platform. This quarter, we expanded business with RRD, a leading global provider of marketing, packaging, print and supply chain solutions, a long-time Elastic Enterprise Search customer, they recently expanded to Elastic Observability on Elastic Cloud to consolidate multiple applications into a single cloud instance and streamline their infrastructure.

We also expanded business with a 7-figure deal this quarter with the top U.S. based global heavy equipment manufacturer. Previously, an OpenSearch customer, the company consolidated its logging platform with Elastic Observability on Elastic Cloud to improve service availability and customer satisfaction. What excites me the most is that we partnered with AWS on this deal through the AWS Marketplace, which demonstrates a strengthening partnership.

Speaking of cloud partnerships, we continued to build momentum with AWS, Microsoft Azure and Google Cloud. Our revenue through the cloud hyperscaler marketplaces again more than doubled year-over-year. With AWS, we announced a new streamlined experience for Elastic Cloud on the AWS Marketplace. This enables joint customers to get started on Elastic Cloud with an easier sign-up and setup experience through the AWS Marketplace console. Also, Elastic was a key partner for Microsoft Azure’s launch of the latest Azure Virtual Machines with Ampere Altra ARM-based processors, letting customers maximize operational efficiency across their observability, security and search use cases. Finally, we announced an expanded partnership with Google Cloud to make it easier for customers to monitor and secure Google Cloud workloads and drive insights from data that resides in data lakes on Google Cloud.

Now, onto our continuing product innovations and our widening competitive moat, in the current environment, we see a real opportunity to help our customers drive consolidation onto our platform and reduce their overall costs. At our ElasticON events, we recently announced a series of innovations to our platform. These include more optimized support for metrics data in Elastic Search, which will enable us to further extend our competitive advantage in metrics and enable customers to more easily consolidate onto Elastic for all their observability needs. This is available in technical preview to-date.

We also announced a new query language, ESQL, which will enable us to support richer query semantics and additional use cases across all of our solutions and will also enable us to make it easier for customers to migrate to our platform from competing offerings. We anticipate ESQL becoming available on our platform later next year. Lastly, we unveiled a roadmap for a new serverless cloud product, which will broaden our addressable market. This new offering will provide a fully managed experience for supporting short duration or bursty workloads and will be a great complement to our current Elastic Cloud service, which is optimized for control, flexibility and performance for long running workloads.

Now, I will share some details about additional innovations and customer wins across our Security, Observability and Enterprise Search solutions. Starting with Security, this quarter, we renewed and expanded cloud business with Uber. They have been using Elastic for threat hunting, investigation and response and recently expanded their use of Elastic SIEM to power their entire enterprise defense platform. Elastic Security is integral to their ongoing security journey. It provides critical capabilities that enable their team to correlate behaviors across data sources, build interfaces for examining security logs and craft detection logic to surface malicious behaviors.

We also expanded business with the U.S. Federal Agency that previously deployed the free and open version of Elastic. They are now using Elastic SIEM on Elastic Cloud for visibility across their security environment, focusing on insider threat analytics. More than 20% of our security customers now use our newer use cases in XDR and cloud security, validating our unified security approach for the modern security operations center.

We already have over 30 customers using CIS benchmark-based cloud security posture management for Kubernetes, our newest use case, which just recently became generally available. Over the last two quarters, we have released several new capabilities in our next-gen SIEM, including threat intelligence management, hybrid sort and host and user entity analytics. In addition to this, we also recently released the first Elastic Global Threat Report, which details the evolving nature of cybersecurity threats. Compiled using customer telemetry data, the report showcased the first-party research conducted by our security research teams and provided unique insights to our customers. Last month, Elastic Security was named a visionary in the 2022 Gartner Magic Quadrant for SIEM. And I am excited to share that Elastic was honored with the Cybersecurity Breakthrough Award for Threat Intelligence Platform of the Year in recognition of the cutting-edge threat intelligence capabilities of Elastic Security.

Now moving on to Elastic Observability, this quarter, we expanded an 8-figure multiyear piece of business with a Global 2000 multinational financial services company, which uses Elastic Observability and Elastic Security. The company relies on Elastic Observability for distributed tracing to enable the migration of thousands of applications from the company’s data centers to Microsoft Azure and Google Cloud and uses Elastic Security to significantly reduce the time spent on threat hunting.

We also expanded business this quarter with one of the world’s leading media and entertainment companies, which has been using Elastic Observability to monitor IT operations at one U.S. theme park location and have now expanded to include two additional park locations in the U.S. and APJ. With Elastic, they can ensure the consistent uptime of critical park functions such as WiFi, point-of-sale systems and virtual lines to provide the best visitor experience possible.

APM traction in the Elastic Observability solution continues to gain strength. 30% of our Observability clusters are using APM in addition to log analytics and we continue to see competitive wins as customers seek to consolidate tools. In Q2, we added additional capabilities to our beta synthetic monitoring capability and have seen almost 4x growth in synthetic test runs. In general, the open telemetry protocol and open standards are an Elastic strength. And in Q2, we saw 44% growth in Elastic clusters ingesting APM data using the open telemetry protocol. We also recently launched the private beta of Universal Profiling, an innovative performance optimization and cost saving capability. Universal Profiling is lightweight and requires zero instrumentation, overcoming the limitations of other profiling solutions by requiring no changes to the application code.

