Brookfield Asset Management Inc

NYSE:BAM

Earnings Call Analysis

Brookfield Eyes Growth and Innovation in 2024

Brookfield Asset Management concluded its best fourth quarter in a stellar first year, with a total capital raise of $140 billion. Fee-related earnings increased by 6% to $2.2 billion, and distributable earnings also grew by 7% to the same amount, envisioning further growth in 2024 with moderated cost growth. The company holds over $100 billion in dry powder after a year of active investing, ready to harness a consolidating market environment with a focus on infrastructure, renewable power, and energy transition sectors. Expected improvements in market stability and investor confidence are foreseen to enhance liquidity, increasing transaction volumes. Looking forward, Brookfield predicts another strong fundraising year, targeting $90 billion to $100 billion of new capital in 2024, and anticipates outsized growth in fee-related earnings due to a strong balance sheet that boasts $2.7 billion in cash and no debt.

Record Fundraising and Strategic Growth Focus

Brookfield Asset Management had a standout year, climaxing in a strong fourth quarter, with $140 billion raised, $93 billion of which was garnered just in the past year. Notably, the closing of the AEL insurance account is poised to infuse an additional $50 billion into their coffers. They achieved new fundraising heights in their infrastructure and private equity funds by catering to a diversified pool of global investors and launching promising new funds like Oaktree's Lending Partners Fund.

Earnings Growth and Positive Economic Outcomes

The firm saw its fee-related earnings grow by 6% and distributable earnings by 7%, each amounting to $2.2 billion, positioning the firm for robust growth in 2024. They anticipate a favorable economic landscape ahead, with moderated inflation, peaked interest rates, and an expectation for the Federal Reserve to ease rates, thus boosting investor confidence and liquidity, which should lead to higher transaction volumes and a thriving environment for investment activities.

Consolidation and Industry Leadership

The company enters 2024 with over $100 billion in dry powder and is eyeing continued industry consolidation, particularly in sought-after sectors like infrastructure, renewable power, and energy transition. These sectors are favored for offering market growth, principal safety, inflation protection, and long-term appreciation. Brookfield's early engagement in these areas has amassed it nearly $300 billion under management, enabling the company to leverage proprietary deals and solidify its dominant market presence.

Diversification and Yearly Fundraising Projections

Brookfield's diversification strategy spans asset classes, products, and fundraising sources, allowing consistent capital deployment despite market fluctuations. Exemplifying their success, the firm can now look forward to raising $75 billion outside its flagship funds, projecting an average total of $90 to $100 billion annually.

Expanding Insurance Solutions and Private Wealth Segments

Upon the acquisition of AEL, Brookfield will amplify its fee-bearing insurance capital to over $80 billion and become one of the U.S.'s largest annuity writers. The firm plans to organically raise $15 to $20 billion annually in insurance capital. Concurrently, their private wealth arm, Brookfield Oaktree Wealth Solutions, is expanding with an aim to generate $12 to $15 billion in annual fundraising, following a year where they successfully raised about $7 billion in this channel.

Emphasis on Product Development for Client Solutions

Brookfield attributes part of their success to adeptly adjusting to market shifts and consistently developing in-house products that meet client needs. Their focus on leveraging investment expertise across their business segments, and investor bases has been a cornerstone of their adaptability and growth.

Earnings Call Transcript 2023-Q4

[Operator]

Hello, and welcome to Brookfield Asset Management's Fourth Quarter 2023 Conference Call and Webcast. [Operator Instructions] I would now like to hand the conference over to our first speaker, Mr. Jason Fooks, Senior Vice President, Investor Relations. Please go ahead.

[Jason Fooks, executive]

Thank you for joining us today for Brookfield Asset Management's earnings call. On the call today, we have Bruce Flatt, our Chief Executive Officer; Connor Teskey, our President; and Bahir Manios, our Chief Financial Officer. Bruce will start the call today with opening remarks followed by Connor, who will talk about our growing fundraising capabilities and finally, here will discuss our financial and operating results for the business.

After our formal comments, we'll turn the call over to the operator and take any analyst questions. In order to accommodate all those who want to ask questions, we ask that you refrain from asking more than 2 questions at one time. And if you should have additional questions, please rejoin the queue, and I'll be happy to take additional questions at the end if time permits.

Before we begin, I'd like to remind you that in today's comments, including in responding to questions and in discussing new initiatives and our financial and operating performance, we may make forward-looking statements, including forward-looking statements within the meaning of applicable Canadian and U.S. securities law. These statements reflect predictions of future events and trends and do not relate to historic events. They're subject to known and unknown risks, and future events and results may differ materially from such statements. For further information on these risks and their potential impacts on our company, please see our filings with the securities regulators in Canada and the U.S. and the information available on our website.

And with that, I'll turn the call over to Bruce.

[James Flatt, executive]

Thank you, Jason, and welcome to everyone on the call. Our results were strong in the fourth quarter, our best quarter in an overall excellent first year for Brookfield Asset Management. In total, we raised $140 billion of capital which includes $93 billion raised over the past year and $50 billion coming from the pending close of the AEL insurance account with Brookfield reinsurance. We were successful fundraising across our flagship funds, including new records for our infrastructure and private equity franchises.

