Saregama India Ltd
NSE:SAREGAMA
| US |
|
Johnson & Johnson
NYSE:JNJ
|
Pharmaceuticals
|
| US |
|
Berkshire Hathaway Inc
NYSE:BRK.A
|
Financial Services
|
| US |
|
Bank of America Corp
NYSE:BAC
|
Banking
|
| US |
|
Mastercard Inc
NYSE:MA
|
Technology
|
| US |
|
UnitedHealth Group Inc
NYSE:UNH
|
Health Care
|
| US |
|
Exxon Mobil Corp
NYSE:XOM
|
Energy
|
| US |
|
Pfizer Inc
NYSE:PFE
|
Pharmaceuticals
|
| US |
|
Palantir Technologies Inc
NYSE:PLTR
|
Technology
|
| US |
|
Nike Inc
NYSE:NKE
|
Textiles, Apparel & Luxury Goods
|
| US |
|
Visa Inc
NYSE:V
|
Technology
|
| CN |
|
Alibaba Group Holding Ltd
NYSE:BABA
|
Retail
|
| US |
|
3M Co
NYSE:MMM
|
Industrial Conglomerates
|
| US |
|
JPMorgan Chase & Co
NYSE:JPM
|
Banking
|
| US |
|
Coca-Cola Co
NYSE:KO
|
Beverages
|
| US |
|
Walmart Inc
NYSE:WMT
|
Retail
|
| US |
|
Verizon Communications Inc
NYSE:VZ
|
Telecommunication
|
If you don’t study any companies, you have the same success buying stocks as you do in a poker game if you bet without looking at your cards.
Utilize notes to systematically review your investment decisions. By reflecting on past outcomes, you can discern effective strategies and identify those that underperformed. This continuous feedback loop enables you to adapt and refine your approach, optimizing for future success.
Each note serves as a learning point, offering insights into your decision-making processes. Over time, you'll accumulate a personalized database of knowledge, enhancing your ability to make informed decisions quickly and effectively.
With a comprehensive record of your investment history at your fingertips, you can compare current opportunities against past experiences. This not only bolsters your confidence but also ensures that each decision is grounded in a well-documented rationale.
Do you really want to delete this note?
This action cannot be undone.
| 52 Week Range |
332.7
665
|
| Price Target |
|
We'll email you a reminder when the closing price reaches INR.
Choose the stock you wish to monitor with a price alert.
|
|
Johnson & Johnson
NYSE:JNJ
|
US |
|
|
Berkshire Hathaway Inc
NYSE:BRK.A
|
US |
|
|
Bank of America Corp
NYSE:BAC
|
US |
|
|
Mastercard Inc
NYSE:MA
|
US |
|
|
UnitedHealth Group Inc
NYSE:UNH
|
US |
|
|
Exxon Mobil Corp
NYSE:XOM
|
US |
|
|
Pfizer Inc
NYSE:PFE
|
US |
|
|
Palantir Technologies Inc
NYSE:PLTR
|
US |
|
|
Nike Inc
NYSE:NKE
|
US |
|
|
Visa Inc
NYSE:V
|
US |
|
|
Alibaba Group Holding Ltd
NYSE:BABA
|
CN |
|
|
3M Co
NYSE:MMM
|
US |
|
|
JPMorgan Chase & Co
NYSE:JPM
|
US |
|
|
Coca-Cola Co
NYSE:KO
|
US |
|
|
Walmart Inc
NYSE:WMT
|
US |
|
|
Verizon Communications Inc
NYSE:VZ
|
US |
This alert will be permanently deleted.
Saregama India Ltd
You don't have any saved screeners yet
Ladies and gentlemen, good day, and welcome to Saregama India Q3 FY '23 Earnings Conference Call hosted by ICICI Securities.
[Operator Instructions]
This conference is being recorded. I now hand the conference over to Mr. Bhupendra Tiwary from ICICI Securities. Thank you, and over to you, sir.
Good afternoon, everybody. On behalf of ICICI Securities, we welcome you to Q3 FY '23 Results Conference Call of Saregama India Limited. So from the management, we have Mr. Vikram Mehra, who is Managing Director; Mr. Pankaj Chaturvedi, who's the CFO; Mr. BL Chandak, who's Executive Director; Mr. Saket Shah, Head, Investor Relations; and Mr. Pankaj Kedia, who's Vice President, Investor Relations. So without much ado, I'll just hand over the mic to Vikram. Over to you, Vikram.
Hi. Good evening, everyone. Quarter 3 saw operating revenues of INR 185 crores and PAT of INR 2 crores. That is a year-on-year growth of 23% in our revenue and 20% in PAT. So it's been a pretty good quarter. We would once again reiterate and request you people to please look at our business always on an annual basis and never evaluate it on a quarterly basis. People often wonder why should there be a seasonality in music, actually, there is. Advertising revenue -- the part of the music business, which is dependent on advertising revenue like YouTube that fluctuates. Carvaan sale, which is dependent on festival season and that fluctuates over the year. Also our policy of recognizing overflows from agreements which have minimum guarantee base is such that the overflows are recognized only in the quarter when the money received by us. So there is fluctuation that keeps on happening from quarter-to-quarter. Hence, please look at the number always on an annual basis and not on a quarter-to-quarter basis.
If I look at our numbers on a 9-month basis and both our revenue has grown by 36% and PAT has grown by 34%. This is in continuation to the last year's growth numbers of 31% in operating revenues and 35% in PAT. There's a reason I'm stating and quoting the last year numbers, just to give you the confidence that the growth that you are seeing is not something which has been happening for only a couple of quarters. We now have been showing growth on revenue and bottom line for over 16 quarters now on a consistent fashion quarter after quarter. During the time of COVID, post COVID, our growth story is continuing. And remember, we have just touched the tip of the iceberg.