In Enterprise Search, we renewed a 7-figure multiyear deal this quarter with a multinational aerospace company. They use Elastic Enterprise Search to provide customers with real-time digital access to the documentation needed to ensure proper aircraft maintenance within their fleet and reduce time on the ground due to maintenance delays. We also renewed business this quarter with the U.S. government agency. They are using Elastic Enterprise Search to help their vaccine approval center rapidly access and evaluate mission-critical data to expedite the submission and approval of new vaccines and monitor adverse event reporting for existing vaccines in partnership with the CDC.

On the innovation front, we recently announced the general availability of vector search as well as updates to improve search relevance through hybrid scoring that combines traditional search with vector search to deliver more accurate and relevant search results. We have seen an 84% increase and deployments actively running a machine learning model in the last quarter, indicating wider adoption of our natural language processing capabilities. Our product strategy in this area is centered around making complex search functionality accessible and scalable across use cases and segments.

Now moving on to our focus on profitable growth, I am proud of the team and the fact that we exceeded both our revenue and our profitability targets for Q2. Our Q2 operating margin of 1.9% was significantly better than our guidance and clearly demonstrates the operating leverage inherent in our business. I have already talked about the steps we have taken to accelerate our profitability growth. Although these decisions are difficult ones to make, we are confident that the changes we have announced will drive even more focus on those areas of our business that have the highest opportunity for growth and operating margin expansion. This will enable us to navigate through this macroeconomic environment with greater discipline and ensure our success in both the near and long-term.

In summary, I want to thank our employees for their dedication and contribution to our performance. I also want to thank our customers, partners and investors for their continued support and confidence. We continue to have confidence in our ability to build a generational company given: one, our market opportunity; two, the criticality of our solutions to our customers; third, our platform strategy, which is more relevant than ever before, giving customers increased desire for tool consolidation in the current environment; fourth, the execution by our team; and finally, our strong fundamentals.

Now, over to Janesh.

[Janesh Moorjani]

Thanks, Ash. We are pleased that we delivered ahead of our commitments for Q2. We delivered 34% year-over-year constant currency growth in total revenue. We continued our momentum in Elastic Cloud, which grew 52% year-over-year in constant currency. We once again beat the high-end of both our top line and bottom line guidance for the quarter despite the current economic environment and despite greater FX headwinds on revenue than we had included in our previous guidance.

On a currency-neutral basis, our total revenue beat in terms of year-over-year growth in Q2 was similar to Q1. In the current business climate and with the trends in our business that Ash described, we see room to focus more sharply on helping our customers derive the benefits of tool consolidation onto a single platform and also to realign resources internally to drive greater efficiencies in all functions. Accordingly, we are taking specific actions in the business.

First, we are better focusing our investments to optimize our coverage in the SMB segment, emphasizing automation and low-touch approaches to better address the needs of customers in that segment while repurposing some of that investment towards enterprise sales coverage. Second, we are rebalancing investments across other functions to invest in priorities such as our serverless architecture and engineering and in digital demand gen and marketing. We will also drive greater efficiencies and align to business priorities in our customer success and G&A functions. Third, we are adopting a specific goal of non-GAAP operating margin at 10% for fiscal ‘24 and the actions announced today already put us on the path to achieving that. We believe these actions will not only help profitability in the near-term, but importantly, allow us to align our team to best capture the market opportunity ahead of us.

While we navigate the near-term, we remain confident in our strategy for the mid and long-term. We have a large market opportunity and our solutions are used in core mission-critical use cases. Customers are increasingly looking for tool consolidation in the current environment, which plays well to our platform strategy. We give customers enormous flexibility with a consumption-based business model and resource-based pricing model. And our core land and expand motion continues. We had healthy additions to the pool of customers over $10,000 in ACV, adding approximately 80 customers in this category and also the pool of customers over $100,000 in ACV, adding approximately 40 customers in this category, both consistent with the prior quarter and we continue to have a world class net expansion rate.

Now let’s get into Q2 results and our updated outlook. Total revenue in the second quarter was $264.4 million, up 28% year-over-year or 34% in constant currency. Subscription revenue in the second quarter totaled $241.2 million, up 27% year-over-year or 32% in constant currency, comprising 91% of total revenue. Within subscriptions, revenue from Elastic Cloud was healthy at $103.2 million, growing 50% year-over-year or 52% in constant currency. Elastic Cloud represented 39% of total revenue in the quarter, up from 34% a year ago and also represented 43% of total subscription revenue, up from 42% in the prior quarter and up from 36% in the year ago quarter.

Professional services revenue in the second quarter was $23.2 million, growing 47% year-over-year or 53% in constant currency. We do not expect professional services to increase significantly in mix. To add more context around deal flow and performance by region, although we saw a balanced deal flow across geographies on a currency-adjusted basis, the Americas grew faster than APAC and EMEA given currency impacts in those regions.

