CBIZ Inc
NYSE:CBZ
US |
Johnson & Johnson
NYSE:JNJ
|
Pharmaceuticals
|
|
US |
Berkshire Hathaway Inc
NYSE:BRK.A
|
Financial Services
|
|
US |
Bank of America Corp
NYSE:BAC
|
Banking
|
|
US |
Pfizer Inc
NYSE:PFE
|
Pharmaceuticals
|
|
US |
Visa Inc
NYSE:V
|
Technology
|
|
US |
3M Co
NYSE:MMM
|
Industrial Conglomerates
|
|
US |
JPMorgan Chase & Co
NYSE:JPM
|
Banking
|
|
US |
Prologis Inc
NYSE:PLD
|
Real Estate
|
|
US |
Coca-Cola Co
NYSE:KO
|
Beverages
|
|
US |
Procter & Gamble Co
NYSE:PG
|
Consumer products
|
|
US |
Realty Income Corp
NYSE:O
|
Real Estate
|
|
US |
Verizon Communications Inc
NYSE:VZ
|
Telecommunication
|
|
US |
Walt Disney Co
NYSE:DIS
|
Media
|
|
US |
Apple Inc
NASDAQ:AAPL
|
Technology
|
|
US |
NVIDIA Corp
NASDAQ:NVDA
|
Semiconductors
|
|
US |
Alphabet Inc
NASDAQ:GOOGL
|
Media
|
Utilize notes to systematically review your investment decisions. By reflecting on past outcomes, you can discern effective strategies and identify those that underperformed. This continuous feedback loop enables you to adapt and refine your approach, optimizing for future success.
Each note serves as a learning point, offering insights into your decision-making processes. Over time, you'll accumulate a personalized database of knowledge, enhancing your ability to make informed decisions quickly and effectively.
With a comprehensive record of your investment history at your fingertips, you can compare current opportunities against past experiences. This not only bolsters your confidence but also ensures that each decision is grounded in a well-documented rationale.
Do you really want to delete this note?
This action cannot be undone.
52 Week Range |
57.24
86.02
|
Price Target |
|
We'll email you a reminder when the closing price reaches USD.
Choose the stock you wish to monitor with a price alert.
Johnson & Johnson
NYSE:JNJ
|
US | |
Berkshire Hathaway Inc
NYSE:BRK.A
|
US | |
Bank of America Corp
NYSE:BAC
|
US | |
Pfizer Inc
NYSE:PFE
|
US | |
Visa Inc
NYSE:V
|
US | |
3M Co
NYSE:MMM
|
US | |
JPMorgan Chase & Co
NYSE:JPM
|
US | |
Prologis Inc
NYSE:PLD
|
US | |
Coca-Cola Co
NYSE:KO
|
US | |
Procter & Gamble Co
NYSE:PG
|
US | |
Realty Income Corp
NYSE:O
|
US | |
Verizon Communications Inc
NYSE:VZ
|
US | |
Walt Disney Co
NYSE:DIS
|
US | |
Apple Inc
NASDAQ:AAPL
|
US | |
NVIDIA Corp
NASDAQ:NVDA
|
US | |
Alphabet Inc
NASDAQ:GOOGL
|
US |
This alert will be permanently deleted.
Stefanos Cris - CJS Securities
Andrew Nicholas - William Blair
Marc Riddick - Sidoti
Good day, and welcome to the CBIZ Third Quarter 2022 Results Call. All participants will be in a listen-only mode. [Operator Instructions] Please note that this event is being recorded.
I'd now like to turn the conference over to Lori Novickis, Director of Corporate Relations. Please go ahead.
Good morning, everyone. And thank you for joining us for the CBIZ second quarter and first half 2022 results conference call. In connection with this call, today's press release and quarterly investor presentation have been posted to the Investor Relations page of our website, cbiz.com. As a reminder, this call is being webcast. A link to the live webcast can be found on our site. In addition, an archived replay and transcript will also be available following the call.
Before we begin, we would like to remind you that during the call, management may discuss certain non-GAAP financial measures. Reconciliations of these measures can be found in the financial tables of today's press release and investor presentation.