The growth in digital consumption, both in terms of new customers coming in, 750 million people have a smartphone, while only 200 million people are actually using any of the streaming services yet. There are a lot of new customer that's going to be coming in and consumption per customer are also expected to go up. So then on average, people listen to 67 songs in a month. We believe in all developed countries, this number is closer to 120 songs per month. You will see that kind of growth happening in India, too, which means Saregama growth story in future -- when I say future, I'm talking medium to long term is going to remain stable.
And also a diversified business model, which ensures that there's not too much or dependent on any one source of revenue, be it subscription or advertising or license fee or physical, we are quite diversified in that sense and will ensure that we'll be able to maintain a profitability too. The music business, which is a combination of both licensing and Carvaan saw its highest quarterly revenue at INR 154 crores. On a 9-month basis, Music segment grew by 25% year-on-year to achieve a INR 433 crores revenue. As mentioned, both licensing and Carvaan contributed to this growth.
Let me first start with licensing, which continues its growth number of over 20% year-on-year. There still be the fourth or the fifth year that we people have been growing at this rate. Release multiple films songs across Telugu, Tamil, Malayalam, Bengali, Punjabi and Hindi Languages. We also released Sanjay Leela Bhansali's first non-film music album Sukoon. Punjabi saw 2 successful non-film songs from Satinder Sartaaj. Bhojpuri language saw 4 massive hits on the non-film side from the #1 artist there Khesari Lal Yadav, collectively crossing 15 crore view on Saregama's official Bhojpuri YouTube channel in 1 quarter.
If we see over the last 9 months, we have taken a new content charge, which is inclusive of marketing of INR 50 crores. Just for reference, the same number was INR 30 crores if you look at a year back, 9 month charge. The strategy of investing in new content is clearly paying off. It's not only allowing us to grow our new content market share, but is also giving us huge impetus to our catalog.
Last financial year, we raised INR 750 crores with an explicit mandate to invest this money in new music content, and we are on track. I want to again assure you this money that was raised will be used only and only for music. All the other investments that we people are [Indiscernible] our internal accruals. Often asked question is how do we go about picking up new content? I think our biggest edge is the investment that we people have done on data mining and building predictive models to decide what content to invest in. And also, our longer-term deals, which have happened on the marketing side, which is giving enough confidence to our partners that we can market content like nobody has -- none of our competitors can, which is pushing them to work more and more with us.
Movie music acquisition deals have been locked across Hindi, Telugu, Tamil and Malayalam languages. You will see some of the movies have been delayed. You will see a lot of them coming hopefully between March to June timeframe this year. This includes the much anticipated movie, the next directorial movie of Karan Johar called Rocky Aur Rani Ki Prem Kahani. There is another Dharma Production called [Indiscernible], starring Vicky Kaushal and Ammy Virk. There's one more Vicky Kaushal and Sara Ali movie called Zara Hatke Zara Bachke. There is Vijay Deverakonda and Samantha film called Kushi. There are 2 Suriya films in Tamil. There's a Mammootty film on Malayalam side, there's another Prithviraj Sukumaran film on Malayalam side. These are some of the big titles that I can think of. The music of this has already been acquired by Saregama.
We will continue investing across all Indian languages, both on the film side and on the non-film side. We have already achieved leadership position across a few of the languages, and we are #2 in some of the other languages. We expect the next 12 to 18 months to be at #1 position across all major languages in India. Carvaan numbers maintained the growth trajectory. They touched 168,000 compared to 141,000 last year. Remember, this year, the festival sale was divided between quarter 2 and quarter 3 because of the timing of Diwali. Unlike last year with the entire sale boost that one gets on account of festival season came in quarter 3. That's why you see the growth numbers between quarter 2 and quarter 3 are different this year compared to last year because already a lot of festival sale had been booked in quarter 2.
If I combine both the quarters, that is quarter 2 and quarter 3, we have sold 324,000 units of Carvaan. And all of these numbers coming only out of customer pool. There is no advertising backing Carvaan now for over 3 years. The latest variant of Carvaan, Carvaan Mobile has given us a lower price point, which is helping us penetrate smaller markets. The con of this is that the average realization of our sold Carvaan unit has come down, but I think the upside of penetrating smaller markets far outweighs the cons. This means that though the unit sales has gone up substantially compared to last year, the revenue numbers would not have grown, but it is still a healthy growth compared to last year. There is no marketing push, which is planned for Carvaan even in quarter 4.
Film, Series and Events vertical touched around INR 100 crores in the first 9 months. It is a matter of great pride for us. It literally means that the revenue has doubled compared to the INR 50 crore revenue that we wrote in the first 9 months of the last financial year. And most of it is coming on the back of the new vertical that we have created called Live Events. Overall, Film, Series and Events now constitute 15% of the company revenues. This vertical is not -- one of the big advantages of this vertical is giving us a huge edge in music acquisition because the fact that we can now give breaks to people on live events also means that artists are more forthcoming and more open to selling their stand-alone songs also to us, because they see a much deeper relationship possible with Saregama compared to any of our competitors.
But again, I remind all of you people, remember that Live Events business is a relatively low-margin business. So as the mix keeps changing, it will have its impact on the PBT percentage, though the music percentage remains unaffected -- music PBT percentage.
Yoodlee saw action this quarter, 2 Malayalam and one Punjabi movie got released during this quarter. Prithviraj Sukumaran's movie Kaapa got released in Malayalam. It opened to great reviews and a good theatrical collection. The movie also got released on Netflix recently, and opened at #1 trending position and is currently trending in #2 across India on Netflix.
Our TV serials that we make and put a on Sun TV, they continue to do very well in terms of TRPs. We launched a new Tamil serial called Iniya, replacing our existing serial called Roja after 1,300 episodes. Remember, we had launched another serial in quarter 2, which has replaced -- the quarter 2 serial replaced had also completed 2,000 episodes, which is Chandralekha.
