CenterPoint Energy Inc
NYSE:CNP

Watchlist Manager
CenterPoint Energy Inc Logo
CenterPoint Energy Inc
NYSE:CNP
Watchlist
Price: 31.87 USD -2.06%
Market Cap: 20.8B USD
Have any thoughts about
CenterPoint Energy Inc?
Write Note

Earnings Call Analysis

Q3-2023 Analysis
CenterPoint Energy Inc

Sound Capital Execution and Positive Guidance

The company exhibited strong capital deployment, investing $1.1 billion in Q3 2023, reaching $3.4 billion year-to-date, exceeding 80% of its 2023 capital plan. Additionally, $200 million was added to its 2023 capital, increasing it to $4.2 billion. This reflects efficient execution, lack of crew loss due to weather events, and customer growth in its Texas electric business. Notably, the firm provided 2024 non-GAAP EPS guidance, suggesting an 8% growth over the expected 2023 earnings midpoint, and aims for a 6-8% growth through 2030. Dividend increased by 10% over the last 12 months. Debt strategy saw a 60% reduction in floating-rate debt, showcasing strong balance sheet maintenance amid higher interest rates. The company stands firm in delivering value with sustained earnings growth, while maintaining customer charge increases below the historic inflation rate.

Leadership Transition

The company has announced that Jason Wells will succeed as CEO starting January 5th, 2024. The current CEO expressed great confidence in Jason, citing strong momentum and a solid foundation in place for the transition. This change is not expected to affect the company's financial and capital growth plans.

Remarkable Third Quarter Performance

Amidst industry headwinds, Q3 2023 marked the company's 14th consecutive quarter of meeting or exceeding expectations. This quarter, they delivered a 25% increase in non-GAAP EPS compared to last year's same quarter, at $0.40. There is high visibility and confidence for the full year, leading to an increase in the non-GAAP EPS guidance range from $1.48-$1.50 to $1.49-$1.51, indicating a 9% growth over 2022 .

Future Earnings and Capital Growth

The company initiated a 2024 non-GAAP EPS guidance of $1.61-$1.63, reflecting an 8% growth from the revised 2023 guidance. They target continued long-term growth, aiming at the higher end of a 6%-8% non-GAAP EPS increase through 2030. A dividend bump from $0.19 to $0.20 also marks a 10% increase over the last year. Furthermore, the firm revised its capital plan up by $500 million, for a ten-year plan totaling nearly $44 billion to support a 10% rate base CAGR through the same period .

Customer and Investor Benefits

Despite inflationary challenges and elevated interest rates, the company's performance benefits both its customers and investors. The commitment to investing in safety, reliability, and resiliency, while balancing impact on customers' bills, is achieving positive results. Importantly, even with sizeable investments in emergency generation assets, monthly average delivery charges have remained consistent at approximately $49 over a decade, exemplifying the company's successful management of customer-affordability alongside infrastructure investment.

Operational Excellence and Financial Health

The company's operational discipline is evident in its O&M costs, expected to reduce by over 12% since 2021. There's a continued focus on reducing O&M costs by 1%-2% per year on average. Capital investment for 2023 has been increased by $200 million due to efficient operations and lack of interruption from major weather events, pushing the invested total to $4.2 billion for the year. The capital investment targets for the subsequent years promise to bolster customer-driven growth, safety, and resilience. To finance this growth, a moderated $250 million ATM program is anticipated for 2024. Lastly, the firm maintains a healthy FFO-to-debt ratio, aimed at 14%-15% through 2030, ensuring financial stability and credit health.

Earnings Call Transcript

Earnings Call Transcript
2023-Q3

from 0
Operator

Good morning, and welcome to CenterPoint Energy's Third Quarter 2023 Earnings Conference Call with Senior Management.

[Operator Instructions]

I will now turn the call over to Jackie Richert, Vice President of Corporate Planning, Investor Relations and Treasurer. Ms. Richert, please go ahead.

J
Jackie Richert
executive

Good morning, and welcome to CenterPoint's Third Quarter 2023 Earnings Conference Call. Management will discuss certain topics that will contain projections and other forward-looking information and statements that are based on management's beliefs, assumptions and information currently available to management.

These forward-looking statements are subject to risks or uncertainties. Actual results could differ materially based on various factors as noted in our Form 10-Q, other SEC filings and our earnings materials. We undertake no obligation to revise or update publicly any forward-looking statement.

We will be discussing certain non-GAAP measures on today's call. When providing guidance, we use the non-GAAP EPS measure of diluted adjusted earnings per share on a consolidated basis referred to as non-GAAP EPS. For information on our guidance methodology and reconciliation of the non-GAAP measures used in providing guidance, please refer to our earnings news release and presentation on our website. We use our website to announce material information. This call is being recorded. Information on how to access the replay can be found on our website.

Now I'd like to turn it over to Dave.

D
David Lesar
executive

Thank you, Jackie, and good morning, everyone. Before we review our third quarter results, I'd like to touch on the leadership transition announcement we made earlier today.

As you've seen, effective January 5, 2024, Jason Wells will succeed me as CEO and a member of the Board. It has been a great personal and professional experience to work alongside him and our very talented executive team. I am incredibly proud of all that we have accomplished together in the past 3.5 years, as we worked hard to position the company to achieve the premium market valuation we have today.

We could not have done it without the support and buy-in of our management team and all of our great employees. I have full confidence that Jason is the right person to take the helm. And given how far we've come, now is the right time to advance this transition.

As our very strong third quarter results demonstrate, we have great momentum and a solid foundation in place.