Today's call may also include forward-looking statements regarding our business, financial condition, results of operations, cash flows, strategies and prospects. Forward-looking statements represent only estimates on the date of this call and are not intended to give any assurance of future results. Because forward-looking statements relate to matters that have not yet occurred, these statements are inherently subject to risks and uncertainties. Many factors could cause future results to differ materially, and CBIZ assumes no obligation to update these statements. A more detailed description of such factors can be found in our filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission.
Joining us for today's call are Jerry Grisko, President and Chief Executive Officer, and Ware Grove, Chief Financial Officer.
I will now turn the call over to Jerry for his opening remarks. Jerry?
Thank you, Lori. And good morning, everyone. Thank you for joining us for today's call. We are pleased to report that the very strong results that we experienced during the first half of this year have continued through the third quarter. With impressive revenue growth coming from every major service line of our business. Within our financial services group, we continue to experience strong demand across all three major service lines, those being our core accounting businesses, our advisory businesses and our government healthcare consulting business. We're also pleased to report that our recent acquisitions within this group are in total, performing in line with expectations and making a positive contribution to our overall results.
Organic revenue growth within our financial services group was 14.4% for the third quarter, and 12% year-to-date, which reflects our continued success in hiring and our ability to improve pricing for our services. While the market for talent remains very competitive. Our investment over the past several years to expand our recruitment team has allowed us to add the talent needed to keep up with robust client demand. Also, our ability to drive pricing increases as a result of the significant investments that we have made in systems, reporting, tools and training to equip our team to have better visibility into pricing and profitability trends by client and by service line. Our pricing discipline should also serve as well if faced with a more competitive environment in the future.
As a reminder, certain of our advisory services tend to be more discretionary by our clients, which make them less predictable to the forecasts and the more recurring essential services that we provide. So far this year, we continue to experience high demand for new work and have also had success in expanding existing projects. Also, the pipeline of work for the remainder of the year appears strong. Although, we have noticed that the scope of certain deal related engagements has reduced and the timeframe for completing that work has extended, which may indicate that M&A deal flow for some of our clients is beginning to slow.
Now moving on to our Benefits and Insurance Group, with organic revenue growth of 7.3% for the third quarter and 8.6% year-to-date, we also continue to experience strong results from our four major service lines within this division. Those being our employee benefits business, property and casualty insurance business, retirement and investment solutions business and our payroll business. Similar to last quarter, strong sales, high client retention rates and favorable trend in Employee Benefits Property and Casualty and payroll are supporting our performance across this division. Within our retirement and investment solutions service line, we have a portion of our business where fees are tied to assets under management. And those fees are down year-to-date based on the performance of the market. At the same time, we have more than made up for that impact as a result of increased fees and other areas of this business, favorable retention rates and strong sales. As we've discussed on past calls, a key driver of organic growth within our Benefits and Insurance Group is our ability to continue to add new producers. We are pleased to report that our producer count within both employee benefits and property casualty is up over last year. And our total producer pool for the entire benefits and insurance division is expected to be up by year end.
Based on our strong financial performance for the first nine months of this year, and our current outlook for the fourth quarter, we're pleased to be in a position to raise our revenue and earnings per share guidance for the full year and where Ware provide the specific targets in his comments. With this, I will turn it over to Ware to review the details of our financial performance for the third quarter and our guidance for the full year 2022. Ware?
Thank you, Jerry. And good morning, everyone. Let me take a few minutes to talk about the key highlights of the third quarter and year-to-date numbers we released this morning. As Jerry, commented, the strong momentum we saw throughout our business earlier this year has continued through the third quarter. Total revenue in the third quarter increased by $80.5 million, up by 28.5% over third quarter a year ago. Third quarter same unit revenue was up by 12.3% with acquisitions contributing 16.2% to growth compared with last year. For the nine months this year, total revenue grew by $254.8 million, up by 29.6% compared with last year. Same unit revenue for the nine months grew by 11.1% with acquisitions contributing 18.5% to revenue growth for the nine months this year compared with last year.