Looking at customer metrics, we ended the second quarter with approximately 19,700 total subscription customers with the vast majority of the additions in the quarter once again in Elastic Cloud. The lower sequential number of customer additions reflects the slowdown in the SMB segment that we described earlier. We are confident that our strategy of focusing on acquiring and nurturing customers that have a higher propensity for growth rather than solely focusing on quantity continues to be the right strategy for us. We once again provided data on customers over $10,000 ACV, and you’ll see the additions in Q2 in that category were similar to prior quarters.

We also saw the success of this strategy reflected in the account of larger customers. We had over 1,050 customers with annual contract values over $100,000 at the end of the second quarter compared to over 1,010 such customers at the end of the prior quarter reflecting the strength of our product portfolio and our ability to drive expansion across the solutions. The customer account in this category remains a strong underpinning of our land and expand motion. Our overall net expansion rate in the first quarter was approximately 125% and was down slightly, reflecting the trends I mentioned earlier.

Now turning to profitability for which I’ll discuss non-GAAP measures. Gross margin in the quarter was 74.5%, with the sequential change versus the prior quarter, driven mainly by better professional services gross margins. Subscription gross margin at 79.2% was consistent with the prior quarter. Looking at operating expenses in the second quarter, we continue to manage our expenses and investments in the business well. Our operating margin in the quarter was 1.9%, which was significantly better than expected due to both the revenue performance in the quarter and tight expense discipline. This once again demonstrates the operating leverage inherent in our business model. Earnings per share in the second quarter, was $0.0. Free cash flow on an adjusted basis was $10.3 million in the second quarter. For full fiscal ‘23, we now expect to be roughly breakeven on adjusted free cash flow.

This outlook includes cash outflows of between $25 million and $28 million related to the restructuring we announced, which reflect onetime payments and were not included in our prior outlook. We also continue to maintain a strong balance sheet. We ended the second quarter with cash and cash equivalents of approximately $856 million. We remain comfortable with our cash position from an operating perspective. Before discussing our outlook for the third quarter and the remainder of fiscal ‘23, I’d like to provide additional color on how we will be approaching the next few quarters.

As we announced, we will be reducing our workforce by 13% and rebalancing our investments across functions, reinvesting a portion of that into areas best suited to drive growth. We will continue to hire for the right roles in the second half of fiscal ‘23 to ensure we are set up successfully for fiscal ‘24 and beyond. While the decision to reduce and rebalance investments was not easy to make, we believe it positions us better for the future to deliver multiyear durable and profitable growth.

It also allows us to deliver faster margin expansion than we had previously committed, and we currently expect to deliver 10% non-GAAP operating margin and a commensurated increase in adjusted free cash flow margin in fiscal ‘24. We also remain confident in our ability to deliver healthy revenue growth given our market opportunity, the strength of our products, new customer trends and our expansion track record. We also continue to expect Elastic Cloud will exceed 50% of total revenue in the fourth quarter of fiscal 2024.

Turning to guidance, with the continued strength of the U.S. dollar against the year ago rates, we expect currency movements to present a headwind to year-over-year total revenue growth of approximately 4% for the third quarter and approximately 4% for full fiscal ‘23. With respect to operating margin, since we also incurred a significant portion of our expenses in currencies other than the U.S. dollar, we effectively have a natural hedge, so the impact to operating margin from a strengthening dollar is less significant.

Our overall guidance philosophy stays unchanged. We continue to guide thoughtfully based on what we know and without excessive conservatism. We have now considered the impact of the current business climate in our second half revenue outlook. Despite this impact, we are raising our operating margin outlook for the year, reflecting our emphasis on full growth. With that background, for the third quarter of fiscal ‘23, we expect total revenue in the range of $272 million to $274 million, representing 22% year-over-year growth at the midpoint.

On a constant currency basis, we expect total revenue growth of 26% year-over-year at the midpoint. We expect non-GAAP operating margin in the range of 4.3% to 4.7% and non-GAAP earnings per share in the range of $0.04 to $0.07 using between 98.5 million and 99.5 million diluted ordinary shares outstanding. For full fiscal ‘23, we now expect total revenue in the range of $1.67 billion to $1.73 billion, representing 24% year-over-year growth at the midpoint. On a constant currency basis, we expect total revenue growth of 28% year-over-year at the midpoint.

We expect non-GAAP operating margin for full fiscal ‘23 in the range of 2.2% to 2.6% and non-GAAP earnings per share in the range of negative $0.03 to positive $0.03 using between 95 million and 97 million basic weighted average ordinary shares outstanding and between 98.5 million and 100.5 million diluted weighted average ordinary shares outstanding.

In summary, we remain focused on execution and believe that we are well positioned for long-term durable growth and profitability. And with that, let’s go ahead and take questions. Operator?

[Operator]

[Operator Instructions] And the first question will come from Tyler Radke with Citi. Please go ahead.