Making this change at the beginning of 2024 allows Jason and the team to hit the ground running. And as you will hear shortly, this move has no impact on our financial plans, capital growth plans nor impacts the great opportunities ahead for CenterPoint.

I have no doubt about CenterPoint's ability to continue to outperform. I'm looking forward to working closely with Jason and the rest of the management team to support a seamless transition.

With that, I'll turn the call over to Jason for a few comments.

J
Jason Wells
executive

Thank you, Dave. I am honored and excited for the opportunity to lead and serve CenterPoint and all of its stakeholders into this next chapter. For my first day at the company, I've worked with Dave and our Board of Directors to reshape and launch our utility-focused strategy. I've also been fortunate to have worked alongside Dave in our pursuit of a track record of consistent execution to unlock value.

I appreciate the Board's confidence in me, and I'm thrilled with the opportunity to work alongside this talented team we have here at CenterPoint to continue enhancing and executing on one of the most tangible long-term growth plans in the industry.

I am confident that with our team who puts our customers at the heart of all we do, the opportunities ahead are boundless. I look forward to spending the next few months continuing to engage with our stakeholders and sharing my vision for the company's great future as we continue to be laser-focused on providing outstanding service to our customers and communities, and executing consistently to deliver enhanced stakeholder value.

Now before I turn it back over to Dave to kick off the discussion of our strong third quarter results, I want to personally thank him for his tireless leadership, mentorship and friendship. He is a force for change and I look forward to building off the momentum he has created.

D
David Lesar
executive

Thanks, Jason. Now let's turn to what was a great quarter. I'm excited to announce that despite the continued headwinds the industry faces, our Q3 2023 represents our 14th consecutive quarter of meeting or exceeding expectations here at CenterPoint.

And as you probably saw from the results published this morning, this quarter can squarely be put in the -- not only meets, but exceeds column. And as I did last quarter, I will share the quarter's headlines.

Headline 1, strong financial results, even with ongoing macro headwinds. Despite the persistent inflation across the economy and increasing interest rate headwinds, we were able to deliver $0.40 of non-GAAP EPS in the third quarter of 2023. This represents a 25% increase over the comparable quarter of 2022.

Headline 2, strong Q3 results give us visibility and confidence to increase full year 2023 non-GAAP EPS guidance range from $1.48 to $1.50, to $1.49 to $1.51 per share. At the new and higher midpoint, this projected increase would represent a 9% growth over 2022. This would also be our third consecutive year of 9% growth, and our third consecutive year with a compounding beat and raise, reflecting our ongoing strong execution.

In addition, we yet again increased our dividend this quarter from $0.19 to $0.20, which represents a 10% increase over the last 12 months, one of the highest increases in the sector. These are just outstanding results.

Headline 3, initiating 2024 non-GAAP EPS guidance of $1.61 to $1.63 per share. Our new 2024 non-GAAP EPS guidance range represents an 8% growth over the midpoint of our new and now higher 2023 guidance range of $1.49 to $1.51. This continues to reflect the compounding effects of our 3 years of expected beat and raise results, and is due to excellent execution over the past several years.

As we've said previously, we continue to target year-over-year growth to deliver value to our customers and investors each and every year.

We are also demonstrating that we continue to have upside to our previously stated annual growth targets.

Headline 4, another upward revision to our capital plan. We continue to be prudent and formally incorporating incremental capital into our plan. We will not deviate from our practice of only adding in incremental investments when we believe we can operationally execute them, efficiently fund them and effectively recover them.

I am delighted to say today that we now have line of sight to increase our capital plan by an additional $500 million. This brings our total 10-year capital plan due 2030 to nearly $44 billion, supporting a 10% rate base CAGR throughout that same period. Better yet, this amount also includes an increase to our 2023 plan from $4 billion to $4.2 billion. This represents a nearly 17% increase since our beginning of the year target of $3.6 billion. The remaining incremental $300 million will be deployed in 2024 and 2025.

These additional capital investments will continue to support safety, reliability and resiliency for the benefit of customers, while balancing the impact on their bills. Chris will discuss the funding of this incremental capital a little later in his remarks.

Headline 5, O&M discipline continues to help results and benefit customers. We continue on a path of reducing O&M costs by 1% to 2% per year on average over our current 10-year plan. We have successfully been able to reduce overall O&M on an annual basis even in years when we have pulled forward O&M. This benefits all of our stakeholders. This year's strong results will allow us to pull approximately $0.03 of O&M into '23 from 2024.

Now over time, we've discussed a lot of pluses, minuses and pull-forwards to our O&M in our earnings calls over the past 3 years. And sometimes it's easy to get lost in the weeds on our great progress, and we do see it in O&M. In fact, that happens to me at times. But here is the bottom line that you should focus on. Even with higher inflation, we are now on track to have reduced total controllable O&M from $1.46 billion to $1.28 billion since the beginning of 2021, a reduction of over 12%.

Headline 6. Our 4 upcoming rate case filings remain on track with a slight modification to the timing of our Houston Electric rate case. With the support of key stakeholders, we are requesting a shift to the timing of our CEHE rate case. With PUCT approval, we will seek to file a couple of months later to allow the use of a calendar year test year which should simplify the filing for all parties. Jason will get into that in a few minutes.

Headline 7, Houston growth continues at a blistering pace. The Houston area has seen a nearly 15% increase in housing starts through the first 3 quarters of 2023. This activity continues to support our annual 1% to 2% organic customer growth that benefits customer charges. In fact, 10 years ago, our average monthly customer charges were approximately $49. Today, even after historic inflation, our monthly charge is still that same $49. This is a testament to benefits of the decades-long 2% organic customer growth here in the Houston area.