Within financial services, for the third quarter, total revenue grew by $72.8 million, up 38.9%. Same unit revenue for the third quarter was up by 14.4% with strong revenue growth throughout traditional core accounting services, advisory services, and government health care consulting services. For the nine months, total revenue within financial services grew by 39.8%. And same unit revenue for the nine months was up 12.0%. Within benefits and insurance, same unit revenue in the third quarter grew by 7.3%. And for the nine months, same unit revenue grew by 8.6%. We continue to see strong client retention and strong new client production. The investments we have made in recent years, the higher and increase the number of new business producers has continued to gain traction. We remain committed to further enhancing growth capabilities within the Benefits and Insurance Group. And we will continue to make investments in hiring additional producers for the balance of this year and beyond. Acquisition activity in 2021 and through this year of 2022 was focused primarily within our financial services business. The newly acquired businesses are contributing to this robust total revenue growth. These acquisitions will continue to perform well. But as we lap these mid-21 acquisitions, the growth rate and total revenue attributed to ‘21 acquisition activity will naturally moderate. Bear in mind as you look at earnings per share for the third quarter and for the nine months compared with a year ago. My comments today reference adjusted results and adjusted earnings per share in both periods. A year ago in the second quarter of 2021, we adjusted results to eliminate the impact of the $30.5 million UPMC settlement cost. Plus we eliminated the $6.4 million gain on the sale of operations that was recorded in the second quarter last year. On an adjusted basis in 2021, we reported $0.41 per share for the third quarter, and we reported $1.84 per share for the nine months. This year in 2022, we announced the acquisition of Marks Paneth effective January 1, we estimated annual revenue of approximately $138 million and we also outlined anticipated first year non-recurring transaction and integration costs that were associated or would be associated with the acquisition. We are extremely pleased to have the Marks Paneth team on board and the business is performing in line with initial expectations.
During the third quarter, and for the nine months this year, we have incurred approximately $1.3 million and $9.3 million, respectively, of one time first year non-recurring transaction and integration costs. These non-recurring costs represent approximately $0.02 per share for the quarter, and approximately $0.13 per share for the nine months. In addition, in the third quarter this year, we recorded a gain of $2.4 million related to the sale of a small specialty non-core book of business in our property and casualty line of service. This $2.4 million gain is recorded as other income and represents approximately $0.03 per share for the quarter and for the nine months. With these items in mind, and with a view towards presenting meaningful, comparable information, eliminating the impact of the items I mentioned, adjusted earnings per share for the third quarter this year is $0.51, up 24.4% compared with the adjusted earnings per share in ‘21 of $0.41.
For the nine months, adjusted earnings per share this year is $2.31, up 25.5% compared with adjusted earnings per share of $1.84 last year. Adjusted EBITDA considering the same adjustments was $194.5 million for the nine months this year, up 26.7% over adjusted EBITDA of $153.5 million last year. Without going into detail during this call a table reconciling reported GAAP numbers to these adjusted earnings per share and adjusted EBITDA numbers that I'm referencing is included in the earnings released issued this morning. So you can see the details of the items included to arrive at adjusted numbers. During last year and then at end of the first quarter of this year after seeing artificially low levels of expenses through the pandemic, we talked about the level of health care and benefit costs, travel and entertainment expense and marketing expenses that are normalizing the higher levels.