This past year, we fund raised across a broad set of complementary strategies and with an increasingly diversified set of global investors. We also launched a number of new funds, most notably Oaktree's Lending Partners Fund, which shows promise in evolving to be a 6th flagship series for us. Our goal is to always have a focus on providing exceptional value to our clients. Our goal has always been to generate strong risk-adjusted returns by acquiring assets for value, leveraging our operational capabilities to grow cash flows and compounding capital over the long term. By staying ahead of market trends and continuously innovating, we've been able to help our clients achieve their investment objectives in ways that truly matter to them.

At the same time, this past year has been about making the necessary investments in our platform to position us for long-term success and growth. We've been expanding our global fundraising organization as well as building our capabilities within insurance and private wealth with the expectation that they will grow to become meaningful contributors to our annual fundraising in the near term. Fee related earnings grew 6% and to $2.2 billion and the distributable earnings grew 7% also to $2.2 billion. The significant capital we raised over the past year sets us up for strong growth in 2024 and with much of the investment in our platform complete, our cost growth should moderate.

The combination of faster revenue growth and slower cost growth should mean a strong year for FRE and DE growth. More broadly, it appears that inflation has tempered. Interest rates have peaked and the Fed soon will begin easing rates. Markets struggle in the face of uncertainty, and these actions signal improved stability resulting in increased investor confidence in pricing risk and therefore, enhance liquidity to capital markets. Transaction volume should pick up as well, which will enable more managers including us to monetize investments, return capital to partners and in turn, enable those partners to reinvest in private funds for what should be an excellent environment for investing.

We are going into this year with more than $100 billion of dry powder across our businesses despite investing over $50 billion last year, one of our most active years of investing. We believe the environment will lead to continued consolidation in the industry. This is a theme you've heard us talk about a lot before. We participated in this consolidation 5 years ago with our Oaktree partnership, and we continue to look at strategic opportunities to further broaden and strengthen our franchise.

This tend towards consolidation is especially true for areas of the alternative asset management space that are most in favor by investors and should attract more capital. Infrastructure, renewable power and energy transition are expected to be among the fastest-growing alternative asset sectors for very good reason. Investors continue to allocate to the space because these are assets that can deliver 4 things all investors see. Market growth, principal safety in uncertain times, inflation-protected cash flows and long-term capital appreciation.

We were an early mover into these areas after we identified the decarbonization, deglobalization and digitalization were megatrends that were shaping the global economy. Governments, corporates and other stakeholders have made commitments to net 0 targets and are grappling with energy security, supply chain resiliency and meeting the exponentially growing demand for data. These challenges will require trillions of capital investment and our infrastructure renewable power and energy transition businesses are well positioned to deliver solutions.

Today, we manage nearly $300 billion of assets across these businesses, making us the largest and most experienced in the space. We've used this first-mover advantage to build critical expertise, deep relationships and we use our scale and source proprietary deals to pursue investment opportunities that are either too large or too difficult for most investors to execute. We believe that our scale, diversity, reputation and strong track record distinguish us in these areas, and we continue to invest in our franchise and strengthen our brand, and we believe we'll come out of this period of consolidation even more dominant than we entered.

With that overview, let me turn it over to Connor to speak about the capabilities and strategy of our fundraising platform.

[Connor Teskey, executive]

Thank you, Bruce. Next, we will speak to our operations and how we have scaled our business, expanded the breadth of our product offerings and enhanced our capabilities across capital-raising channels. Today, our diversity across asset classes, product strategies and fundraising sources enables us to raise and deploy capital more consistently year-to-year and in different market environments. This is increasingly a key differentiator in our franchise.

This past year is a good example of how our partnership approach and investment track record have allowed us to raise larger flagship funds and deliver on our ambitious capital raising targets. At the same time, we have been expanding and diversifying our suite of complementary funds. Today, we have over 100 active funds across our business that cover a wide range of asset classes, products and strategies, many of which we are fundraising for at any given time. In addition, we've also been building out our fundraising capabilities across an increasing number of channels. The result is that we can expect to raise approximately $75 billion annually, separate and apart from our flagship funds, which are typically raised every few years. That should allow us to annually raise $90 billion to $100 billion on average at this point in time.

Let us break down that figure a little bit. While most of our fundraising will continue to be driven by our institutional sales team and by our public affiliates, we are continuing to grow other channels to augment and diversify our fundraising. A good example of this is the growth of our insurance solutions channel. As Bruce mentioned, we expect [indiscernible] acquisition of AEL to close shortly, which will bring our fee-bearing insurance capital up to more than $80 billion from approximately $35 billion today.

At the same time, Brookfield Reinsurance will become one of the largest writers of annuities in the United States. And by employing the same operational enhancements utilized following the acquisition of American National a few years ago, we expect to meaningfully grow AEL's pace of annuity underwriting. And over time, we should be able to organically raise $15 billion to $20 billion of insurance capital annually. And that would be independent of any additional insurance acquisitions that [indiscernible] may do.

We have also been building Brookfield Oaktree Wealth Solutions, or both, which is our private wealth business. We have approximately 150 dedicated employees across 10 countries to meet the growing needs for alternative assets in the private wealth market. We have partnered with more than 50 wealth groups worldwide in delivering institutional quality investment strategies to their clients. We currently have 5 perpetual strategies specifically developed for private wealth investors, across credit, real estate and more recently, infrastructure.

At the beginning of last year, we launched the Brookfield Infrastructure Income Fund to investors in Asia Pacific and Europe. And recently, we launched the strategy in the United States. The strategy has been very well received, and we've raised almost $2 billion over the past year. In total, we've raised approximately $7 billion of capital through our private wealth channel last year. And over time, we expect this channel to grow to $12 billion to $15 billion of fundraising annually.