Headline 8, still targeting Houston Electric customer charges at or below the 2% historical rate of inflation. While continuing to heavily invest in the fundamentals of safety, resiliency and reliability, our goal is to keep Houston Electric customer charge increases at or below the 2% historical level of inflation over the longer term.

In summary, balancing the economic headwinds such as higher interest rates and inflationary pressures, with the tailwinds of unseasonably warm weather, especially in our Houston service territory, we continue to deliver for both our customers and investors.

The third quarter of 2023 highlights this management team's commitment and ability to execute even through adverse macro conditions. We continue to believe that we have one of the most tangible, long-term growth plans in the industry. And we believe we have the right team in place to extend our track record of execution.

Before I hand it over to Jason and Chris, I want to express my sincere appreciation to all employees here at CenterPoint that endured extreme weather conditions this summer to keep the power on for our customers when it mattered most.

Now let me turn the call over to Jason.

J
Jason Wells
executive

Thank you, Dave. Before I get into my updates for the quarter, I also want to extend my gratitude to all of our employees who work through the challenging weather and economic conditions this summer to provide exceptional service to our customers.

Now looking at the regulatory calendar on Slide 5. I want to provide an update regarding the timing of our 4 upcoming rate case filings, beginning with the first 1 of 2 that will be filed next week. That is our Texas gas rate case. For the benefit of our customers, and to reduce administrative burden on all of our stakeholders, for the first time, we will be combining our 4 Texas gas jurisdictions into a single rate case filing.

We expect that this combined filing will result in reduced monthly bills for certain customers, specifically to those in our smaller, rural Texas gas areas of our service territory as well as our large commercial and industrial users. Those residential customers in more urban areas are anticipated to see a moderate overall monthly bill increase.

Additionally, this single filing will simplify future consolidated annual group filings from 4 to 1 per year.

Moving on to our other Texas business, Houston Electric. We are now targeting the second quarter of 2024 to file our rate cases. We had previously guided to the first quarter of 2024. However, to simplify the case for all stakeholders, we now anticipate using a calendar test year ending December 31, 2023, rather than the previously contemplated test year-end of September 30, 2023.

The shift to a calendar test year reduces the administrative burden for all parties. Given the anticipated new test period end date, we wanted to ensure that we had enough time to compile our filing. While we're still developing the parameters, we are still anticipating the rate case to have a relatively flat revenue requirement and look forward to highlighting the large O&M reductions we've been able to achieve, which will be a key contributor to the expected revenue requirement.

In our Minnesota Gas and Indiana Electric businesses, we don't anticipate any changes to the timing of our filings as we continue to target early November, December of this year, respectively, for those filings. Although we don't expect the timing of the Minnesota rate case to change, the structure of our filing will. We are planning to file a 2-year forward-looking rate case instead of a 1-year rate case, which we've historically filed. This change will allow us to file for a revenue increase for the second year and maintain those rates to the next rate case, putting us on an expected path to smooth revenue increases for the benefit of our customers.

Additionally, given the filing will cover a longer period, it will naturally result in fewer rate case filings, lessening the administrative burden for all stakeholders.

Moving to the regulatory updates shown on Slide 6. Outside of our rate cases, during the quarter, we began to recover on our interim mechanisms at Houston Electric. The first interim mechanism related to our distribution investments, known as the DCRF, which went into rates on September 1 with an annual revenue requirement increase of $70 million. The $70 million increase relates to our distribution investments made during calendar year 2022.

As many of you are aware, recently enacted legislation now enables Texas utilities to make 2 such filings per year instead of the one we were previously allowed. This should allow for the reduction of regulatory lag associated with our future distribution capital spend at Houston Electric as we continue to make customer-driven investments.

The second interim mechanism that also went into rates relates to our recently settled emergency generation or T filing, which like the DCRF, was included in customer rates beginning on September 1. This is a tremendously constructive outcome for our customers. These emergency generation assets can be deployed during some of the most critical times like extended outages caused by severe weather events that occur in the Houston area.

As power resiliency and reliability remain a key focus of ours and the communities we serve, we will continue to advocate for these customer-focused outcomes.

I want to take a moment and highlight that although we continue to make these customer-driven investments in resiliency and reliability, which in aggregate, equates to over $300 million in incremental revenue. We are still mindful of the impacts to customer charges.

As Dave said, 10 years ago, our average monthly delivery customer charges were approximately $49 a month. Today, even after historic inflation, our average monthly delivery charge is still that same $49. This is a testament to benefits of the tremendous organic customer growth here in the Houston area as well as our disciplined focus on managing O&M.

Lastly, I'd like to provide an update regarding the generation transition in Indiana. We had filed for cost increases associated primarily with the increased cost in solar panels and MISO interconnection costs. This quarter, we have received reapproval for Posey Solar, which is one of our 200-megawatt utility-owned solar projects.

We are also revising the place in service dates for 2 of our renewable generation projects that are now expected to be operational in 2026, which were previously anticipated to go into service in 2025. These delays come in with these types of projects are due to increased pricing and the long queue for MISO interconnects, among other factors.

As we've said before, in instances of delayed projects, we will work to sequence our other capital deployment opportunities to eliminate any earnings' impact to our plan. We want to recognize the Indiana Commission who continues to work to balance all stakeholder input of our ongoing energy transition as we work towards moving away from more costly coal generation to cleaner, lower-cost generation investments in wind, solar and natural gas.