All the 3 serials that we people have on Sun TV are actually slot leaders, giving us a strong position. Live Event business saw 2 Diljit Dosanjh shows in this quarter, both in India. We also premiered our own IP show Disco Dancer in London. This is our first attempt to go out there and create movie-based musicals, which can attract a large number of people in their 40s and 50s, basically people who have a greater spending power, use the equity of those movies and get the customers in and enjoy the songs that are part of these musicals. We also have intend to record these songs and then monetize the videos of these songs on various platforms like YouTube and Facebook.
The next season of Disco Dancer will be happening in the financial year '24. So overall, we are very, very comfortable right now and happy with the way this quarter has progressed. Our mainstream music has done very, very well, and it continues to grow at over 20%. The Films, Television Serials, Event Business, it will always be seasonal in nature, depends on which event is coming in which quarter. But on an overall basis at INR 100 crores, I think it's becoming a substantial chunk of overall revenues. That will be all. Thank you. We'll be happy to take questions now.
[Operator Instructions] We have a first question from the line of Ankush Agrawal with Surge Capital.
Firstly, just a clarification. So our music licensing business has grown at a usual 20% plus rate for this quarter as well, right?
Yes, it's over 20%. We will be sharing separately the growth numbers, both on Music and Carvaan at the end of the financial year. Yes, I'm giving the comfort right now, it is upwards of 20%.
So Vikram what explains our lower PBT growth of just 11%? Like, have we made some kind of losses in the Carvaan business? Or what explains that?
Mix is changing. Remember, as we people are going further and further, the Live Events, Films and Series is a much lower margin business.
No, I'm talking about Music segment PBT growth, the segmental -- music segment PBT has grown about 11%.
There also remember content charge for the newer content has also been considered.
Yes. But on content charge growth for this quarter has been the lowest for last many quarters, like last 2 quarters, we were growing at like triple digital rate, the content charge was going, but now a [Indiscernible] increase, right? So this quarter content charge increased about 35-odd percent. So just trying to understand the equation over here. Are there is some other costs that have increased on the music business side or something that you want to highlight.
No [Indiscernible] any substantial change which is happened there. And you are looking at right now, the number -- just give me a second. I'll just answer your question.
It's INR 15.9 crores versus INR 11.5 crores last year.
So the moment I add that much amount of INR 5 crores number that itself changes the numbers...
So it's largely on the content.
There is no one-off stuff which is happening here, that is substantial enough. The Carvaan business for us for the last 3 years, I've been saying this, is it breakeven business. So Carvaan because we are -- Carvaan, the only chances of losses are marketing, we have stopped marketing Carvaan. So that you rest assure I'll never come to you saying that our numbers are getting lost because of Carvaan. If we ever want to reinvest in Carvaan, we will inform you first.
[Operator Instructions]
We have next question from the line of [Sonashish Chatterjee] with Asterisk Capital.
My question is, if we say our breakeven is 5 years, so actually, we invest or acquire a music by INR 100. On average, in the next 5 years, we get INR 100, right? But it should be [Indiscernible] on the first year, it should be very high, may be INR 40, INR 50. On the fifth year, it will be very low. So my question is, what is my -- if I acquire a music by INR 100, what is my profit in the sixth year or fifth year when the music is not popular anymore?
So I think -- I can't give that specific. I just want to clarify you -- there is this understanding that music has a life for 1 year and 2 years, and it does very well earlier days. While I'm in agreement with you that the first year is the highest number, that's why we also take 38% charge-offs also in the first year because first year is the highest number for any song. Year 2 falls down, which is reality, but after that it starts picking up once again. So our typical trajectory is year 1 is the highest, year 2 comes down. So some of the songs year 3 is further down and year 4 onwards the numbers start going up again because then they start the digital growth, it's higher than the rate at which natural numbers are falling down. So that's the reason a catalog or even movies that we've acquired 4 and 5 years ago, their all monthly numbers are higher than the previous month.
So please -- see this is a general misconception that music typically has a shorter life or today's music has got a shorter life, while catalog music used to have a much longer life. We have seen this with our own content, with our competition content who had music of late '90s and 2000s. We are now seeing with a brand-new music of our own that music, which once get into the playlist or top of mind of any customer, if he or she starts singing that song, then songs stays with them until the day they die, it remains as a favorite song. So for my father, for him, Dilip Kumar music is the only music that -- which is Mukesh and Mohammed Rafi time. For me, the same thing happened with Bachchan and Kishore Kumar. And in current generation, it will be a Arijit Singh signing for Ranbir Kapoor and that we think will stay.
Okay. And sir, I have one another question. Suppose in India, 50% of streaming companies become paid subscribers. So then our profitability goes up, but then what happens to our breakeven? Because do you think even competition will push the acquisition cost also because our profitability has moved up.
So I stated this, if the streaming platform, which is the one part of our overall revenue mix, the other parts are also equally important. But the streaming business, the day it turns pay will give a huge profit kicker to all of us, not just to me, but to my competition also, which means that payback periods may become shorter. But if the payback periods become shorter, there may be an increase in the content cost. As long as we are still able to go back and maintain a discipline of not picking a content with a payback period of greater than 5 years, we are still in the same space.
My revenue goes up, maybe my cost also goes up. I still maintain a payback period of 5 years. So that's our guiding principle. We do a combination of film music versus non-film music, Hindi music versus Bhojpuri or Gujarati or Bengali or Telugu or Tamil music. And why do we go on and play it in all languages, it gives me a decent -- puts me in a position to balance my investments in each of these languages and ensure that overall basis, I'm still within 5-year payback period.
We have the next question from the line of Ravi Naredi with Naredi Investments Private Limited.
[Foreign Language] What is the benefit to shareholders of Saregama? And what is the business that company is doing?