[Tyler Radke, Citi]

Hi, thanks for taking the question. So I think given that you just had an Analyst Day and put out some long-term targets, I think investors are keen to kind of hear the magnitude of what’s changed in the last couple of months. So maybe if you could just talk about where you’re seeing the slowdown by use case, whether it’s Search versus Security, Observability? And then if you could kind of comment on the trends throughout the quarter and into November, have things worsened in November? And then I just wanted to clarify if you’re backing away from the targets or if you’re reaffirming those. Thank you.

[Ash Kulkarni, Chief Executive Officer]

Yes. Thanks for the question, Tyler. This is Ash here. Maybe I can kick things off and then invite Janesh to also add more to it. So just in terms of what we saw, as we talked in September during the Financial Analyst Day, we had been watching the macro environment very carefully, especially given that we had seen the FX headwinds. And through all of Q2, what we saw was in October things started to change and act differently than what we had seen prior to that. Specifically in SMB, we saw a lot of belt tightening, and we are seeing this in a couple of places, very obviously. First is in monthly cloud. Monthly cloud tends to be – a lot of it tends to be SMB. We saw consumption construction there. We also saw fewer SMB customers signing on to the platform. So that was one. The second thing that we saw in October, which is sort of the last month of our quarter, as you know, in certain international geographies where we had seen the dollar tightening having the dollar increase having a significant impact on just the way customers are thinking about things, we saw customers going through more approval processes. And these were deals where we continue to compete very well. Some of these deals slipped out from Q2 into Q3. Some of them have even closed since then. But we see that, that pattern of more approvals, and we expect that to continue going forward. So the assumptions that we’re making effectively are that SMB, what we saw in October is going to continue for some time. The pattern of deal inspection is going to continue for some time, but having said that, our competitive position remains very strong. We continue to do well in competitive environments. In terms of our win rates, they stayed healthy as they have been. And we had promised when we talked to you during the Financial Analyst Day that we are going to be watchful, and we are going to be thoughtful in terms of how we act based on the data that we see. And hopefully, you’ll see that that’s exactly what we’re doing here. We saw some impact and we saw behavioral changes in SMB, and we are taking actions to make sure that we change the way we operate based on some of those data points.

Your other question was in terms of use cases. We really didn’t see any difference in terms of the behaviors around use cases. It was more around segments. So the biggest impact was in the SMB segment where we saw belt tightening and lastly, around the $2 billion target. Look, what I’ll say is our goal hasn’t changed. The fundamental strength of our business remains strong. And we’ve always talked about the fact that we’re building a generational company. We’re building a multibillion-dollar company. $2 billion was always a milestone in that journey. Clearly, given the business environment that we are dealing with, we expect that, that’s going to be difficult, and it’s going to be harder. And we acknowledge that. So we are not reaffirming, but we are also not changing any of that guidance. We’re going to continue pushing forward. Like we said, fundamentally, we are not compromising on growth. We are just being far more focused based on the reality of the macro environment that we’re seeing, and we want to make sure that we are putting our investments where we believe we can get the best return.

[Janesh Moorjani]

Hey, Tyler, I’ll just add on because you had a question about how November has played out as well. I think Ash covered all the other points quite nicely actually. November has been steady so far. We have continued to see business play out as we expected. We’ve not seen any meaningful change in terms of customer tone in the month of November. So I think that we’ve reflected that obviously in the outlook here for the back half. So we feel pretty good about the number that we’ve called for the back half, and we’ve tried to incorporate all of these trends specifically into the guidance and suitably derisk the guidance for the back half to accommodate for these. So we feel good about the outlook for the back half and based on what we’ve seen in November so far.

[Tyler Radke, Citi]

Helpful. Thanks for all the detail. And just on the decision to do a force reduction here, I mean, obviously, we’ve seen the market kind of continue to prioritize profitability over growth. But I guess, why now? And I guess if you go into a little bit more detail the specific areas that you’re looking to make these changes and the confidence that this won’t necessarily be disruptive in terms of our growth aspirations? Thank you.

[Ash Kulkarni, Chief Executive Officer]

Yes. Thanks, Tyler. As you can imagine, these are very difficult decisions. And I’ll reiterate that we really could not be more thankful to our employees, everything that they do, their efforts. The – just everything that they put into Elastic and our success. Now having said that, like we had told you even during the Analyst Day we have been very carefully observing the data in the market, why now, because we have always made decisions based on data. And like we told you in September, we had not seen the impact of the macroeconomic environment affect our business other than the FX piece, which we had talked to you about then. But we wanted to be very watchful and that’s what we were doing. And once we started to see the impact, we were very careful about making sure that we understand the nature of that impact. And like I mentioned, the biggest area where we experienced this is in SMB. And in SMB, it was across the board. It was in all regions. It was across all use cases. And we’ve traditionally had a sales-assisted motion for SMB. And what that means is we would have customers land on monthly cloud and then we would have an SMB sales team that would spend energy in trying to convert those customers into annual contracts. And given the environment, what we have been seeing is really that, that effort that’s being spent on the SMB area is really not giving us commensurate returns.