Those are my updates for the quarter. I am proud of our operational execution, and especially in light of the extreme weather some of our jurisdictions endured during the quarter.

Our Houston Electric service territory experienced 12 new record demand peaks. Our crews restore transmission lines to mitigate generation congestion, provided relief through voltage reduction and organizationally took a leading role in socializing the need for customer energy conservation.

Through these efforts, we were able to not only keep the power on for our customers, but also manage our O&M while doing so, benefiting future customer rates. Although our sector continues to face headwinds, I am still firmly in the belief that our tailwinds, such as efficient capital deployment, strong organic growth and O&M reduction opportunities exceed our headwinds.

With that, I'll now turn it over to Chris to provide his financial update for the quarter.

C
Christopher Foster
executive

Before I get started on the financial results, Dave, thank you for your support of me as I sought to hit the ground running. And Jason, congratulations to you.

Today, I'll cover 3 areas of focus. First, our Q3 results, including our positive revision to 2023 non-GAAP EPS guidance and the initiation of 2024 non-GAAP EPS guidance.

Second, our positively revised capital plan and corresponding financing plan. And third, a look at where we stand today with respect to our balance sheet.

Now let's start with the financial results on Slide 7. As Dave mentioned in his headlines, with 3 quarters of 2023 behind us, we now have the visibility and confidence to provide an upward revision to our full year 2023 non-GAAP EPS guidance range from $1.48 to $1.50 per share, to $1.49 to $1.51 per share. This increased guidance range reflects projected 9% growth over full year 2022 actual non-GAAP EPS of $1.38 when using the midpoint. This would represent our third consecutive year of 9% growth.

On a GAAP EPS basis, we reported $0.40 for the third quarter of 2023. Our non-GAAP EPS results for the third quarter removed the results of our now-divested nonregulated business, Energy Systems Group.

On a non-GAAP basis, we also reported $0.40 for the third quarter of 2023, compared to $0.32 in the third quarter of 2022. Growth in rate recovery contributed $0.09, which was driven by the ongoing recovery of various interim mechanisms for which customer rates were updated earlier in the year, such as the transmission tracker or TCOS at Houston Electric and the Texas Grips.

Also contributing, and as Jason noted earlier, during the quarter, we began recovery of 2 separate mechanisms at Houston Electric, DCRF and TEEEF.

In addition, we continue to see strong organic growth in the Houston area, extending the long-term trend of 1% to 2% average annual customer growth, which continues to benefit both customers and investors.

Weather and usage were $0.05 favorable when compared to the same quarter of 2022, primarily driven by the historic summer heat in our Houston Electric service territory. This Q3 warmer weather impact partially offset the unfavorable cooler weather impact of $0.06 we experienced in Q1 and Q2 of this year.

O&M was flat for the third quarter and $0.02 favorable year-to-date when comparing to the first 3 quarters of 2022. And we remain laser-focused on reducing O&M by 1% to 2% per year on average, while executing our core work plan to meet our customers' needs. In fact, due to the favorable impact from the weather, we were able to increase Q3 spending on certain O&M items for the benefit of our customers.

These O&M activities included accelerated vegetation management, which we see as prudent, given the heightened recent drought conditions, and other targeted projects that should help us improve safety and reliability for our customers.

Our consistent progress on O&M is clear. Over the last couple of years, we have been able to use hotter summers to increase our spend on O&M for the benefit of our customers. However, when looking at our current O&M trajectory, even with this increased spend, we are anticipating reducing controllable O&M by over 12% since 2021.

These are excellent results for customers and investors alike. We continue to look for and execute on additional opportunities each year.

Closing out the earnings drivers for the quarter, favorability from rate recovery and weather were partially offset by an $0.08 increase in interest expense. The continued rising interest rate expense on short-term borrowings was the primary driver for this unfavorability when compared to the third quarter of last year. However, we continue to be opportunistic in reducing short-term floating rate debt exposure. I'll discuss this in greater detail in just a moment.

Let me now focus a bit on our 2023 capital plan, which you can see here on Slide 8. The third quarter of 2023 represents yet another quarter of sound capital deployment execution as we invested $1.1 billion for the benefit of our customers and communities. This brings our year-to-date total investments to $3.4 billion year-to-date across our various service territories, or over 80% of 2023 capital plan.

Additionally, as Dave mentioned in his headlines, we are now able to incorporate an additional $200 million of customer-focused investments in 2023, which increases our full year 2023 capital plan from $4 billion to $4.2 billion.

Let me provide a little context around this update. This year saw a couple of operational factors beyond the second DCRF law that benefited us. First, we did not experience the temporary loss of our great frontline crews to mutual aid requests as there were not major weather events that activated that need.

With those crews at the ready to execute more work, we were able to support our continued customer growth of over 2% in our Texas Electric business as well as advanced some of our pipeline modernization work at our Texas Gas business as opposed to waiting until next year.

I'm proud of the team's ability to be nimble in this way as we continue to invest in safety, reliability and resiliency for our customers.

Now turning to our 2024 non-GAAP earnings guidance. As we enter the final quarter of 2023, with confidence in our ability to deliver strong full year results, we are already looking to next year. And going forward, we would intend for our traditional rhythm to be -- to provide subsequent year non-GAAP EPS guidance for you in the third quarter of the prior year.

And as a result, today, we are initiating our 2024 non-GAAP EPS guidance range of $1.61 to $1.63 per share. This would represent an 8% earnings growth over our now-higher expected 2023 earnings' midpoint.