So that the -- we have got the NCLT approval for the same. Let my CFO speak to you on the legal status.
The shareholders of the company have approved the demerger. The result of the shareholders meeting has also been filed in our petition with NCLT in the month of [Indiscernible]. And the latest is that we are monitoring this and the things are on track. The final order should come to us before 31st March. On benefit side, Vikram do you want to say on non-core part .
See that's the part -- on the benefit side, it's just about getting our company more sharply focused. Around 5, 6 years ago, we made the first round of changes in Saregama where all non-core businesses have got out of them, things which are not core to the business of IP creation and monetization, Saregama walked out of those businesses. There were some other investments that were lying out there within Saregama, and some parts of the business, which were not core to what Saregama does. So [Indiscernible] focus within Saregama, we decided to hive it off as a separate business so that both businesses can do justice to their core. .
Okay. Okay. Sir, second, when we met our QID, when our fund will be utilized in the company, whatever purpose we raised QID.
We are constantly looking at opportunities, thereby if we can pick up catalogs, but at a price point that are value accretive to all our investors. There's no point picking up large catalogs if they come -- at a price point, which makes no financial sense for us. So we are playing -- the good part is we have the money to close the deal at any time. But we are following a very prudent policy so that we don't end up overpaying just because money is sitting there with us.
Right, right. That is intelligent thing.
Internally, I can give you this comfort that we are maintaining a very strong audit on the financial investments because this money has to be utilized only and only for music and nothing else. So this money is typically invested in relatively very low risk debt, so the money is protected and the moment we get opportunities of investing in other businesses, which somewhere are going to help our music business either directly in directly, we will move in immediately. We are any time are in dialogue with at least 4 to 5 companies, but the deals have to happen at the right valuation.
And Vikram, your new initiatives like Diljit Dosanjh and Disco Dancer, please tell few words for same how they are running revenue-wise in our company in third quarter?
Sir, you can see the third quarter numbers, which the Live Event is reported along with Films and Televisions. We did around INR 27 crores. I think for Live Events Q1 and Q2 were bigger because we held concerts in U.S. and Canada in those quarters, quarter 3 were only India as for Diljit Dosanjh is concerned. Live Events business has got 2 reasons why we're doing it. One, yes, there is margin, but the margins are very small here. What it does is that when an artist comes to know that not only can he sing songs for Saregama, but he can also do Live Concerts with Saregama, then the artist wants to work with the company that much more than he wants to work with the competition.
The competition may be offering only songs and nothing else. That's our main edge. So multiple artists are now reaching out to us and saying, listen, we will -- we want to give you our songs, maybe at a discount, but please can you also do something on the live business with us. So it's just building synergies. For us, it's just a natural extension of our music business. We are very clear on the Live Event side, we will do only and only music related [Indiscernible] and start holding executions and conferences, that's not the business that we are in. So if there is a live happening, it will be mostly IP-related and always connected to music.
And sir, last, my question is revenue growth is 25% in 9 months, do you think such growth possible in future and for how much we get?
Sir, music, I'm still -- I'm not going to run away from the fact that there are -- there will be short-term pressure coming here and there in the industry as OTT services move from advertising to subscription, there will be pressures coming in. But we are reasonably confident that the quality of our catalog and our new music acquisition will ensure that we will be writing this 22% to 25% growth even in the short run, definitely in the medium to the long run.
As far as since Events and Live business is concerned, we have been showing that our growth is actually far higher. In 9 months, we have literally grown 100% there. So I don't see too much of a trouble right now for that business also to grow at 25%.
We have next question from Bhupendra Tiwary with ICICI Securities.
My first question was on the new content. So you talked about Ranveer Singh movie, I think 2 Vicky Kaushal movie and then Vijay Deverakonda movie and then couple of regional content apart from, I think, the tie-up we have with Arijit and Sanjay Leela Bhansali, one we released on this time around.
So now one, I just wanted to understand how is the pipeline of content? I think I believe that the movie pipeline itself was smaller last year in terms of the Hindi movie vis-a-vis the pre-COVID times. So how is the overall pipeline, I mean, new content pipeline that we see apart from the big names, so I understand that. And has it changed the economics kind of I think in terms of the competitiveness, has it come down in terms of the content acquisition cost? What are you observing there? That was my first question, after which I'll ask the couple.
The movie production is back in business, 100% now. So COVID -- the problems of COVID are long forgotten now. Also, increasingly you're seeing movies getting released in theater rather than going to a digital platform directly, which is good news because any movie that goes to theater, typically the music of that movie does far better than a movie which is going to the digital platform directly. So you will have visibility on all the 4 big languages, Tamil, Hindi, Telugu and Malayalam. And there are multiple releases lined up both with the bigger stars and the smaller stars, budget movies, smaller budget films.
When we people acquire music in any particular language, we follow a portfolio approach, whereby there are some big more expensive but high-profile films that you end up taking and then multiple smaller to middle budget films that we end up taking. The risk factors are greater in smaller films. But if they fire, they fire big time. Larger budgets typically do well because you pay that much amount of money only and only because there's a big star cast, composer and singers connected to it. So that's how typically this entire planning goes about on the film music side.
Hindi film acquisition typically happens anything around 8 to 12, 15 months in advance of the release of the film, that's a stage at which composes are being finalized and singers are being finalized and situations are being finalized and that is the time often we come in, if it's a large budgets film. If it's a smaller budget film, then we come in only when the songs are fully ready. On the Tamil and the Telugu side, we people end up acquiring music on a typically 6 to 9 months in advance basis for very big guys and maybe a month earlier for smaller budgets films. Have I answered your question?
Yes. I think most of it. Now the second part of the question was -- I mean, second question was largely on the web series. We had a couple of web series lined up for release -- I mean, under the process. So how are they are lining up? And do we expect a couple of them releasing by FY '24, I mean, what is the time line?