For the first nine months of this year, these expenses represented an approximate 100 basis points headwind to margin on income before tax, compared with the lower levels experienced in 2021. While we are seeing increases this year versus last year, these expenses most notably travel and entertainment expense, are expected to level out at approximately 100 basis points lower than pre- pandemic levels in 2019. As we continue to enhance revenue growth with intentional outreach efforts to clients and to new business prospects, we expect that these costs would present headwinds this year. Comparing year-over-year adjusted results for the nine months ended September this year, pretax income margin was down 40 basis points. The expense items I described represented approximately 100 basis points of headwinds. And aside from the intentional increase in T&E, and other increased expenses and the short list of items that I mentioned, we are happy to be leveraging other costs. As always details to the impact of accounting for gains and losses in our non-qualified deferred compensation plan are outlined in the release. Because we are comparing a period in 2021 with capital markets gains compared with this year with capital markets losses, there is a significant impact to the GAAP reported numbers as you look at both gross margin and operating income. As a reminder, pretax income margin is not impacted by this factor. Cash flow from operations continues to be solid. Earlier this year, we amended our unsecured credit facility to increase availability from $400 million to $600 million and we extended the maturity by five years. At September 30, the balance outstanding on the newly upsized $600 million unsecured facility was $271.1 million, with about $311 million of unused capacity. In the nine months this year, we've used approximately $95.8 million for acquisition purposes, including earnouts on acquisitions that were closed in previous years.
In the third quarter, we announced the acquisition of Stinnett & Associates that was effective July 1, with a Stinnett transaction combined with estimated earn out payments on previously closed transactions. For acquisition purposes, we expect to use $13.5 million over the remainder of 2022, approximately $50 million in 2023 , $46.5 million in 2024 and $27 million in 2025. Since the end of 2019, we have closed 15 transactions, and we have deployed approximately $268 million of capital for acquisition purposes, including earnouts on payments over that time. In addition to using funds for acquisitions during the third quarter, we repurchased approximately 744,000 shares of our common stock. Through September 30, we have repurchased approximately 1.6 million shares in the open market, at a cost of approximately $68 million. Since September 30, under a 10- B program, we've repurchased approximately 400,000 additional shares, making the total shares repurchase through October 26, approximately 2 million shares this year. To recap repurchase activity in recent years since the end of 2019, we have repurchased a total of approximately 7.3 million shares, representing about 13% of shares outstanding compared to the end of 2019. Approximately $236 million of capital has been used towards this repurchase activity since 2019. The balance sheet of September 30 is strong with leverage of approximately 1.5x of adjusted EBITDA. This provides plenty of capacity to continue with strategic acquisitions and provides the flexibility to continue with share repurchases.
DSO on September 30, was 93 days compared with 88 days a year ago. Bad Debt Expense for the first nine months was 12 basis points of revenue compared with seven basis points a year ago. Depreciation and Amortization for the third quarter was $8.2 million versus $7.0 million last year, year-to-date, depreciation and amortization is $24.7 million, compared with $19.9 million last year. Capital spending for the third quarter was $2.4 million and $6 million for the nine months. For the full year of ‘22, we're expecting capital spending to be approximately $10 million. With a recent rapid rise in interest rates, we're seeing an impact in interest expense. We have $115 million of fixed rate swaps in place to hedge the full impact of rising rates. But for the third quarter and year-to-date we reported an increase in interest expense that impacted margin by approximately 20 basis points of revenue. In addition to the fixed rate swaps with investment income earned on client funds, there's also a natural balance sheet hedged to further mitigate the impact of rising rates. The effective tax rate for the nine months this year was 26%. And that was up from 24.5% a year ago. For the full year this year, however, we continue to expect an effective tax rate close to 25%. Although, this can be either higher or lower due to several factors. We will continue to say that over time, we expect to achieve a 20 to 50 basis points annual increase in pretax margin. As you look back in recent years, we are pleased that our performance has exceeded the higher end of that range. But with 100 basis points or more impact of the items I outlined earlier, the margin on pretax income may be relatively flat this year compared with prior year.
Looking ahead, the recurring and essential nature of many of our services provides stability through economic cycles. Through the third quarter of this year, as we look at employment driven metrics, impacting benefits and in our payroll business. We are seeing continued signs of steady and strong employment within our clients. As we look further ahead and recognize the potential for economic slowdown if we encountered pressure on revenue growth, with a number of variable items in our cost structure, we can take measures to mitigate the impact. The tools and systems we have put in place in recent years have enabled us to increase pricing and keep pace with underlying cost pressures, leveraging costs and protecting margins. The investments we made and are continuing to make new business producers, particularly focused within our Benefits and Insurance Group have gained traction and we're seeing strong new business coupled with strong client retention and that is driving revenue growth.