Beyond 2024, we continue to target the mid- to high end of 6% to 8% non-GAAP EPS growth through 2030. We also target growing dividends in line with earnings, and as some of you may have noticed, we took the step to increase our dividend this quarter from $0.19 to $0.20, which represents a 10% increase over the last 12 months, one of the highest increases in the sector.

Supporting this 2024 growth is our now-revised capital plan. For 2024, we are targeting to deploy $3.7 billion of customer-driven capital to support the growth, resiliency and safety of our system for our customers.

On top of the incremental $200 million added to the 2023 capital plan, we will add approximately $300 million of incremental capital to the existing $43.4 billion 10-year capital plan through 2030. This brings our new total amount to $43.9 billion. This $300 million is anticipated to be deployed in 2024 and 2025.

Allow me a minute to step back and give all of you a feel for our thinking here on this upward revision. It's much like we've said before. We need to be able to efficiently execute, fund and recover our costs as we think about including more capital for customers. This additional capital represents our move to take advantage of a few factors. First, we have the opportunity to provide it by the recent resiliency legislation that passed in the Texas legislature, where we can start to pull some of that work into play soon. And the team has come a long way on better capital execution in recent years.

I want to take a moment and put in perspective just how far we've progressed in our capital plan since our last Analyst Day in 2021. The new $43.9 billion capital plan through 2030 is nearly 10% higher than the $40 billion-plus plan we outlined when we hosted that Analyst Day. And with our revised 2023 capital target, we will have deployed over $12.5 billion in capital since the beginning of 2021, over $1 billion more than our then-market capitalization.

Additionally, the 5-year capital target of $18 billion plus communicated back in 2021, which now stands at over $21 billion, represents over a 16% increase in capital.

At that same prior Analyst Day, we also announced that we did not need any equity to fund our $40 billion-plus capital plan nor did we need equity to fund the previous increases to $43.4 billion. And that was still the case when we referenced our most recent revision to $43.4 billion, in part due to the financing lift from the noncore ESG transaction we announced in the last quarter.

However, as we have previously said, as our capital plan grows and as we began to spend incremental capital beyond the $43.4 billion plan, equity or equity-like funding would be required. And the reason for this is simple. While we are committed to making customer-focused investments for safety, reliability and resiliency, we are equally committed to preserving a strong balance sheet.

As we go forward and evaluate acceleration of incremental growth capital additions to our plan, you should assume that we will fund in line with our consolidated capital structure. So it follows today that in order to efficiently fund the $500 million of incremental capital opportunities I discussed a moment ago, we anticipate initiating a modest ATM program in 2024 of approximately $250 million. Ultimately, we see this capital we highlighted today, along with the ATM, introducing additional flexibility for our future plans. And as we've said before, we will continue to evaluate efficient funding for future incremental capital that we formally fold into the plan.

To be clear, any ATM program proceeds are dedicated to enhance growth and incremental capital investments. The equity issued under this program will, in no way, reduce our earnings' growth targets through 2030.

As discussed, we continue to reaffirm our target 8% next year and the mid- to high end of 6% to 8% thereafter through 2030. With our revised capital plan, we are still intently focused on delivering work affordably. We continue to target our customer delivery charges at Houston Electric to be equal to or less than historic inflation rate of 2%.

We have confidence in our ability to achieve this through Houston's tremendous organic growth, securitization charges rolling off the bill later next year and our plan to reduce O&M 1% to 2% per year on average.

A great example of our ability to keep customer charges manageable even as we make our system more resilient can be found in Q3. Even with the recovery of more than $700 million in investments in our temporary emergency generation now being included in customer rates, customer charges have increased at less than an annual average of 1%.

We have a strong track record on bringing focus to affordability and smoothing of rates for our customers. Like Dave mentioned earlier, our average charge was $49, 10 years ago, and it's averaging $49 today.

Finally, I will cover some of our financing and credit-related topics on Slide 9. As of the end of the third quarter, our calculated FFO to debt was 14.3%. This represents an expected increase from Q2 as the recovery of our investments accelerates going into the back half of the year.

We anticipate this acceleration to continue through Q4 of this year, as we will have a full quarter of recovery on our DCRF and TEEEF investments that we indicated began on September 1. We continue to target FFO to debt of 14% to 15%, which runs through 2030, and importantly, provides at least 100 basis points of cushion to our downgrade threshold of 13%.

As a reminder, we are carrying approximately $400 million of debt at the parent, which was issued to fund our higher equity layer at Houston Electric and Texas Gas, which we believe is the proper capitalization of these businesses.

Another area in which we've seen improvement is the continued reduction of our exposure to floating rate debt. Through the third quarter, we reduced floating rate debt to approximately $1.8 billion, which represents a 60% reduction from the beginning of 2023. We continue to be opportunistic in reducing this balance further and the convertible bond issuance during this quarter is a great example of capitalizing on opportunities.

Our $1 billion convertible issuance allowed us to redeem our $800 million Series A preferred shares that were set to go floating during the quarter on September 1 of the year at nearly 9%. So some good opportunistic savings were achieved there. The remaining approximately $200 million of convertible bond proceeds allowed us to pay down commercial paper contributing to the net reduction of floating rate debt exposure.

Lastly, after quarter close, we issued $450 million of private placement notes at SIGECO. As we've noted in prior quarters, this was an opportunity to fund the entity on a stand-alone basis, rather than relying on intercompany borrowings from the parent.

On a go-forward basis, this should translate to a lower relative cost of borrowing versus the parent. And as a result, this reduced parent-level debt to total borrowing by another 2%. This is a milestone as our final step of the Vectren financing integration.