Switching gears now to product development. Core to our success has been our adaptability to the ever-changing market environment and our focus on adding new products and solutions for our clients. The majority of our new products come organically from in-house product development. Our product development function works across our businesses and investor segments to leverage our investment expertise and global presence to develop new solutions to meet our clients' investment objectives.

This serves as an important competitive advantage, allowing us to differentiate our platform from our competitors. It enhances our relationships with clients because we can create tailored strategies to meet their needs and proactively adjust to ever-changing market conditions. As a result, we expect the role of new product development to be an even bigger driver of our business going forward. Some of the new products and strategies we've recently announced include a EUR 10 billion private investment-grade debt fund with the purpose of originating and distributing high-quality private credit investments.

This initial fund will launch with EUR 2.5 billion of seed funding in part from Brookfield reinsurance. Another example is a joint venture with Sequoia Heritage called Pine Grove, which will focus on acquiring secondary funds in the venture capital and technology sectors. Pine Grove is raising an inaugural fund in the first half of 2024, with $500 million in seed capital collectively from Brookfield and Sequoia.

We also continue to leverage our deep relationships with investors in the Middle East and are launching a Middle East private equity fund this year as well. This region continues to be one of the fastest-growing in the world, and we have established ourselves as the best positioned sponsor in the market. Also, with our private equity franchise, we'll be launching a newly formed financial infrastructure platform. This strategy focuses on opportunities in digital payments and services, a key pillar in the digitalization of the global economy over the coming years.

Lastly, we also recently announced the launch of our multibillion-dollar catalytic transition fund, CTF in partnership with UAE's Altera. Altera committed $1 billion of seed capital into this fund which will have a differentiated and focused mandate on raising and deploying capital exclusively in emerging and developing markets with a focus on energy transition, industrial decarbonization, sustainable living and [indiscernible] technology.

In addition to product development, at the same time, we always seek to strategically and selectively invest in and partner with managers that have capabilities that are complementary to our platform. We do so when investing can be done accretively and when building a product organically would take too long. This can be done at scale like we did with Oaktree in credit, and over the past 5 years, we've partnered in many ways, including building our private wealth business, scaling our insurance business and sharing valuable insights across our portfolios.

However, we also selectively make smaller tactical investments in managers that we believe can help scale and are complementary to our business. One example of the latter approach is our 50% interest in LCM, a European-based private credit alternative asset manager. Since we began our partnership with the firm, LCM has tripled the size of their main funds in addition to growing across their platform. We think there is an opportunity to do more of these tactical acquisitions. These will be managers that can be assisted by the overall scale of our business and capital and managers whose growth can be accelerated when brought into the Brookfield ecosystem.

Most will benefit from our insurance assets under management and from our client relationships. In addition, we can provide these managers with the proprietary data insights that we gather from our more than $900 billion of assets under management. In order to manage our growing private credit capabilities across Brookfield, notably Oaktree, LCM, our SocGen partnership and our insurance investment strategies, we recently placed all of our credit strategies under a new credit group, which is led by Craig Noble.

Craig is a Brookfield veteran. He's been with us for approximately 20 years and was most recently responsible for our institutional and wealth fundraising, Prior bringing all of our credit strategies together with our newly formed credit group, allows us to work effectively across our credit teams, provide excellent returns and maximize our ability to create value for our clients. We are confident that credit will be a meaningful driver of BAM's growth over the next decade, given the industry tailwinds and our collective focus. This adjustment will help us achieve that.

We will now turn the call over to Bahir to go through our financial and operating results for the quarter.

[Bahir Manios, executive]

Thank you, Connor, and good morning, everyone. So for this morning's call, I'll focus my remarks on 3 areas, starting with a discussion of our financial results for 2023 and I'll then do a bit of a recap on our capital raising efforts for the year and then conclude by touching on the outlook for 2024. So first, just on financial results, fee-related earnings, or FRE for 2023 were $2.2 billion, up 6% from the prior year. This increase was primarily the result of capital raise for the various flagship funds, which we raised during the year, including our fifth infrastructure fund and 6 private equity fund as well as capital that we deployed within our various credit and complementary funds where we earn fees on invested capital.

These increases were somewhat offset by lower catch-up fees and transaction fees, lower fees associated with our permanent capital vehicles and increased costs as we scaled up the business considerably in 2023. Distributable earnings for the year were also $2.2 billion, up 7% compared to 2022. This increase was primarily attributable to the increase that we had in our FRE. We ended 2023 with $916 billion of AUM or assets under management, up $126 billion or 16% from the end of 2022.

Our fee-bearing capital currently sits at $457 billion, up $39 billion and 9% compared to the prior year and will increase to over $500 billion with the shortly anticipated AEL deal. Our fee-bearing capital benefited from strong inflows as well as capital deployed during the year in addition to higher valuations on our permanent capital vehicles. This was somewhat offset by capital that we returned to our clients during the year.

Also during the year, we deployed $58 billion of capital in investments, recorded over $30 billion of monetizations across the business and ended the year with $107 billion of uncalled fund commitments. Now turning to fundraising. And as Bruce noted in his remarks, we had inflows of $93 billion over the past year, which will soon be over $140 billion once the AEL transaction closes and we get the approximately $50 billion of assets that come with this transaction that we will be managing. The $93 billion of inflows were spread across approximately 50 strategies as well as $13 billion of inflows coming from Brookfield's reinsurance business.