Results for the nine months are very strong. As we look at the balance of the year, we are comfortable increasing full year ‘22 guidance as follows. We expect total revenue to increase within range of 26% to 28% over the $1.1 billion reported in 2021. On an adjusted basis, we expect 2022 adjusted earnings per share to increase within a range of 26% to 28% over the adjusted earnings per share of $1.66. reported last year. GAAP reported earnings per share is expected to increase within a range of 48% to 51% over $1.32, reported in 2021. The effective tax rate for the full year of ‘22 is expected at approximately 25%. As I mentioned earlier, this can be impacted either up or down by a number of factors. Fully diluted weighted average share count is expected within a range of 52.5 million to $53 million shares for the full year this year. So with these comments, I will conclude and I'll turn it back over to Jerry.
Thank you, Ware. Before we move to Q&A, I want to touch on what we're hearing from our clients. The fundamental attributes of our business that we believe will allow us to continue our strong performance. Even if the business climate becomes more challenging, and provide a brief update on our M&A activity. Every quarter, we informally survey a broad cross section of our clients to get a feel for their outlook on the economy, and the prospects for their business. While responses vary across our wide range of clients, the geographies they serve and their industries. Our clients generally remain optimistic about their performance through the end of this year. Although longer term, there is an increasing level of concern about rising interest rates, the rate of inflation, threats of an economic downturn, shortages of skilled labor and continued supply chain challenges. With those items and all the discussions around the possibility of a more challenging business climate in the months ahead. I want to take this opportunity to emphasize how the strength of our business model combined with our long-term investments in our people, service offering, systems and tools position us to continue to perform relatively well even in less favorable business climates. The fundamental attributes of our business model include that approximately 75% of our revenue comes from essential and recurring services. That's work that our clients need us to perform regardless of the business climate. And of the remaining 25% of the more project oriented work, we often see continued demand for a good portion of that work, even in slower economic periods. Although, the services provided in the scope of engagements may be different. Other positive attributes of our business are that we enjoy very high rates of client retention at approximately 90%. We operate over a broad geographic footprint. We have a diverse client base with regard to their size and industries. And we provide strong and consistent cash flow, all of which have historically allowed us to remain resilient, and approach changes in the business environment from a position of strength.
Finally, as I previously mentioned, we continue to make significant progress and driving improved pricing for the core services provided by our Financial Services Group. We are confident in our ability to maintain the rates that we have in place, and feel that there's still more room to continue to secure pricing increases in the future. Moreover, our continued investments to expand our service offerings, and add people with specialized depth of expertise also position us to support our clients in new ways and to help them navigate and find opportunities in more challenging business climates. As we demonstrated throughout the pandemic, revenue generated from these types of services helped to mitigate the impact of other areas of our business that may be -- that may experience slower demand in this kind of a landscape.
Now, let me turn to M&A. Adding high quality, best-in-class organizations to our team through acquisitions is and will continue to be a key component of our growth strategy. So far this year, we've completed two acquisitions with combined annualized revenue of approximately $155 million. Beyond these recent acquisitions, our M&A pipeline continues to be strong, and we have access to capital to close on the transactions that are in our pipeline, and likely to be completed in the month ahead. With that, we will move on to Q&A.
[Operator Instructions]
Our first question comes from Christopher Moore from CJS Securities.
Good morning. This is Stefanos Cris calling in for Chris, thanks for taking our questions. Can you talk a little bit more about price increases in the financial services business? And how susceptible those are in a slowing economy?
Yes, this is Jerry. Look, what we've done over the past several years is make substantial investments in the tools and the systems and the reporting that give us better visibility into our pricing opportunities by client by service line. And that's reflected in the results that you've seen today and the very strong results, how that plays out in, a more challenging business climate time will tell, although I will comment and our expectation is that there's still pricing opportunities in that environment for us. And we will work with our offices to make sure that we're taking advantage of those opportunities. So I think it's still going to be positive for us. But time will tell exactly how that plays out.