We remain intensely focused on maintaining a strong balance sheet, especially in what appears to be a higher-for-longer interest rate environment. We have worked hard to build an additional conservatism in our long-term plan. And today shows another step of progressing that plan for our customers and investors. This shared focus on good planning is what we believe will allow us to continue to execute, even in the face of continued headwinds.

With that, I'll now turn the call back over to Dave.

D
David Lesar
executive

As you've heard from us today, we now have 14 straight quarters of meeting or exceeding expectations. We are a pure-play, regulated, premium utility and on a course to continue execution of our current plan with incremental growth opportunities to support our customers well beyond that.

Thank you for listening to me tell our story for the past 3.5 years. This has been a great ride, and I look forward to finding my next opportunity. We also look forward to celebrating Jason's promotion with all of you at EEI.

J
Jackie Richert
executive

Thank you, Dave. Operator, we'll now turn it back to you for Q&A.

Operator

[Operator Instructions]

The first question will come from Shahriar Pourreza with Guggenheim.

S
Shahriar Pourreza
analyst

So just -- I want to just touch on the confidence that's going into '24 and obviously, growing at the top end from the raised guidance.

I guess, how are you kind of maybe addressing the headwinds, like interest rate pressures on about $1 billion worth of maturities?

And you do have, and Jason, you've been talking about this, you have rate cases, right, in Texas, Indiana, in Minnesota that you have to get through, which could also create some lag. It's a lot of moving pieces. So I guess, where are the levers? And just talk about your confidence level in these cases as well because it will dictate '24 and beyond.

C
Christopher Foster
executive

Sure, Shar. Thanks for the question. I think there's probably 3 things I would focus on. I'll make sure to hit the rate case piece to, in fact, I'll let Jason maybe give you some color there. I think there's probably 3 things that give us the confidence.

First is the thoughtful capital planning, where we're now seeing some of the benefit, with improved regulatory mechanisms. Second is O&M discipline that we're starting to really continuing to improve on. Third would be just really looking across the plan for incremental opportunities as we go. So unpack each of those.

On the capital side, we're now experiencing some of the benefits that are layering in over the increases that we've put in over the last 18 months. And on top of that, we've got the Texas legislation that passed earlier this year that's going to help reduce the regulatory lag. And we'll start to see some of the benefit of those investments in '24 and '25. And so we think that ability to file 2 DCRFs per year in particular, in that incremental recovery of incentive comp can help us reduce regulatory lag by about half.

On the O&M side, really, as David, in particular, we continue to be focused on reducing O&M 1% to 2% on average. And you heard that now that we're looking back in really 2021 forward, we're now looking at a 12% reduction, which is pretty substantial.

Then lastly, I was getting at looking really across the plan. And so there, although not really O&M-specific, we're looking at exploring some savings opportunities with respect to income tax. And since we divested all those nonregulated entities within the company that were of any material size, we've been looking to ensure that there's an efficient state income tax structure that exists beyond that. So we're looking here in the near term for some potential tax savings as well.

Maybe I'll just take it to Jason for more color on the regulatory cases.

J
Jason Wells
executive

Yes. Thanks, Chris. Shar, I would say that the extension of the filing date for Houston Electric will not create any additional regulatory lag. I want to be clear about that. As a quick reminder, we have access to the DCRF and TEEEF cost, the capital recovery mechanisms up to the date that we make that rate case filing. So we don't see this extension in the filing date creating any additional regulatory lag.

S
Shahriar Pourreza
analyst

Got it. Okay. Perfect. And then just lastly, obviously, I appreciate the CapEx increase and a modest step-up in equity. What's left in the upside CapEx you've highlighted in the past versus what you put into plan? And is there, I guess, is there any reason you even track that anymore, given the incremental opportunities? It's obviously not something you guys have highlighted in the deck, so.

J
Jason Wells
executive

Yes. Thanks, Shar. And I think you hit it at the end of your question there. Candidly, I don't think that there's a reason to continue to track. What we had originally for last quarter articulated as a $2.6 billion set of capital opportunities that were outside of the plan.

Candidly, as we've gone through our planning process for '24 and looking at our long-term plans, the pipeline of additional CapEx opportunities above our now $43.9 billion CapEx plan remains significant, well in excess of that $2.6 billion. And so I think it just becomes a confusing factor to reconcile that. I think we've earned the confidence and track record.

That pipeline of opportunities is deep. And as we see the opportunity to efficiently execute them, efficiently fund them and efficiently recover them, we will continue to pull them in for the benefit of our customers.

S
Shahriar Pourreza
analyst

Okay. Perfect. Jason, congrats to you on Phase 2 and obviously not a surprise to anyone. And Dave, congrats to you on your next phase. And if you're not bored of the utility sector, I'm sure there's other utilities that may need your help this year.

D
David Lesar
executive

Yes. I'm not bored of the utility.

Operator

The next question comes from Steve Fleishman with Wolfe Research.

S
Steven Fleishman
analyst

First, my condolences on the Astros, but more importantly, congrats to Dave on putting a great job. And very happy for you, Jason.

D
David Lesar
executive

Thank you, Steven. I'm thanking you for the Astros, I think.

S
Steven Fleishman
analyst

Dave, you can win every year in the utility business, but you can't in baseball. So the -- I guess, just could you give a little color on the $250 million of equity of just kind of -- should we expect that to be kind of largely done, kind of during the year, next year?