We've held several large fund closes since our last earnings announcement, raising $33 billion of capital. The most significant fundraising updates and deal activity since the beginning of the fourth quarter include first, within our infrastructure business, where we have 2 updates. In December, we held the final close for the fifth vintage of our flagship global infrastructure fund bringing the total strategy size to $30 billion. With approximately 200 investors committed to the fund, this fifth vintage is 40% larger than the predecessor fund.

We are now approximately 40% deployed across 6 large-scale assets, and the momentum on the capital deployment front is very strong. Second, we held a final close for our infrastructure debt fund for a total strategy size of over $6 billion. Over 60% of the investors in this fund are new to the strategy showcasing Brookfield's leadership position in the infrastructure debt space.

Within our renewable power and transition business, we recently finalized the first close for the second vintage of our flagship global transition strategy at $10 billion. In the fourth quarter alone, we raised over $6 billion, including an aggregate $3 billion commitment to our transition strategies received from Alterra. In real estate, we are completing the first close for the first -- for the fifth vintage of our flagship real estate opportunistic fund strategy at $8 billion and expect the final close later in 2024.

In our credit business, Oaktree raised $30 billion across its franchise in 2023, including almost $10 billion in the fourth quarter. The 12th vintage of our opportunistic credit fund raised $2 billion in the fourth quarter, and our Strategic Lending Partners fund raised $1 billion, bringing the fund sizes to $8 billion and $4 billion, respectively, at year-end. Oaktree has a robust pipeline for additional private credit fund raising, and we expect to complete the fundraise for these funds later in 2024.

Now turning now towards our outlook for 2024, and as Connor highlighted, should be another very strong year on the fundraising front as we have 4 flagship funds that are still in the market and approximately 50 strategies that we have either started to raise money for or expect to launch in the very near future. This should mean that we're in a good position to raise another $90 billion to $100 billion of capital in 2024, and this excludes the AEL acquisition as well as any of the capital that we raised as part of our 2023 plans that slipped into January of this year.

We also have over $100 billion of dry powder available for deployment in what we expect should be a very attractive environment for investing. All of this should drive significant growth in our fee revenues in 2024. At the same time, as previously mentioned, we worked hard in 2023 to build much of our investment teams and infrastructure for all these new fund strategies that Connor touched on. Much of that investment is now complete, so we expect our expense growth to moderate in 2024, resulting in a sizable improvement to our margins across the business.

So with all that said, and as we highlighted during our call last quarter, we expect to generate outsized growth in our fee-related earnings in 2024, and so with that as a backdrop, in addition to our balance sheet, which has close to $2.7 billion of cash and equivalents and no debt, I'm pleased to report that the Board of Directors has declared a dividend of $0.38 per share for the first quarter of 2024, payable on March 28th to the shareholders of record as of the close of business on February 29. This dividend increase represents a 19% annual growth rate, which is at the high end of our 15% to 20% target range for dividend -- annual dividend growth that we set out when we formed the company a year ago.

This dividend reaffirms our conviction around our outlook for earnings growth for the next year and beyond. And so with that, that wraps up our collective prepared remarks for this morning. Thank you for joining the call, and we'll now open it up for any questions. Operator?

[Operator]

[Operator Instructions] Our first question will come from the line of Brian Bedell with Deutsche Bank.

[Brian Bedell, analyst]

Just to clarify on the fundraising outlook for '24. And I appreciate all the comments on the detail. I count about $110 billion potentially with another $35 billion or so to go with the flagship. So just wanted to see if that seemed correct? And is the $10 billion transition first close, is that all in calendar '24? Or was some of that in the fourth quarter?

[Unknown Executive]

Thanks for the question. I'll maybe take that in 2 parts. The first maybe to answer your second question there. What happened at the end of 2023 is we completed our fundraising, but almost entirely to service some of our largest LP partners around the world. They essentially committed to a number of our funds in 2023, but they needed to utilize 2024 allocations. So we did the fundraising work in 2023, and we closed it in the first couple of weeks of January. And that's what causes some of the slip from Q4 into the early part of the year. We are not double counting those numbers when we give our outlook for 2024. We are treating that as 2023 raised capital. And therefore, as we look ahead to this year, do very much expect it to be in line with that, call it, run rate average of somewhere between $90 million and $100 million, excluding the increase due to AEL closing.

[Brian Bedell, analyst]

Got it. That's super clear. And then just as a follow-up on insurance. I appreciate the color there on the $12 billion to $15 billion of annual annuity production. Just I guess, maybe longer term, what's the appetite to do even more deals over time at the parent, the capacity at the parent to do more insurance deals and both struck this division even to a larger extent and expand that $12 billion to $15 billion in future years.

[Unknown Executive]

Great question, Brian. And obviously, that will be update -- that will be up to the team at [indiscernible]. But what we would say is with the upcoming closing of the AEL transaction, that business has very, very significant scale in the United States and becomes one of the market leaders and can deliver tremendous amounts of organic growth very accretively. Therefore, if [indiscernible] was to consider further deal activity, we do expect that they may consider alternative markets beyond simply the United States.

[Operator]

Our next question will come from the line of Cherilyn Radbourne with TD Cowen.

[Cherilyn Radbourne, analyst]

I wanted to start with a question for you. In the DGTF press release earlier this week, you were quoted talking about how one of the emerging trends in transition investment involves supplying renewable power to the data and technology sector. And I was just hoping you could elaborate on that a little bit and talk about how much of the second fund do you think will be devoted to that type of activity?