So always remember, there always will be a delta between us closing the deal with the platform and handing over the series to them and getting our money and recognizing the revenues, while the platform may take its own time to finally schedule the release of the series, depending on whatever suits them. We are -- our series model is more safer, if I may say so because we typically start work on the series only once we have a mandate from a platform. We are trying to pitch series both on the large scale, as well as the small to medium scale. We are -- at the same time, there's a lot of emphasis going on films in regional languages, which is Malayalam, Punjabi and Marathi, which can first hit the theater and then eventually go to TV and digital platforms.
Sure. So we had 2 or 3 series, if I'm not wrong, which we were working on, which we had announced, 2 I could remember, web series, I think. Has it been -- I mean, has the shooting and all those things completed or it's under...
So majority of the part is completed here, where our deals going on. Unfortunately, our contracts with our platform forbid us to any mention of anything until the time they are not ready to talk about it. So the film business in that sense is simpler because you decide you want to do a film, within 6 to 9 months a film shoot is completed [in a date set]. Series business is a longer wait time because scripting itself takes longer, then production happens and then it's all with the platform to decide when are they ready to announce it.
Sure thing. And the third question, I just wanted -- I mean, I had a doubt, I mean, I saw the presentation. In the streaming partner thing, I couldn't see Gaana. So I was just wondering, I just wanted -- I mean, are we continuing with -- are we on Gaana or it's just that kind of a thing, just last question.
All I can say, as a policy we don't talk about individual partner deals. But I had a similar question being asked to me at the end of quarter 1 on our deal with Meta. And that time also said this, and I'm repeating the same thing here. Often, we will have deals going or deals being put off as part of the negotiation process with various partners of -- our role as a management team is to ensure that while we are negotiating with the partner, and having -- at times having to take a tough stance of pulling off our content from those platforms, the overall revenues cannot fall. If we are pulling off content from one platform, we need to ensure that we get more than -- the customer of that platform moves to some other platform and listens to my song.
So if you are found of listening to our latest Arijit song or Badshah Ka Pani Pani, and if it's not there on platform A, you will go to platform B and listen to it, and we get compensated that way. So in fact, in spite of the fact that we may not be there on some of the platforms in this quarter, my music revenue has still grown by over 20%.
We have next question from the line of Dheeresh Pathak with WhiteOak Capital.
A few questions. First is, what percentage of our YouTube views would have an ad load?
You are audible, but I don't know that you can hear us.
Yes, I can hear you now. So I wanted -- I don't know if you heard my question. What percentage of...
Earlier question. See, I cannot comment as specific in particular as that. The YouTube revenue depends on actually 3 factors. Factor number one, how many views have a music been able to generate, or our videos being able to generate, the number of videos on which an ad is put at the rate at which ads are coming in. So the part 2 and part 3 are more in the hands of YouTube than in our hands, they keep on fluctuating. But overall, we are seeing a healthy growth coming out of YouTube.
Because we have some sense that the views you are anyways sharing with us in aggregate on the YouTube platform, and then based on your top client disclosure, we can work out the monetization per view, it is coming out to be much lower because the only thing that can explain is that you have a very low ad load, your content on YouTube. Otherwise, the number is not making sense to me at least and I can take this offline more clarity.
To clarify this, yes, the rates keep on moving and when we people report the YouTube number data, it's reporting data both for YouTube as well as YouTube shorts, which is a YouTube property, and [Indiscernible]. YouTube shorts is a property, which is very similar to Instagram. So the way -- the simplistic way in which you're trying to arrive at the [Indiscernible] not be the right way to do it. I'm happy to clarify more stuff on offline.
That was useful. Then in the annual report, there is a breakup of the licensing revenue between domestic and international. So what is the basis on which you define those 2 [indiscernible]?
The revenues, which is for our customers outside India, that is [Indiscernible] International and remaining is domestic.
So the client billing might happen outside India, but it is happening for consumption by users of that platform in India, that would might still show up as international, right? .
Well, see, the revenues that we receive are also in foreign currency typically. So we use a consistent benchmark because exactly we will not know what consumption is in India and what is outside of any of that.
Okay. So the international revenue is paid in foreign currency, and that saw a sharp increase as per the annual report last year. The growth when we saw in licensing, a lot of it was from the international revenue. There was not much growth in domestic. So was there a specific reason for that?
That all depends. Right now, the growth was coming. So short of telling you the name of the player. The moment I tell you name of the player, it becomes very obvious why this thing is happening. Some of the biggest boys who are there in this game right now right now are international guys. There's specific deals where there's a huge increase that people saw, and hence you will this number.
Remember whether it's the streaming platforms where some of the bigger names are international guys, as well as video streaming business, some of the biggest guys are international guys.
Yes. So that's what I'm saying. So hypothetically, let's say if it is YouTube, you get YouTube consumption is happening by YouTube users in India, but you struck a deal with them at an international level, so you'll classify that as international revenue stream, right?
The underlying doubt you have you can -- I'll be able to -- I think, answer your question because otherwise you go in circles here. I can't disclose beyond a point on the call, confidential information. So if you can tell me what your concerns is, I'll try to address that.
Actually, when we saw the increase, the breakup, we saw that a lot of the growth came from international revenue. So what I'm trying to understand is -- is the bucketing of the revenue based on consumptions of streaming by users based out of India? Or is it just the billing is happening outside India, but users of that streams are still in India?
Billing. It is nothing to do [Indiscernible]. It depends where is the party with whom we have got the commercial deal being signed with where are they based? And are they asking the Indian entity to do the deal or international entity to do the deal.
Understood. That makes sense. There is a seasonality in Q2. Is there a reason that some renewals happen or the overflow based on minimum guarantee gets billed in Q2 that Q2 is typically a higher quarter, a big quarter?