And we are not expecting the SMB environment to change either in the near future. We expect that that’s going to be an area where there will be continued stress in the economy. On the other hand, we continue to see on the enterprise side, long-term opportunity for us to continue to do well. And so as we’ve taken these actions on the go-to-market side, the majority of it has been centered around SMB. Obviously, when you look at the go-to-market side, it’s more than just the sellers. It’s supporting teams like the SDR teams or the sales development reps, even on the marketing side. One of the big areas of change for us has been to drive more towards digital demand generation, which really works much better in a bottom-up adoption motion. And so that’s been the kind of change that has happened in marketing. On engineering, the overall change has been very limited. And primarily there, the change has been to make sure that we create the focus and rebalance investment towards areas that I’ve talked about as being a very high priority for us and strategically important for us going forward, and that’s all around cloud and serverless. And the three solution areas continue to remain strong. So it’s been a – the changes have been across the board, but they have been very targeted. they have been focused on addressing the areas where we believe that we can drive the greatest growth and profitability and also making sure that we are not investing or finding more efficient ways to address parts of our business that are not showing the returns that we would have hoped for. And specifically, I’d call out SMB

[Janesh Moorjani]

And Tyler, maybe the one thing I’ll just tack on to that is, as Ash said, we are doing this so that we can invest in the right places to drive growth. And a part of that is to ensure that we continue to invest appropriately in the second half so that we have the right outcomes in the second half, but also prepare ourselves for fiscal ‘24. We want to make sure we’re entering fiscal ‘24 with the right capacity and the ready to go.

[Tyler Radke, Citi]

Thank you.

[Operator]

The next question will come from Pinjalim Bora with JPMorgan. Please go ahead.

[Pinjalim Bora, JPMorgan]

Hey, thanks for taking the quesiton. Janesh, I just wanted to understand the guidance a little bit more. It seems like it’s going – or coming down by about 1 point of growth, constant currency, about 200 points. I think you used the word de-risk for the second half. What makes you confident that the model is derisked at this point?

[Janesh Moorjani]

Hey, Pinjalim, I’m happy to talk about that. So in terms of the approach that we took on the guidance, to start with, obviously, please that we came in above expectations that we had set for Q2, both on the top and the bottom line. In terms of how we thought about the guidance, a couple of things. One is we first have factored in the current economic climate. We’ve assumed that the recent trends from October will continue for the foreseeable future. We’ve, as Ash mentioned, considered the trends in the segments, both SMB as well as Enterprise. We have considered what we see across the geographies. We have considered the consumption trends that we’ve seen in the business. We’ve looked at it from the standpoint of new and expansion motions as well. And then we’ve, of course, factored in the impact of all of the changes that we announced today also. So we’ve suitably factored all of these into our outlook. And then in case things happen to get worse out there, we’ve also built in some additional level of protection into our guidance, as we always do, to balance the risks of the unknown. So there is no court change to our guidance philosophy there. We don’t guide excessively conservatively, but we do guide prudently. So we actually feel pretty good about the outlook. And then as I said, November has played out nicely so far. So we feel pretty good about Q3 and the rest of the year.

[Pinjalim Bora, JPMorgan]

Understood. And Janesh, another one for you, the [indiscernible], the net retention rate trending down, I want to ask about the retention, the growth tension side, has that – is that getting impacted because of the SMBs? Is that fair to assume? And then how the – or is it mainly on the expansion side?

[Janesh Moorjani]

Yes, it’s a great question, Pinjalim. So a couple of thoughts that I’ll put out there in terms of the net expansion rate. So in terms of the gross renewals, we actually didn’t see any significant change in the gross renewal rate for our subscriptions. We don’t break out the numbers specifically because individual projects obviously introduce some level of noise into the measurement. But as we looked at the renewal rates internally, they were very consistent with what we’ve seen before. And when I think about how that played out in terms of the expansion dynamics, we did see expansion slow a little bit, and I think that’s partly the effect of the – some of the trends that we talked about that we saw in the month of October. Within the net expansion rate, that does include some effect of SMB and monthly cloud consumption, which is annualized for the purposes of that net expansion rate calculation. So the softer SMB performance in October also would have had an adverse impact on that.

But the way we think about that is that even at 125%, it is still a world class expansion rate. And when you look at the customers over $100,000 ACV, which is the other way that we think about expansion, we have continued to grow that number in a pretty solid way. And that’s a more current data point that indicates the expansion momentum that we are seeing. So when I think about it more broadly, the underlying trends continue to play to our advantage where customers continue to adopt us across multiple solutions. We continue to move further up within the enterprise. We are getting closer to the customers and becoming more strategic to their businesses. So, for all of those reasons, I actually feel quite good about the longer term opportunity ahead of us.

[Pinjalim Bora, JPMorgan]

Got it. Thank you. I will get back in the queue.

[Ash Kulkarni, Chief Executive Officer]

Thank you.