[Unknown Executive]

Love that question. Thank you. Maybe just to take a step back and lay the groundwork a little bit. there's not much doubt that the leading technology companies around the world today are the largest and fastest-growing businesses. And the way those businesses are growing is through cloud and AI and the way to deliver cloud and AI is through the build-out of more data center capacity. This obviously presents a tremendous opportunity for our infrastructure business and its leading data center capacity or its leading data center platform. But perhaps one thing that we feel is not entirely recognized is with the new large-scale data centers that are required to support the growth of cloud and AI, these are very large computationally intensive and energy intensive. And therefore, putting one of them on a power grid has a destabilizing impact and the large tech companies want to put multiple data centers on each power grid around the world.

And therefore, increasingly in order to get your data center permitted, you have to come with a power solution as well. And in an indirect way, power is now on the critical path to growth for the large tech companies. And this is a real opportunity for Brookfield because we are perhaps one of, if not the only provider who can provide not only scale data center capacity, but also scale clean energy solutions on a global basis to enable the growth of these large tech companies. And this is not a market opportunity for the future, this is a market opportunity right now. It lends itself to not only those that have the capital and the capabilities, but also those that put the work in, in the past and have the platforms and the pipeline available to service these growing technology companies. And it's been a huge driver of our business in both infrastructure and renewable power and transition. And should tie it all up with answering your question, I would expect renewables to continue to be somewhere between 35% and 50% of our global transition fund.

[Cherilyn Radbourne, analyst]

That's great color. And then separately, the letter to shareholders mentions that your existing LPs made a lot of crossover investments in the latest round of fundraising. Can you talk about what that sort of crossover ratio is across your client base currently and where you think that ratio can go based on your benchmarking?

[Unknown Executive]

Certainly. So it's obviously different fund to fund, but probably a rough rule of thumb that can be used is approximately 20% -- approximately 50% of the capital we raised across 2023 came from re-ups from existing fund investors, 25% came from crossover investors and 25% came from new investors. That's probably a good rule of thumb breakdown. We are seeing that 25% from crossover investors as certainly the fastest-growing of those 3 proportions and that's simply a function of our growing relationships with our clients and our ability to offer more products that might meet their interests.

And so just on average, to dig a little deeper there, like on average, how many funds does the average LP investing with you? And where do you think you can take that over time? Certainly. So the number today is about 2. The average LP we have is in approximately 2 of our funds, 2 of our strategies. We think there's lots of runway for growth in that number. We could see that number doubling over time. It is a process and something we work with our clients on. But we do see that number moving in only 1 direction.

[Operator]

Our next question will come from the line of Alexander Blostein with Goldman Sachs.

[Alexander Blostein, analyst]

So Connor, lots of discussion around product development and helpful color, obviously, around the $75 billion plus minus that you guys expect to get over time per year outside of flagships. Curious how that impacts your balance sheet strategy. So with respect to any GP co-invest to kind of seed some of these products and accelerate the growth. How do you think about utilizing something in that $3 billion cash that you currently have on the balance sheet? And I guess, related to that, how does that inform your acquisition strategy as well?

[Bahir Manios, executive]

Alex, it's Bahir. Maybe I can just start off and talk through the balance sheet strategy and then probably Connor will chime in just on acquisitions and such. So look, we've -- as we noted in our Investor Day and our call last quarter that the most immediate uses for the balance sheet resources that we have in hand will be used to make GP commitments in a number of the complementary equity strategies that we have. in addition to using some of that capital to seed new verticals, new strategies and also to do selective GP acquisition. So that's the strategy. That's what we're highly focused on.

Some of the near-term initiatives that we're working on, and Connor touched on most of these in his remarks, but we'll be allocating capital towards Pine Grove, our technology secondaries strategy. We've got our special investment strategy or BSI within our private equity group that we're also allocating capital to. Two secondary strategies, one in infrastructure, one in private equity. We're also going to be committing capital to. And then the 2 exciting new initiatives that we talked about today, being the Middle Eastern private equity fund in addition to the financial backbone or infrastructure strategy as well. So we're finalizing our plans. We don't have all the sort of final numbers on all of that, but I just wanted to give you an idea of all the vast amount of things that we're going to be doing to assist a number of our business units and these strategies are going to be very additive to our franchise going forward. And maybe Connor will speak to GP acquisitions.

[Connor Teskey, executive]

For sure. And I don't have much to add beyond what Bahir said, other than to say that we're very fortunate to have a very strong financial resources on our balance sheet. And between some of the tactical GP M&A that we mentioned in our remarks, and the seeding of the new product development. That is where we expect the vast majority, if not the entirety of our balance sheet to go towards. We certainly view those as both the most accretive and the most growth-enabling opportunities for that capital.

[Alexander Blostein, analyst]

Great. That's helpful. And my follow-up is around the fundraising targets you've laid out for 2024. So as we sort of think about the $90 billion to $100 billion of fundraising you expect to see this year, as the business becomes more diversified, the sources of that have obviously expanded. So you have insurance, you have traditional style kind of LPGP funds [indiscernible] got well. So help us maybe frame what's the fee-bearing capital associated with that $90 million to $100 million? And then ultimately, what's kind of the blended fee rate you guys expect to come in? And I understand it's not going to all come in on day 1, so it's not all going to hit in 2024, but help us maybe think about how this fundraising dynamic translate into actual management fees.