And then is there anything to just read into it about? In the past, you talked about kind of asset sale potential and things like that. Is that just less likely now, given the market environment? Or is it, maybe just the needs are not enough to consider asset sale as you're kind of feathering this in the incremental CapEx?

C
Christopher Foster
executive

Sure, Steve. Happy to hit it. I think if you just look at what we updated today, we took the plan from $43.4 billion to $43.9 billion. And really, fairly relatively small amount of a CapEx increase, but one that we thought was reasonably funded with the modest movement in the ATM of introducing a $250 million.

Stepping back, going forward, if you look at kind of how we've articulated it previously, we've probably been putting ourselves in a position to talk about the longer-term CapEx plan and the associated refresh. Really, once we get through the key rate cases that are in front of us at this stage.

Pointing to kind of the last factor that you mentioned, we're consistently looking at -- look at the most efficient way to fund our equity going forward. But I just want to be clear that we are talking about at this stage. Any future considerations on an ATM would be incremental to the $43.9 billion, right? So they'd really be growth-centric beyond the $43.9 billion that we're talking about today. And again, we're looking to do that larger capital refresh once we can work our way through these cases.

Operator

The next question comes from Julien Dumoulin-Smith with Bank of America.

Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analyst

Congratulations, guys. Well done. Look forward to more. Yes, absolutely. All right. Just wanted to pivot back to that last question a little bit. I mean, incremental resiliency spending through some of these filings in Texas seems like a pretty clear opportunity. I know it's preliminary.

Can you elaborate a little bit more about that upside relative to the $2.6 billion you guys had articulated earlier. I get that there's kind of a big opportunity. But just a sense of what you guys are seeing out there, and there's some out there that are really putting some big numbers.

And then related, if you can, how does that timeline square up with the Texas Electric case here, if at all, to the extent to which that drove some of that timeline consideration?

And then maybe lastly, I'll throw in this, since it's related. How do you think about the merit of further LDC asset sales versus ATM, considering this upside in the plan tied to resiliency, or what have you? Again, I get that the modest size of the ATM is sort of tied to the modest CapEx increase. But as you think about these bigger, chunkier increases, is that still on the table? Or is it a little bit in the back burner considering the backdrop today?

J
Jason Wells
executive

Yes. Thanks, Julien. There's a lot to unpack there. On the CapEx side of things, look, let me just say, last quarter, we had talked about a pipeline of opportunities of $2.6 billion outside of the plan. As we've gone through our planning process, it is well in excess of that.

I think those opportunities are in all kind of aspects of our business. I mean, you hit on them. I think the resiliency opportunity here at Houston Electric remains significant. I think it's a real question around the pace of work and we're in the middle of preparing that filing that I'll come back to in a minute.

But resiliency is clearly a key driver. But I equally see an incredible amount of opportunities on our gas side as well, particularly given all the growth that we've seen here in Texas for our Texas Gas business.

So I would say they're equally weighted. They're well in excess of the $2.6 billion we used to track. We're just moving away from tracking that because it becomes confusing what's in the plan, what's out of the plan, how does it adjust quarter-by-quarter. But suffice it to say, it remains a deep pipeline of opportunities.

With respect to the filing timing, we are waiting for the final set of rules to be voted out by the PUCT likely in December here. We will then -- and we are now currently preparing our filing, which will likely be sometime kind of late in the first quarter for that resiliency filing.

I think this is incredible piece of legislation, and we're excited about proposing plans to really enhance -- continue to enhance the resiliency of our Houston Electric business. And so more to come there. I think as it relates to the timing of the filing, it will likely come in maybe a month or 2 or so before we file the Houston Electric rate case. So it will be a busy regulatory calendar for the Houston Electric business next year. But roughly kind of at the same time, as I said, end of first quarter for the resiliency filing, a little bit after that for the Houston Electric filing.

And then sort of more broadly on asset sales. Look, we love the businesses we run. It's a privilege to serve all of our communities. We constantly receive inbound interest on all of our assets. And as we think about additional movements, increases in our CapEx plan, I think we've earned the confidence that we will find the most efficient way to finance that incremental growth. So I would say, we will make the right decision to maximize value for all of our stakeholders as we look to funding this incremental capital pipeline that I articulated.

Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analyst

Got it. Excellent. Nicely done. And just a quick clarification here. You made an allusion to some CapEx timing shifts in Indiana based on the renewable projects. Just what's the backfill plan, if you can elaborate a little bit more?

J
Jason Wells
executive

Well, some of it's already underway. I mean I think some of the capital that we've announced today, we're executing that capital, putting that capital into service. That will allow us then to begin to seek recovery next year, and fully earn on it in '25.

And so this pattern of looking out in the plan and resequencing capital has been something that I think we've built a track record for. Originally, when the Department of Commerce opened up its original investigation, that moved the timing on a handful of our original solar projects. We seamlessly accelerated some capital, particularly here in Houston Electric to offset that. And effectively, that's what we're doing today with this CapEx increase.

So I think the important part about these renewable generation projects up in Indiana, and I think it's important to reemphasize, it represents less than 10% of our total CapEx for the company. And so it gives us a great deal of flexibility as we see the potential slowdown in operational dates for those plants. We can accelerate either in the other electric or gas portions of our business.

Operator

The next question comes from Jeremy Tonet with JPMorgan Securities.

Jeremy Tonet
analyst

Congratulations again to Dave and Jason here. Great to see. And maybe just kind of picking up with this point. Obviously, Dave is a big figure in the city of Houston, very ingrained in the culture there. I was just wondering, Jason, if you could maybe speak a bit, I guess, having moved to Texas, how you feel your relationships with the local community stakeholders has evolved over time being somewhat newer to the city?