[Operator]

The next question will come from Joel Fishbein with Truist Securities. Please go ahead.

[Joel Fishbein, Truist Securities]

Thank you for taking my question. Janesh, I would love to just here what happened in monthly customer cohort? I know you mentioned something about it on the call, I just want to go a little bit deeper. And what percent of business is that now? And where do you think that, that trends? And then the second follow-up to that is just how is the government business for you guys been specifically? Thanks.

[Janesh Moorjani]

Yes, happy to take both of those, Joel. So, in terms of monthly cloud performance, Monthly cloud was about 16% of total revenue, and that was a tick down from where it’s been in the past. In prior quarters, it was roughly 17% of total revenue. And I think that just reflects some of the consumption trends that we talked about, particularly on the SMB side because a lot of those customers are on monthly cloud. And in terms of context, 1% change there obviously translates to a few million dollars in revenue. So, it is quite meaningful. But monthly cloud continues to be a great way for us to acquire and scale new customers. We have talked already about some of the changes that we are making to double down on those and focus with even greater investments in digital demand, and in particular, as one example. So, those are some of the trends that we saw from a monthly cloud perspective. And then in terms of the Federal business, Fed continues to be a very strong practice for us. We have invested in the Fed business for some time now, and that team has been really successful in prosecuting many use cases and ensuring that we are used in mission-critical workloads across multiple agencies. In Q2, we were actually quite pleased with our performance in Fed. The team did well to close all of the business that we were looking to close, and we are excited about the opportunity in Fed looking ahead.

[Joel Fishbein, Truist Securities]

Thank you so much.

[Operator]

Your next question will come from Raimo Lenschow with Barclays. Please go ahead.

[Vinod Srinivasaraghavan, Barclays]

Hi. This is Vinod Srinivasaraghavan on for Raimo. Thanks for taking my question. You had mentioned 30% of Elastic clusters are using APM now, just wondering if you could give us a sense of how that’s progressed from last quarter or last year? And from a sales perspective, how do you kind of go about incentivizing more customers in this type of environment to try and use and scale up on APM or security or some of your newer product areas?

[Ash Kulkarni, Chief Executive Officer]

Yes. Hey Vinod, maybe I can touch upon this. So, we don’t break out discretely the growth percentage in terms of how APM is being adopted. We gave this data point primarily because as we have been driving customer adoption, not just across solutions, but within a solution, so Observability going from log analytics to APM metrics and so on, there is a growing need that we are seeing in growing interest and consolidation. And so this data point was one that we are sort of giving for the first time because it’s now pretty clear that our APM solution is one that is gaining a lot of traction, has gained a lot of traction. Matter of fact, one of the customer examples that I gave in my prepared remarks, the large eight-figure deal that we signed with a large financial services institution was really all about APM. So, it’s being used at scale. It’s being used in very significant ways. And the way we tend to drive that expansion motion is in a couple of ways, right. So, one is the pricing model tends to be incredibly relevant in that scenario because our pricing model is completely based on consumption. So, it’s not like the customer has to start with going all in on Elastic on any of those newer use cases, we typically tend to suggest that they play with it. They tried for instrumenting a few applications at a time getting familiarity with the capabilities and then deciding if it’s something that they want to roll out across their entire real estate. And that’s how we have been growing in a very viral manner, the expansion scenarios. And it’s gotten to the point now where a significant percentage, like I mentioned, of our Observability customers using APM in some way, shape or form. And we just expect that to continue growing. The other thing that we are doing is also making sure that, that’s the play that our sales teams are driving with all our enterprise and commercial customers. It’s that that land-and-expand motion that we really focus on. Once the customer lands and they typically tend to land on cloud, like we have talked about in the past, the real focus for the sales teams ends up becoming all around expansion. And that expansion is centered around starting from logs in Observability to APM to metrics. If the customer starts with security, specifically with SIEM then going from SIEM to XDR. I also gave some stats about the adoption that we have seen around XDR and some of our security use cases. So, we are starting to see that flywheel work quite nicely. And that’s really going to be the focus going forward as well.

[Vinod Srinivasaraghavan, Barclays]

Thanks. Appreciate that. And just one more for me. I think last quarter you mentioned that you weren’t seeing too much impact from macro on – from on-prem to cloud migrations, are you seeing an impact to there now, or is the slowdown mainly attributed to lower expansion like you said from SMB on the cloud?

[Janesh Moorjani]

Maybe I will take that one. So, on the self-managed side, we are actually quite pleased with the performance there. It grew 20% year-over-year in constant currency, which compares favorably to the prior quarter. So, we were pleased with what we saw there. In terms of the overall business perspective, there is nothing in particular I would call out other than customers just continuing to express a preference for cloud. So, we generally view that as a positive for the business. And in fact, as you know, encourage that preference as well. We do think that self-managed will continue to grow. And that growth over the long-term should just mimic where workloads reside. So, it’s not a substitution effect. We are not trying to do any kind of forced march. It’s just that cloud workloads are growing faster than on-prem workloads. The way we think about it from a longer term perspective is that our opportunity set is large and our penetration rates are low. So, we should have plenty of room to grow in both the cloud and the self-managed formats.