[Bahir Manios, executive]

Yes, Alex, it's Bahir again. There's probably a lot of details. As you can imagine, we've got -- as I noted in my remarks, we've got 50 strategies that we're going to be out fundraising on, and that's just on the what we call the complementary strategy side of things in addition to the 4 flagship. So with respect to fundraising, the way for 2024, the $90 billion to $100 billion target that we've set out for ourselves you should expect 1/3 of that to come from the flagships that we're still fundraising for. And as you know, we earn fees on committed capital there. 1/3 will come from the complementary strategies. You could say half of those will come from equity related strategies. So financial infrastructure, Middle Eastern private equity catalytic transition, secondaries, et cetera, and half of those will be from credit funds. So we'll be out in the market next year with our real estate finance fund, our royalties business is growing. Our consumer finance business, LCM is also growing, a number of strategies in Oaktree, 17 capital, et cetera. Lots of great things happening there.

So broadly speaking, maybe half of that will be based on invested capital versus committed capital, and generally takes us 3 years or so to invest that capital. And so again, third comes from flagships, third from complementary strategies, about 15% or so, 20% comes from insurance inflows that Connor touched on, we'll get paid on those right away as soon as we get them. And then there's your normal course co-investments that we do, perpetual strategies, semi-liquid, et cetera. So lots of things. And I'd say, from a fee perspective, the average fees that we've had over the last couple of years, which is over 100 basis points will be consistent. We expect that to be consistent heading into 2024.

[Operator]

Our next question will come from the line of Mike Brown with KBW.

[Michael Brown, analyst]

Just wanted to start on the insurance side of the business. Can you maybe just expand on the timing for the AEL close? I think the hope was a year-end close, but I understand regulatory approvals take time. But what's maybe the updated view on that? And anything you can maybe expand on as to what has caused it to not yet close? And then just in addition to the scaling of the insurance business at the Brookfield Corp. Do you think you have the right asset mix and scale to continue to service the insurance balance sheets like -- for example, do you expect to meet to kind of continue to scale the ABF business? And as you do so, does that actually set you up well to win some more third-party insurance AUM over time?

[Connor Teskey, executive]

Mike, thanks for the question. In terms of the AEL closing process, I would say it's very normal course for a transaction of this type. In November, we received overwhelming support from the AEL shareholders. We continue to work through the regulatory process and I would say we continue to target closing shortly. Nothing really to report and certainly nothing out of the ordinary in how that process is progressing.

In terms of how our platform is set up to service that insurance balance sheet and third-party insurance clients. We feel that we are extremely well positioned today and will only go from strength to strength in that regard. Really our process of being well positioned to service insurance started in 2019 with our partnership with Oaktree and giving ourselves access to one of the largest and broadest credit franchises in the world, obviously, with credit being a key asset class to service insurance when you were able to pair credit with the long-duration inflation-linked assets that we have across real estate and infrastructure and renewables, we really feel that we have a product suite that is relatively unmatched in terms of servicing those clients.

All that being said, there's room to run. And as we think about some of those tactical M&A opportunities, one that is top of mind are other credit type initiatives that may be well suited to service insurance clients. So your question is spot on. We think we're well positioned today, but can go from strength to strength in the future.

[Michael Brown, analyst]

Okay. Great. Maybe a question for Bahir. In 2023, the consolidated margin came in around 54%. As we look out to 2024, you've got a lot of moving pieces that are falling into place and certainly some large fundraising numbers that will kind of come through throughout the year. Is it possible that the margin gets back to the 56 level -- 56% level, I think it wasn't like kind of the prior year period? And what is kind of the run rate margin expansion potential that we should think about when we look beyond 2024.

[Bahir Manios, executive]

Mike, certainly. So look, when we when we're reporting and usually refer to our margins, we do it on sort of a proportionate basis, taking all the Brookfield-related activities and taking Oaktree at its share et cetera, and to come up with a net demand proportionate sort of margin of 56% for the year. So that's down 200 basis points from the prior year. And our target starting in 2024 is to get back to certainly prior year levels and even higher for the years beyond. Lots of execution ahead of us, but that is at least the target that we've set out for ourselves internally as an organization.

[Operator]

Our next question will come from the line of Craig Siegenthaler with Bank of America.

[Craig Siegenthaler, analyst]

My first one is another one on AEL. There's quite a few alt managers with partnerships with annuity underwriters now. and they're all looking to grow. So it looks like competition is intensifying. At the same time, interest rates are now falling, which do indicate that annuity sales may also go down. So I know the ROE and NIM doesn't exactly matter for FAM. It's more of a [indiscernible] issue, but higher competition could impact your retail channel flow. So my question really is, what are your thoughts on the competitive landscape today?

[Connor Teskey, executive]

There would be 2 answers to that question. One, the nice thing about the AEL transaction is we have a playbook that we just executed on through American National. And we knew exactly what we did there in order to drive growth and increase profitability in that business. And we see a lot of the same attributes and opportunities upon closing AEL. And yes, the market backdrop will influence that. But we think a lot of the near-term performance and growth is going to be within our control. And while interest rates and competition may have an impact.

The second point is upon closing this transaction, we have very meaningful scale in the United States. And that will be a key differentiator and a competitive advantage that positions us well even in a different interest rate environment that may be more competitive. We think our scale will continue to provide a competitive advantage and a bit of a moat that will allow us to continue to drive that that, call it, $12 billion to $15 billion of growth annually.

[Craig Siegenthaler, analyst]

My follow-up is on Real Estate Fund V. So -- the last 2 vintages were $15 billion. You already raised $8 billion through January, so more than halfway to the prior sizes. I wanted your perspective on kind of recent conversations with LPs, feedback from the road shows. Do you think you're going to be able to hit the $15 billion level by your final close, which I think you said will be later this year. So we're penciling in around Q4 '24 for the final close of Real Estate Fund V?