Actually 3 is the best quarter we have because of factors, one, that is the festival season and Carvaan sales typically does the best in that particular quarter. And then YouTube revenues typically peak at that particular time because of that much -- ads being delivered and the rates are higher, Q3 is the highest, then it's Q2, then it's Q4, then Q1.
Okay. Okay. One last question. This content charge, this comes across various line items, right? Because when you acquire content on the balance sheet, at least my understanding is it is showing up in 3 line items, one is an intangible, second is in inventory and third is in current assets. So this content charge that you mentioning is summation of all those new costs which are capitalized and then expensed through the P&L in operating costs, as well as amortization, as well as royalty, right?
That's correct. So apart from the 3 items on the balance sheet, you also have a marketing cost, which is strictly attached to P&L. That is also part of the content charge as we have defined in our presentation as well.
What you put as intangible versus, what you show in current assets, is it just the genre that regional is put into intangibles and Hindi is put into current assets?
A lot of money is paid as an advance for our content and that's been working. Once it gets released, it moves to your fixed asset portion, which is the intangibles. It's only the stage of the content, which determines where it is going to be placed in the balance sheet.
But everything will initially move to current assets and then will move into intangibles, is that the way to think about it?
Yes. That is usually the life cycle of [indiscernible].
Last annual report, you also put music rights in inventory for the first time. So is there a specific reason for putting it in inventory, which was not there earlier?
Yes. So there are royalty-based deals. The nature of those content acquisition is different, and we have been accounting those consistently under inventory, and that's the reason you find in all the 3 buckets.
The next question is from the line of Nitin Sharma with MCPro Research. .
Can you please talk about the ad rev environment around the YouTube. Some sense, has it slowed down or is it at par, what it was in first quarter or so?
So unlike the western part of the world, we have not seen the advertising scenario as such slowing down on the digital front. And this is -- I'm not going to just talk only about YouTube. If I look at various properties, we have seen that, as always, quarter 1 was a weak quarter, which is traditionally the weak quarter from an advertising perspective. Quarter 3 and both quarter 2 and quarter 3 saw a very, very decent growth on the advertising front, this is a very different narrative from what you will hear from the television world where the revenue seem to be falling down on advertising, but not digital. Our experience shows right now that the revenues are still holding steady. .
Understood. And 2 for bookkeeping question. So what led to fall in the other expenses in this quarter?
So it's actually some of the expenses we had to regroup, reclassify with the revenue. So that's basically a P&L neutral item as it's not impacting P&L. Otherwise, yes, there is no other thing to report on that.
Okay. So is it from item already classified as bad debt and then it got recovered, something like that? .
I will not say with specific line as such, but you are right. Some items were appearing as expensive. As per the accounting principle, we had to net it from the revenue. So on P&L, no impact as such.
Understood. And the last question, I see a clothing segment on your website. Can you please talk about this? .
Could not get you.
There's a clothing segment on your website, I think some T-shirts or catalogs being sold. Can you just talk about it? Is this some promotional activity or a new segment?
You're talking about clothing segment. There are small experiments that are being done right now all times about how to further monetize our IP. Many such experiments run at all times at a very, very small scale. We typically don't talk about it till the time they don't reach at least some substantial chunk. So this is one of the multiple experiments being carried out on the merchandising side. When the segment becomes substantial either in terms of cost, hopefully in terms of revenue, then I'll talk about it, it's just too early.
We have the next question from the line of Savi with 2Point2 Capital. .
I just had a question on the service business. If I look at the segmental results for 9 months, that has fallen as compared to last year, fallen by quite a bit, whereas the capital employed has increased substantially. So while the profitability has decreased by more than 50%, the capital employed has almost doubled. So both the profitability and the return on capital has declined for this segment. Is this -- I mean, how should I read this?
So the first part, you should read it this way that unfortunately or fortunately we are combining the Live Events business also. So whatever impact you're seeing is on the Live Event. Live Event is not even a 1-year old business. It has got its own one-off costs that has been put out here. And hence, you are seeing some profitability being on the lower side on a 9-month basis, still business is healthy enough business. As far you are talking about the money which is locked here, there are multiple large projects that have been kick started as we people try to scale up the entire film business, so that's what's there. You will see many of the films coming out over quarter 4, quarter 1 and quarter 2 of next year.
So you are obviously monitoring the return on capital in the business because at the end of the day that is important in the long run.
Absolutely, I'm with you right now. So there is -- hopefully next year or maybe a year after that will start splitting maybe the Event business separately, then you can actually see. The actual money locked out there on the film side as well as the return that is giving. We have committed to a 15% to 20% margin. That's the only thing I've stated until now on the Films and Series business, and we are holding ourself to that commitment.
Okay. And on the content cost side, where there's obviously a Q-o-Q decline. There's a Y-o-Y increase, but I mean the amount of investments that we are making does not seem to be significant in context of the amount of cash we have. So is it that the competition has increased significantly, and we don't want to partake in that and that's why we are staying away from acquiring...
I'll tell you what exactly has happened here. There were 4 big films that were supposed to be released in quarter 3. And we have -- and hence, and when we people go out there and plan our calendar of releases, we keep in mind that in any particular month, there's no point having too many big projects being released in the same language. Unfortunately, on the Hindi side, lot of films have got been pushed. Seeing the debacle of some of the larger budget films on the Hindi side, many producers went back to the drawing board to further fine tune their films, which has pushed the release dates of some of our films. They were supposed to come out in Q3. Some have now got pushed even beyond quarter 4 to quarter 1 of next year.
Just that aberration that you're seeing in here. We cannot suddenly decide if 3 films are being planned for a quarter, saying, right now those films are not coming, just put some other replacement in. I think also what I'll take in all humility as a learning for us that we should be prepared for this as people go forward and at any time have multiple other things also lying in our back. So this is a problem that you are seeing only and only because of Hindi films getting pushed.