[Vinod Srinivasaraghavan, Barclays]

Understood. Thank you.

[Operator]

The next question will come from Matt Hedberg with RBC Capital Markets. Please go ahead.

[Matt Swanson, RBC Capital Markets]

Yes. Thanks. This is Matt Swanson on for Matt. Kind of a follow-up to the last question around consolidation. I mean obviously, this is a positive, but I would assume this is also making deals, maybe a little larger, but also more complicated. You mentioned the increased scrutiny that we are seeing in this macro. Could you just talk a little bit about how this consolidation theme might be impacting sales cycles? And then I mean you went into it a bit, but just kind of things you are doing to streamline this from a go-to-market perspective?

[Ash Kulkarni, Chief Executive Officer]

Yes. So, the deals that actually ran into more approvals and so on weren’t necessarily tied to consolidation per se. So, we are not necessarily seeing a correlation between consolidation and deals taking longer, the fact that certain deals took longer because there were more approvals needed. And by the way, that is something that our sales teams are now actively accounting for. We sort of know that, that’s going to be, like I mentioned, more the norm, so we are sort of accounting for that. But those were in regions and countries where the strengthening U.S. dollar has given those customers reason to just be that much more thoughtful. And several of those deals actually came in into Q3 already. So, these were not deals that got affected in terms of us losing them from a competitive standpoint. We did very well. It was just the timing of things. So, that was number one. The second is to the point of consolidation, we agree that consolidation is an opportunity. And that’s, like I mentioned, that’s something that we are really leaning into. And the field is actively having those conversations, right, because at this point, we see that the spend is something that’s on everybody’s mind, how do customers be a little more thoughtful about what they are spending on. And there is a natural desire to ask, how can I do more with Elastic, where else can I use you in such a way that my incremental – my overall cost of ownership comes down, and those are the conversations that really we are driving as sales plays now throughout our organization. And that’s – I expect that, that’s going to be a greater aspect of what we do going forward. But I am not seeing any correlation between that and deal cycles because the change that we saw in deal cycles, that was somewhat we are talking on.

[Matt Swanson, RBC Capital Markets]

Yes. That’s extremely helpful. I guess the second part, just given that macro and given the cost sensitivity you mentioned, have you guys seen any changes in adoption around the free tier over the last couple of quarters or maybe this quarter, either customers migrating down or additional usage from companies that are in that new to Elastic?

[Ash Kulkarni, Chief Executive Officer]

We have not seen that. Matter of fact, one of the things that we have seen is people who might have been using the free – and I actually mentioned one of these customers. I referenced one of these customers, a government agency, in my prepared remarks. I mean what we are seeing is, as the economic environment becomes such that everyone is inspecting their spend, we are seeing customers actually think about the cost of managing things themselves and recognizing that they are better off with a fully managed cloud service as opposed to trying to install and manage everything themselves. So, we did see customers adopting some of our higher tiers, and we haven’t really seen any impact where customers are saying that they want to go to the free tier, simply because the moat is massive. The difference between our premium tiers and the free tier is very significant. So, if you are using any of our advanced capabilities, giving all of that up is an extremely high hurdle. And we haven’t seen any of that behavior.

[Janesh Moorjani]

And then, of course, the other thing I would just point out there, Matt, is that on cloud, as you know, there is no free tier. Everything is paid beyond a couple of weeks of the trial period.

[Matt Swanson, RBC Capital Markets]

Appreciate the color.

[Operator]

The next question will come from Koji Ikeda with Bank of America. Please go ahead.

[Koji Ikeda, Bank of America]

Hey guys. Thanks for taking my question. Just one for me here and I am really kind of trying to focus on this less than 100,000 customer ACV cohort here. So, just given the commentary with the SMB and really thinking about these two components being a fairly big component of the total revenue and really that $2 billion fiscal ‘25 target. I really want to understand the growth potential of this category of the medium-term. I heard that you guys are repurposing SMB spend to enterprise sales, a higher focus on self-serve for SMB and then some investments for digital demand generation. So, a lot of puts and takes there. So, I guess the question is, how should we be thinking about the growth in this sub 100,000 ACV segment here? Is the second quarter kind of the net add a good way to think about a sustainable net adds in this category? I mean does it go down from here? Does it go up from here? Any sort of help on how to think about this category? Thanks.