J
Jason Wells
executive

Yes. Thanks for the question, Jeremy. I appreciate it. Obviously, incredibly big shoes to fill from the standpoint of Dave's status in the community here.

But I've been working, since I hit the ground here, with a variety of organizations outside of Houston Electric and obviously, our greater CenterPoint family. So I've been deeply involved in the community, serving a number of different interests.

I would say that Houston is a very welcoming and transitory community with a strong civic focus. And I've been able to tap into that to build a broad network.

My focus isn't just on Houston alone. It's incredibly important. And I think, the activities outside of my day job here at CenterPoint reflects my commitment to the community. But even this week, we were up in Minnesota, meeting with the governor and other elected officials around priorities for our Minnesota Gas business, I continue to make my way around our full service territory.

And so I think, and hopefully, you have seen -- I understand the importance of being involved in our communities. Houston being obviously our home base, but we have the privilege to serve 6 states and want to be active in all of them.

D
David Lesar
executive

Yes. Let me just add a little something to that. It's hard. As you know, Jason is a humble guy, and he finds it hard to pat himself on the back. But I think he's done a great job in 3-plus years. He's been here in the Houston community and in the broader places that CenterPoint serves. And I think he's doing a great job there. He's embedding himself in the community. I'm not going anywhere. And I think it's going to be all easily handled, and I don't think there should be any concern at all about it.

Jeremy Tonet
analyst

Got it. That's great to hear. And then maybe just pivoting over towards Minnesota, if I could. I think you touched on the potential to change the structure of the filing to 2-year forward-looking rate case, instead of 1 year.

So I was just was wondering, would that raise your earned return expectations in the jurisdiction, if it does come to fruition? And is this a benefit to CenterPoint's outlook if the commission approves for the 2-year test look there?

J
Jason Wells
executive

I think just overall sort of smoothing of rate increases for customers and sort of consistent with a common theme around a lot of our regulatory updates today, sort of simplifying our rate case schedule. I wouldn't really look at it as much as an earned return.

Minnesota is the one state that we operate in that has a forward-looking test year. Historically, what I used to say was that in even years, we would see a revenue increase, and in an odd years, we wouldn't see any increase, and so we'd have to overcome that regulatory lag on odd years.

This filing for a 2-year forward past year begins to address that profile. And so again, it starts to reduce a little bit of regulatory lag, smooths rate increases for our customers and overall reduces the administrative burden. So we're excited about making that filing next week.

J
Jackie Richert
executive

Operator, we have time for 1 more question.

Operator

The last question will come from David Arcaro with Morgan Stanley.

D
David Arcaro
analyst

Congrats to both Dave and Jason as well. I was wondering just on the Houston Electric rate case filing. I appreciate the color there. And just wondering if you could dig a little more into -- have there been any changes in your expectations in terms of the size of the revenue requirement asked? Does it give you an opportunity to capture any kind of chunkier capital projects that might have been completed in the fourth quarter this year? Or any O&M savings, things like that as you head into that second quarter timing?

J
Jason Wells
executive

Yes, David, I appreciate the question. And the short answer is no. I don't think the extension was for that reason. Really, with the fact that we have now the opportunity for DCRF and TCOS a year.

The rate case -- Houston Electric largely becomes a rate case that centers around cost of capital, around depreciation rates and any deferred regulatory assets and liabilities.

As I mentioned, we have the opportunity to seek recovery of capital that we're spending now and through the fourth quarter, up until the time we file that rate case through the DCRF and TCOS mechanisms. And so I wouldn't really look at this extension as an opportunity for us to address any capital. It really is going to be a case that involves -- revolves around cost of capital, O&M and regulatory assets.

And back to sort of the first part of your question, no, there's no fundamental change. I think we're looking at the potential for a small revenue decline, potentially a flat revenue increase.

We have been clear that we're going to advocate for a higher cost of capital. But we -- as we forecast what that calendar year test year is going to look like, we have reduced O&M more than the increases that we would propose from a cost of capital. So I think that should put us in a standpoint of filing for a revenue requirement, again, relatively flat, potentially modest decrease as we've communicated in the past.

D
David Arcaro
analyst

Okay. Great. That's helpful. And maybe just on the floating rate debt, the $1.8 billion you still get out there, do you plan to continue to reduce that and term it out going forward? Or is the level it's at now the comfortable balance overall as you think about capitalization?

C
Christopher Foster
executive

Sure. Dave, I think, first of all, I got to give some credit to the team for working down even what we walked into this year was 27% floating rate debt as a percent of the total. We're now at about 10%. So really good progress there.

As we look at near-term financing, even looking into earlier next year, just as an example for what we think, how we think this is manageable. We're looking at roughly $700 million at CMP. And just to give you a feel for that, that component of our outstanding floating rate already sits at 5.8%. And so as you can imagine, given where things are right now, we think it's pretty manageable. In fact, we might be opportunistic in going after that relatively soon.

So just to give you an example of we're already looking here and have laid out kind of the next couple of years for you in terms of what's in front of us, and think it's manageable at this stage, even with the longer-for-higher kind of macro theme that's going on right now.

D
David Lesar
executive

Okay. Before we go off the call, I would just want to thank all of our shareholders and analysts that are on the call that have believed in me and our story. And just stick with us because the best is yet to come. Thank you.

Operator

This concludes CenterPoint Energy's Third Quarter Earnings Conference Call. Thank you for your participation.