And on the dividend side, I don't know if you can comment on this, but dividend amount seems to be quite substantial. So...
So that's both prerogative as a management team. I have no say in this, all I can tell you right now, I think the intent is very, very clear for many, many years now. Yes, last year also we ended up giving 300% dividend. I think that the intent is very, very clear right now that we want to maintain a track record of being a good dividend paying company. We still -- I'm not running away from all the other commitments I've made to you as a management team member that we are holding ourselves to growth rates of between 22% to 25%, both on the music licensing, as well as [indiscernible]. We are holding on to a commitment that [Indiscernible] will be used only and only for music and nothing else.
So I'm agreeing to those revenue numbers also, I'm agreeing to 32% to 33% profitably operating income [Indiscernible] interest and depreciation, as well as not touching those funds. We believe we are in a position right now to manage all this.
We have next question from the line of [Anika Mittal] with [Indiscernible] Research.
Sir, my question is from, again, from dealing with the earlier participant, like we are seeing the layoff and cost cutting from the organization, right? And cutting on the advertisement cost due to the rising inflation, I think OTT is spending by the players like Netflix due to lower than expected subscription growth, likely to impact our revenue growth. So if that is the case, so do we have any alternative revenue streams that can compensate us because OTT in film segment and advertisement from YouTube has a major impact on our revenue stream.
So we people -- one, you'll be happy to know majority of our revenue which is very, very, very high double-digit numbers, right now it is protected through fixed fee or minimum guarantees. So any quarterly seasonality or even an annual seasonality can be borne by us very, very easily. Second, we have -- we get a share of advertising revenue. We get a share of subscription revenue. A lot of cases, there's a licensing fee that we end up getting. So we are reasonably protected. Nobody is completely protected if the market really starts tanking, but we have been quite prudent over the last 2 years when our numbers -- financial numbers were doing very, very well, and our profitability has been going up. We have not gone overboard, just going out there and increasing our manpower expenses.
If you see the manpower expenses of [Indiscernible] right now as a percentage of profitability, we are falling down. So we did not go overboard increasing our cost structure just because there was a great time that had come in between, and we maintain that kind of a prudence even here. So I'm holding on to our guidance right now of 22% to 25% increase on the revenue side and the profitability in terms of operating income before content, interest and depreciation of 32% to 33%.
That's right. And sir, one more thing. You were talking about this Live Event business. So how much revenue we did in first 9 months, sir?
Overall between Films, Series and Live Events, we have done close to INR 100 crores in the first 9 months.
But the point is, this is a low-margin business. Don't you think the overall ROC will get impacted as long as this business shall increase its share to the overall mix?
But it's an essential core of the business right now. One, we are in the larger business of entertainment, and not just music. Second, even to protect our music business, we need to be there in these segments. Films is something that every competitor of mine is working on. And you can go and check almost every player who is an Indian player who is into music business is also into the film business.
It gives us a very secure way to secure music of the films because we people start getting into the funding of it. Secondly, when we go out there and talk to these digital platforms, almost all of them are now licensing both music and films from us together. So it improves my negotiation position to a very great extent.
Third, as long as these are positive value accretive, they may not give me the same returns in music, but music I can't grow at a rate beyond 23% to 25% unless I'm ready to take a big hit on my margins because to grow at a rate faster than that, I'll have to acquire music at a very, very high cost, which will have a dent on my bottom line. So for us, good mix is that to manage our overall growth ambitions, we continue growing music at a 23% to 25% while maintaining our margins, while get additional growth coming from other areas, which are -- have a synergy with music and also still our positive margin businesses. That's how we look at it.
And one more thing sir, you were talking about advertisements are not going right for the TV world right? So how do you see this thing on our revenue side?
Our dependence on TV advertising is very, very limited. All I can tell you at this juncture is that my TV serials is the only area, which is a smaller part of our business. that we made for Sun TV, where we have some dependence, and we have not seen a fall in quarter 3. But in general, I know in the industry, there has been a substantial fall. TV serial business, the good part is, we also have the IPs owned by us. So we have a -- if there is any fall that we see on television, we are hopefully able to make up for it by putting the same content on YouTube and Facebook.
Just a clarification on the digital side, there is not any issue at all from the advertisement -- YouTube advertisement, right?
Sir, I'll say quarter 2 and quarter 3, we have seen a very decent growth coming out here on the YouTube revenue.
And going forward also, you are not seeing any kind of reduction on digital ad spend? .
It's little difficult for me to give those kind of absolute statements.
Based on your conversations with the people associated in the industry, right? So that's why give an idea only.
Business, what we need to do is to protect and shield ourselves from any one -- if some external industry goes down, it should not affect us too much. If I tell you right now, that if something happens to advertising in YouTube, nothing will change at Saregama, then it will be a false statement. All we can do is to protect ourselves contractually, so through minimum guarantees, through fixed fees and to a diversification of the business that we people are in.
Just to give you comfort, you were talking about Live Event business, while we keep to think that economy is in a state that it is in, for a Diljit Dosanjh show that happened in Bombay, we sold 10,000 tickets. For Diljit Dosanjh show that happened in Gurgaon, we've sold over 12,000 tickets. And these are all tickets, which are upwards of INR 2,000. So there is a market sitting. So we are -- there's a ticketing revenue also coming to us, there are fixed fee, there are advertising, there is licensing, there is physical. There are multiple things that we people are playing in, which gives us protection.
And sir, what's there on the QIP utilization side, can we expect something out of it in the near term?
I think you will prefer that we are delayed, but we do prudent buying rather than overpaying and picking up catalogs, which will not be value accretive to us. So just give us a little more time. I know we are testing your patience, but give us a little more time so that we can pickup catalog at the right pricing. Until that time I show you the money is fully protected and not going to be utilized for anything else.