Great, thanks. And just to follow up, private equity has been relatively a recent entrant in the financial services M&A. Can you just talk about what valuations you're seeing today versus, 12to 18 months ago?
Yes, definitely. And that's the right timeframe. About 18-months ago we, it was rare that we would really have that type of competition, when we were talking to firms, we have seen them over the past 18-months, and that in multiples have ticked up a little one or two turns in that space, but it's still very affordable. And we find that the pricing, we can be very competitive in our pricing and still provide, our targeted IRR on those transactions. So to date, it really hasn't -- they haven't driven pricing beyond something I think is reasonable.
We have question now from Andrew Nicholas from William Blair.
Hi, good morning. Thanks for taking my questions. The first one I wanted to ask kind of plays off of your recession or resiliency commentary, Jerry, and it's about kind of the profitability of the different practices within your two segments, or your two primary segments. Is there any major difference in profitability between those businesses that would perhaps be a bit more susceptible? Maybe what makes up that 25% of more project based business relative to the 75% that's locked in?
Ware do you want to get --?
Yes, let me, hi, Andrew, how are you? The area that might be more susceptible. And we talked about this before. Core accounting is pretty repetitive in a central government healthcare services is pretty recurring and long term in nature. But on the financial services side, the advisory business is more project oriented. Having said all that, there's a good I'll say half of that business that tends to be recurring from year-to-year, for example, valuation does annual goodwill impairment and then tangible studies and things of that. They also do project work related to purchase price accounting and transaction that's maybe a little more volatile, just to give you an illustration. So that's the piece of business that slowed down a bit in ’20 - ‘21. But rebounded very nicely ‘21 and ‘22, we've got it, we've got an eye on that. So far, the pipeline is full, and we're seeing some signs of initial softness. But we also have some variability in the cost structure that will enable us to protect margins as we go forward. So that's probably the area that we look at as probably being the most vulnerable area within our suite of businesses.
And Ware all else equal is that piece that is vulnerable higher margin than the rest of the segment or is it pretty comparable to kind of the core accounting tax were.
Now it tends to be higher margin we've had value pricing opportunities this year because demand has been so strong. If our ability to continue that is compromised, or we need to be a little more flexible clearly the pricing could, I think it'll step but it won't enable the year-over-year increase as we've seen this year. To the extent that we're under pressure on projects and pipeline and business, we have some variability in the cost structure with contractors and the like. They're where we conserve staff against surge demand. So that's a bit of a variable component within that model that really serves as well here, if we encounter a slowdown, where those steps are needed.
That's helpful. Thank you. And then going back to the pricing comments, is there an outsized opportunity in that department? When it comes to acquisitions generally, and maybe even Marks Paneth more specifically, do you take that as a key part of your acquisition case now maybe more so than you did a couple of years ago? And is or is that something that takes a little bit more time to assess after incorporating or integrating an organization like Marks Paneth?
Andrew, it’s Jerry, that's a great observation. I will tell you that we have not seen a firm anywhere, I'm sure the Big Four have some of these capabilities. But below the Big Four, we've not seen a firm that have the tools, the processes and systems or reporting that we've built in this area. So the answer is, yes, in every instance, when we look at a firm, we see opportunities to bring those tools to that firm, and help improve their discipline around pricing. We don't typically put it in the, well, we don't typically, we don't ever put it into the model. But we know that that opportunity is there for us.
That's helpful. And then if you don't mind me squeezing one more in just looking at the acquired revenue over the past three quarters or year-to-date. I know we as analysts are kind of forced to make some assumptions on the smaller deals, but it certainly seems like that Marks Paneth has been incredibly successful year-to-date maybe $120 million - $125 million year-to-date revenue if my math is correct. That certainly seems like it's pacing ahead of the $138 million that you had originally targeted. I don't maybe my math wrong, but just trying to square away that math with what seems like, in line commentary in terms of your expectations, because it seems to me that Marks Paneth is really fitting the cover off the ball.