[Janesh Moorjani]

Yes. Koji, maybe I will try and unpack that a little bit. So, a couple of thoughts. In terms of our customer acquisition motions, we continue, as we have done over the past couple of quarters to focus on driving towards customers who have a greater propensity to spend over time with us, which has meant focusing on those customers that are above that 10,000 ACV threshold and focusing less on the long tail of smaller customers that might spend just a few hundred dollars a month, for example. And you see that in the numbers. So, when you look at the total subscription customer count, although sequentially, we added fewer total customers. When you look at the customers that are more than $10,000 in ACV, that customer additions was consistent with what we have done in prior quarters. So, we feel pretty good about the new customer acquisition motion and the effectiveness that we are driving as we try and work the cost to acquire customers into the calculus as well. So, I think that’s working quite nicely now. If you think about how those customers then eventually expand into the greater than 100,000 category, I think that’s where we – you can look at a couple of metrics. Obviously, the net expansion rate and then also just the sheer number of customers in the greater than 100,000 count in that particular category. And again, in both of those categories, you will see that the expansion motions are working quite nicely. Here in Q2, they were a little bit slower than what we would have ideally liked. And I think that just reflects the broader trends that we have talked about from an enterprise perspective. So, what that does for us in terms of continuing to drive growth into the future suggests that the areas that have been working nicely for us, we need to continue to expand investment in those areas. So, for example, in digital demand gen and marketing to continue to acquire customers at the right pace and the right kinds of customers at the right pace and then to continue to invest in the higher touch selling motion where we can continue to expand those customers into larger customers over time. And those are the two areas where we are continuing to shop in and invest a bit further, while focusing our – and pulling back some of the investments in some of the other areas that were less productive in those selling motions.

[Koji Ikeda, Bank of America]

Thanks Janesh. Thanks for taking the question. Appreciate it.

[Janesh Moorjani]

Yes. Of course.

[Operator]

The next question will come from Kamil Mielczarek with William Blair. Please go ahead.

[Kamil Mielczarek, William Blair]

Hi, thanks for taking my question. I just want to double-click on the competitive environment. I believe you said win rates are unchanged. But as you look across your three products, can you provide more detail on where you are seeing the most competitive pressure? And there is a large number of private vendors entering the Observability space, are you seeing any change in who you are coming up against some deals?

[Ash Kulkarni, Chief Executive Officer]

Yes. So let me maybe touch upon that. So in terms of the three different segments, like I mentioned, where we tend to lead with in new accounts is almost always either in log analytics for Observability or SIEM for security or Enterprise Search. In Enterprise Search, we really haven’t seen any change. In security and log analytics, we really haven’t seen any change either. What we have seen is, as we land and we expand, as we expect – when we are trying to talk about XDR, we tend to see the vendors that have already been in the XDR space, but that’s where we typically tend to go with that expand motion, not with a new customer, but with a customer that’s already familiar with the Elastic platform that’s already using us for say SIEM. And then we basically get the point across to them that the same agents that they have deployed for ingesting data into SIEM for analytics are the agents that can help them with actual endpoint protection. So, it tends to be a different kind of a conversation as opposed to just going head-to-head against other XDR vendors. And it’s the same thing even in Observability, because we also tend to start with log analytics, which has been an area of extreme strength for us. That’s an area where we are very well known. We tend to have the advantage. We compete incredibly well in that area. And once we start with log analytics, the progress that we have made on APM has been with existing customers, right. So once we land with log analytics, we will expand from there, we don’t tend to just go into completely new APM scenarios for APM itself, like for APM alone. So, it’s because of all of those dynamics, we have not seen the competitive environment change in any meaningful way at all.

[Kamil Mielczarek, William Blair]

That’s really helpful. And just a quick follow-up, you have well over $800 million in cash and cash equivalents. Can you update us on how you are thinking about the decision to build versus buy? And given the declining valuations in private markets, would you be more open to a more transformative acquisition?

[Ash Kulkarni, Chief Executive Officer]

Yes. Look, from our perspective, typically, one of the things that we have been very focused on is we want to make sure that we are building a platform, not just assembling a portfolio. We believe that, that’s the right answer in the long-term. When you have a clear well integrated platform, the land and expand motion tends to work much better. Your overall efficiency tends to only improve over time in terms of how you go to market, even in terms of your engineering efforts. So we want to be consistent with that. And so that’s one of the reasons why traditionally we have always done tuck-in technology acquisitions. In the private markets, to your point, at this point, to be honest, I don’t think that the private markets have corrected the way we have seen the changes in the public markets. It will happen in time. That’s what history has always shown us. But as that happens, when that happens, we are always going to be looking for technology tuck-ins that allow us to bring our future forward, because we tend to integrate them deeply to make sure that we have a consistent platform. So I don’t expect that strategy to change. When you say transformative, some of those small tuck-in acquisitions could end up being transformative just in terms of what that lets us accomplish in new areas that lets us get into. And we will always be on the lookout for those kinds of things, but that’s how you should think about our strategy there.

[Kamil Mielczarek, William Blair]

That’s helpful. Thanks, guys.

[Operator]

This concludes our question-and-answer session. I would like to turn the conference back over to Ash Kulkarni for any closing remarks. Please go ahead.

[Ash Kulkarni, Chief Executive Officer]

Well, so thank you all for joining us. The thing that I’d say in closing is we are absolutely focused on our execution and we remain confident in our ability to both drive growth and build a generational company and also continue to focus on profitability, as we have demonstrated through all the things that we have done. So thank you again. Have a great day.

[Operator]

The conference has now concluded. Thank you for attending today’s presentation. You may now disconnect.