[Connor Teskey, executive]

Yes, like very little concern. We're thrilled with the traction that the fund has been getting and really it's important to recognize what our flagship fund offers. This is a fund, an opportunistic real estate fund that has delivered 18% net IRRs across 4 vintages to date. And it is for lack of a better term, perfectly suited for the current market environment. So I would say the traction is very strong. A first close at more than 50% of the fund target is a very, very strong indication. And a point we would highlight is -- that's very much in line with the previous funds as well in terms of their first close.

And perhaps the thing that gets us really excited is the re-up rates we're seeing from our clients are particularly strong in real estate. And that's really a function of our franchise and something that gives us confidence in hitting that target fund raise this year.

[Operator]

Our next question will come from the line of Nick Priebe with CIBC Capital Markets.

[Nikolaus Priebe, analyst]

Okay. I wanted to ask a question about fundraising dynamics and your experience with the second iteration of the transition fund. I think you've suggested that you're anticipating an expansion in the number of LPs in Fund II. But considering that the vast majority of assets in the first fund are still unrealized as you seek to broaden the investor base, does that create an impediment for a subset of investors? And in that context, not to put the cart before the horse, but would you expect more success or momentum on that front for the third vintage specifically, considering that the inaugural fund at that time would be a bit more mature in its life cycle?

[Connor Teskey, executive]

Thanks, Nick. Perhaps a few things to unpack there. The first I would say is a -- let me start by saying, yes, we have a very strong belief that the number of LPs in BGTF2 will dramatically meaningfully exceed the number of LPs in BGTF1. The first reason is a macro reason which is, although we're only, call it 3 years between fundraising for successive vintages, 2 things have happened in the market on a very accelerated pace over those 3 years. One is many institutional investors around the world either now have a transition allocation or they have at least determined where within their business transition investments fit and they have a dedicated pool of capital towards those types of strategies.

That dynamic has increased meaningfully versus 2021. And therefore, we are seeing a much broader opportunity set in terms of LPs looking to deploy in these types of strategies. The second one is entirely commercial, which is the last 2 or 3 years have demonstrated to market participants that investing in transition is a very, very attractive risk-adjusted return and a very large and growing attractive commercial strategy. And therefore, we are seeing not only bigger allocations, but more investors allocating to the space. Those are the macro dynamics. The comment I would make more specific to our cadence of coming back to the market is, yes, we don't have realized marks in BGTF1 yet as a result of the fund only being largely invested over the last couple of years. But what we're seeing from LP partners, both existing and new potential partners is it's very clear some of the key macro trends that we got out in front of and some of the very attractive value entry points we secured in that BGTF1 fund.

And therefore, while there aren't realized marks that people can rely on, the value entry points that we were able to secure using our scale and using our operating capabilities are very obvious to investors and I would say, quite supportive of our fundraising for BGTF2. So is it an unusual dynamic? Perhaps. Do we view it as an impediment to fundraising? No, we do not.

[Nikolaus Priebe, analyst]

Okay. That's good color. And then just shifting gears, I understand the way that carried interest is shared between the manager and the corporation. It won't be a meaningful contributor to the distributable earnings in the immediate future. But I was wondering if you could talk a little bit about how much carry you've accrued so far and just how big you envision that component of the earnings profile becoming in the longer run, say 5 years from now?

[Connor Teskey, executive]

Certainly. And maybe just as a reminder to everyone, at the time of the spin out, accrued [indiscernible] was left at [indiscernible]. So we were starting from a clean slate. And then on go-forward [indiscernible], 1/3 goes to BN and 2/3 remains with BAM. So exactly as was just mentioned, we do not expect realized [indiscernible] to be a meaningful part of our DE for the first 5 years post spin-out. To date, our accrued [indiscernible] has reached about $200 million, but we expect that to continue to grow very, very meaningfully going forward. And by the end of the decade, I think in our Investor Day forecast, we suggested that by 2029, we expect to see realized [indiscernible] in approximately the $2 billion range with that more than tripling in the 3 to 4 years following that. So while it is a bit deferred in the future, this becomes a very meaningful driver of our economics come the latter portion of the decade.

[Operator]

Our next question will come from the line of Kenneth Worthington with JPMorgan.

[Kenneth Worthington, analyst]

We're seeing renewed concerns about the commercial real estate market in the U.S. I would say punctuated by some comments by Janet Yellen highlighting some risks here. How do you see the investment in realization environment sort of developing in 2024 and your real estate business broadly as the year continues to roll on.

[Connor Teskey, executive]

Certainly. Thanks, Ken. Maybe just a couple of points here is there is no doubt that there is a little bit of stress in certain portions of the real estate market. But while that stress, that temporary stress is a reality for some. It's also an opportunity for others. And with the breadth of our real estate franchise, and how we fund our businesses, we're in a great position to ride through this environment, continue to keep refinancing our businesses. And the one thing that's often being overlooked in the real estate market right now is high-quality underlying assets are performing exceptionally well.

The issue is on funding and liquidity as opposed to underlying operating performance. And that's certainly what we're seeing in our portfolio. So you combine that strong operating performance with how we fund our businesses, we see a path to riding through this, but this is where the opportunity is created. And we mentioned that we're seeing great traction for our BSREP franchise that's in the market. It is well positioned to take advantage in this market environment and secure some very, very attractive value entry points. And that's why I think we're seeing such strong fundraising success there.