Yes, Andrew, another good observation and maybe Ware and I could take him on this a little bit. But the one thing that to keep in mind with regard to the accounting practice, in general, and certainly true at Marks Paneth is, it's really hard to look at it on less than a full year basis, because in any given quarter, certain work can get pulled forward. And so it's hard to yes, the answer is they're performing very well. We're very pleased, continued strong performance. But it's hard to look at the performance of that business to the first three quarters and then kind of straight line that growth through the rest of the year.
[Operator Instructions]
Our next question is coming from Marc Riddick from Sidoti & Co.
Hey, good morning. So I wanted to touch on certainly have covered a lot of things and really appreciate that as well, I was wondering if you could talk maybe sort of big picture here, because on top of the acquisition contributions, and going back to the pricing and the organic growth it's pretty clear that you guys have gained a lot of market share, I was wondering maybe you could talk a little bit about what you're seeing there. as far as some of those benefits, and maybe how you think that might continue to play out.
Hey, Marc, it's Jerry. Again, another really good observation. What we've seen is that the model that we've been really kind of building over a long period of time, which is expanded expertise and depth of expertise and scope of services has resonated very well with the market. And so that combination of continuing to build depth of expertise and breadth of services, combined with a very strong kind of business development, sales outreach combined with now a reception, receptivity to digital outreach and thought leadership and programs all have gone to drive significant growth across the business. So those are, again, very intentional steps that we've taken along the way that are now really kind of paying dividends and that's what we're seeing in our growth.
And I noticed it's probably predictable. But I'd be remiss if I didn't ask anyway, could you bring us up to date as far as where you are, as far as the marketing approach, I think not just with the commercials, but maybe the broad brush wise, not just from a spending perspective, but sort of maybe effectiveness that you think you're seeing there. Thanks.
Yes, from an effectiveness standpoint, marketing is really, you have -- hard to activities, and then you take a pause, and you measure your brand awareness. And the last time we did that, which was certainly within the past 12-months, we were very pleased with the results and the outcome as to within markets where we are focused our brand awareness, certainly relative to prior periods of time, and then the performance, or how well recognized we are certainly compared to our peer group. So what that tells us is that we're doing the right things in the right areas. With that said, it continues to evolve all the time. And in particular, I think, the digital portion of that and how we're approaching our clients and prospects from a digital perspective and the results of that striving.
And then you touch on this a little bit, I'm sorry, --
On the campaign, you will see that as soon as the next kind of wave of our campaign of our national TV campaign will come out right after election cycle. So we'll -- you'll see some of that coming out shortly here.
Make sense. I would imagine those rates are a lot less expensive. Last thing, you touched on this a little bit. But as far as reaching out to clients and getting feedback from them, you touch a little bit about the broad reach of verticals that you touch on the industry clients verticals there. I was wondering if you could talk a little bit about maybe if there any standouts either good or bad, as far as the differentiation that we've seen from your – from the client industries, and maybe what they might be experiencing or what you're hearing from them. Thank you.
Of course, there's always -- there are always differences by industry. So for example, if you're in the construction industry, you're particularly interested in interest rates and what's happening there. If you're in the -- if you own, develop and own those properties, residential is in higher demand right now than commercial rental property. So there are those types of factors that are weighing in on particular segments. But again, the takeaway to the comments are that we are not overly weighted in any particular industry, or geography that might have a more difficult time in various economic climates.
This concludes our question and answer session, I would like to turn the conference back over to the CEO, Mr. Grisko for any closing remarks.
Thank you. As we wrap up today, I just want to take this opportunity, as we always do to thank our shareholders and analysts for your continued support. And also, as always, I want to take this opportunity to recognize and thank the key drivers to our success and that being our team members. It was a very busy third quarter procedures with client deadlines and various busy seasons across our business. Whether going above and beyond for a client or connecting with or supporting a colleague. Our team's focus on growth, dedication to service and our commitment to our core values is what really sets CBIZ apart. And it's the foundation for our strong performance. I'm grateful to each team member for how they contribute to our success and make CBIZ a better place for all of us every day. With that we'll close our third quarter call. Thank you again for your time and enjoy your day. Thank you.
The conference has now concluded. Thank you very much for attending today's presentation. You may now disconnect.