The second part of your question went to asset liquidity. And perhaps I'd make a comment that applies to real estate, but perhaps applies to all of our asset classes. Throughout 2023, interest rates were increasing, but more important than them increasing was their trajectory was uncertain. And that uncertainty did not make for a robust environment for capital recycling and for monetization. What we saw across real estate as well as our other asset classes like renewable and infrastructure is high-quality assets of small to medium-size could still receive very, very attractive bids, and we monetized assets across all of our platforms in that way.

But what was more difficult in that environment was large-scale monetization. With increasing stability in interest rates, we do see that market coming back in 2024. It will take time. It will, we think, accelerate throughout the year. But the good news for us is we were able to use our scale to invest in 2023 when there were very few bidders. And we made the conscious decision to -- not force ourselves to realize assets in that market. And more appropriately wait for better times.

So all in all, we do see liquidity accelerating throughout 2024, not only in real estate but across our asset classes. And that's simply a function of the uncertainty in the market increasingly being removed as interest rates stabilize.

[Kenneth Worthington, analyst]

Okay. Brilliant. And maybe for Bahir, I think this is more of a clarification. Credit had a substantial pickup in inflows and outflows this quarter. [indiscernible] 25 of the supplement. And it looks like the insurance piece was a big driver of that on Page 7 of the supplement. Is there anything seasonal about the fourth quarter? Or was it Argo that really impacted the fourth quarter inflows and outflows? And as we think about the insurance contribution to your fundraising target, the $15 billion to $20 billion guide overtime, is that a gross number? Or is that sort of a net number, net of the outflows that the insurance piece kind of see? So just trying to figure out how to think about that in the context of longer-term fundraising guidance?

[Bahir Manios, executive]

Ken, you're absolutely correct, the fourth quarter insurance inflows benefited quite substantially from the Argo transaction that we spoke about. With respect to the outflows within credit, we may -- I may just want to clarify that with you after the call, but it may have been some funds that reached the end of its cycle, if I remember correctly. And then with respect to the last point, the $15 million to $20 million is a net number that we're using based on the forecast of the various platforms that we have that we have built in our insurance business, aside from the annuities business that gets sort of all the -- that gets all the headlines, Brookfield Reinsurance has also built up or is in the process of building up a sizable pension risk transfer business in the U.S. where it started to bid on mandates at the latter part of 2023, and there's going to be considerable growth coming from that channel in 2024 and also are in the process of building a similar business in the U.K., where that market is also quite significant.

[Operator]

Our next question will come from the line of Mario Saric with Scotiabank.

[Mario Saric, analyst]

Just 2 quick ones on my end. Bahir, your comment on expected outsized growth in FRE in '24. Is that expectation or the definition of outside kind of is that relative to '23 actual growth or your target kind of FRE growth of 15% to 20% over time that you outlined at the Investor Day. I just wanted to clarify kind of what you thought about when you [indiscernible].

[Bahir Manios, executive]

Mario, yes, apologies if I've confused in terms of definitions. But we set out that 15% to 20% CAGR that we expect to deliver on from an FRE perspective over the plan period. And to clarify what I meant is 2024 should be -- should exceed that target just even given all the capital inflows that came in, in 2023, that alone should be a big contributor in addition to expenses moderating as we noted. And then we've got such a healthy pipeline for 2024. So that's what I really meant.

[Mario Saric, analyst]

Perfect. Okay. And just as a quick follow-up on your commentary on the margin. Coming back to '22 levels, i.e., about 100 basis points up year-over-year. Is that inclusive or exclusive of AEL and the capital coming in from that?

[Bahir Manios, executive]

It's all in, Mario. It's all inclusive.

[Mario Saric, analyst]

Okay. And then my second question, maybe dovetailing on the previous question, just in terms of 2024 transaction volumes, monetization and so on. There was a comment both in the press release and the shareholder letter kind of on realized valuations responding accordingly to busy transaction activity over the next few years. I think, Connor, you mentioned that may be a bit slow to start, but it's expected to accelerate. Are you suggesting the expectation that valuations are expected to rise from here on in, i.e., kind of valuations of trough -- or do you think a narrowing in the bid-ask spread will materialize resulting in lower valuations initially, which will be the ultimate catalyst to reignite transaction volumes.

[Connor Teskey, executive]

Mario, the answer to your 2 questions at the end is both. But perhaps I'll clarify maybe something I said a moment ago. We are already seeing transaction volumes in the early part of Q1, higher than they were in Q3 or Q4 of 2023. So while we do expect them to continue to accelerate throughout the year, we're off to a very strong start in terms of that acceleration. And really for high-quality assets, I would say the bid in early 2024 has been very, very robust. And what we are seeing is new year allocations, stability in interest rates and an increasingly open financing market really being a driver of one enhanced transaction activity; and two, creating an environment that's more supportive for valuation. So the point I would make is the answer to your question is it's both. But I would highlight that it's already started. It's not something that we're only forecasting for the future.

[Operator]

That concludes today's question-and-answer session. I'd like to turn the call back to Connor Teskey for closing remarks.

[Connor Teskey, executive]

Go ahead, Jason.

[Jason Fooks, executive]

Great. I'll just say, if anyone should have additional questions on today's release, please feel free to contact me directly. Thank you, everyone, for joining us, and we'll see you next time.

[Operator]

This concludes today's conference call. Thank you for participating. You may now disconnect.