And so you mentioned quarter 3 is basically your best quarter historically, right? And numbers are also showing that. What is the reason for muted growth Q-o-Q? Because it was festive season and all this thing so.
Yes there is the festival season. Carvaan and YouTube quarter 3 typically ends up doing pretty well. Then, there is also the nature of the contracts that we people have. Usually, all the overflows come out there in quarter 2 or quarter 3 of the financial year, so it happens. So there is that kind of a movement that also happens. I think the best way for you to look at us is look at us always on a trailing 12-month basis. That will give you far more comfort.
Okay. That's the thing. And where do you see our top line by the end of FY '23? And how big do you expect Q4, considering the significant business you did in Q4 FY '22?
So sir, as I said right now, traditionally, Q3 is our best quarter. Our attempt, obviously, will be to maximize the revenues in quarter 4. But the variations are not going to be wild variation that you're talking about here. But traditionally, Q3 is the biggest quarter for us. Let's see which other quarter go. But on a long-term basis, I'm holding on to our guidance of music licensing growing between 22% to 25% and Films, Events and Series business on an annual basis, growing at 25%.
I think that should give you more comfort than just a quarter part because quarters move here and there.
We have next question from the line of Aditya Nahar with Alpna Enterprises.
We move on to the next question. Our next question is from the line of Shubham Ajmera, SOIC Ventures LLP.
Sir, I was going through all our YouTube channels and there one of our main music channel that is Saregama music. There is a degrowth in the number of views on both Q-o-Q, as well as Y-o-Y. So can you please highlight on it? And also on the new movies lined up for the...
There is no degrowth on YouTube views that we people have. Don't -- so I can't comment on a specific channel. We have I think over 32 YouTube channels across all languages. Even in Hindi, we have got multiple channels, not just one channel. We have shared our quarterly numbers on YouTube. Overall YouTube numbers, which is channels viewers user-generated content connected to us and YT shorts and in fact of 44 billion views in Q2 have grown to 53 billion views in quarter 3. .
Sir, I was referring to Saregama music channel.
It's little unfair right now to pick up one channel and you think that's a flagship channel, it may not be. There are multiple channels. I'm happy to get into more details here. But overall, YouTube numbers for us have given a very substantial growth in this quarter. .
Okay, understood. And on the new movies lined up, so how much movies will be coming up in the next quarter and next Q1?
There are big -- at this juncture if I go by the release dates, which have been announced by the producers. And unfortunately, they're completely dependent on them. The lineup is on Hindi side, since you follow Hindi is Karan Johar's directorial movie Rocky Aur Rani Ki Prem Kahani is expected to release in April. If that does, then the songs will start coming out from the month of March. There is Vicky Kaushal, Sara Ali Khan's movie Zara Hatke Zara Bachke. Again, the dates have been announced in February, March as of now. We are still awaiting if they want to change the date. It's a very common practice in our industry for producers to change dates.
Then there is Vicky Kaushal, Ammy Virk film coming called Rola. Then there is Ajay Devgn film coming called Maidaan. Then, there is a movie called Pippa, which is Ronnie Screwvala's film, which in fact was planned for '22, then became early '23, now we're hearing it may go to mid '23. Then there is Vijay Deverakonda and Samantha's very big film called Kushi in Telugu. Specifically naming this because both these artists are very well known in the -- on the Hindi space too. We have Prithviraj Sukumaran's films right now coming in the quarter 1 in Malayalam. We have 2 Suriya films that we people have locked right now, which will be coming hopefully in Q3 of the next financial year.
We have Mammootty film which is locked. We have Ajith film, which is locked. Then on the Tamil side, you have Sivakarthikeyan films also getting locked here. You have Dhanush's film, which is locked. So there's a range of stuff that we people are working in Hindi, Tamil, Telugu and Malayalam, which you will keep on seeing right now over the next few weeks, months, hopefully in the calendar year '23. We have also learned our lessons. So we are going to be prepared right now that if there are a large number of movies getting pushed, then there will be a lot more non-film songs that will keep on coming out.
Understood. Understood. And on the Mango Music, like the acquisition which we have done last year of Mango Music, so just wanted to check like, is it started resulting in the financial terms as well?
Yes, it has. So the numbers, we people have jumped from literally not being a player in Telugu to a clear #2 position in Telugu, which is a combination of some great new music and the Mango catalog acquisition.
Understood. And my last question is on the Carvaan business. So like can you share the product mix in the Carvaan. How much percentage is from the newer mobile versions, which we have launched? And how much is from the older variant per se.
Unfortunately, I'll not be able to share that information. But I've been stating for the last 2 quarters that Carvaan Mobile is playing a substantial enough role. The Carvaan, the old Carvaan is a product -- is a 5-year old product now and has got no marketing support over 3 years now. So it's been a newer product obviously, which is helping us that much more, newer variants of Carvaan, Mini Carvaan, Mobile Carvaan music which is allowing us to sell these many number of units.
Ladies and gentlemen that was the last question. And now I'd like to hand the conference back over to Mr. Vikram Mehra for closing comments. Over to you, sir.
I'll just repeat whatever I said earlier. We maintain our bullish stance on music licensing. We expect a 22% to 25% annual growth over the next 3 to 5 years. The next 12 months -- where 12 to 18 months, where we will see the transition of the OTT or the music streaming industry to move from an ad-based model to a subscription-based model will have its short-term pressures and things will go topsy turvy, but the moment I start looking at 18 to 36 or 5 years, 60-month horizon, I see a very stable growth of revenue coming in.
But even during this period, we are confident that we will be -- this period means next 12 to 18 months. We are confident we should be able to handle these pressures because of the diversified nature of our revenue and increasing market share in the space of music. We will continue with our investments, aggressive investments both on film and the non-film music side across all the major leading languages of the country. We are on constant watch out and conversations with multiple companies which are either music catalogs or companies which are connected to the world of music, may not be directly holding catalog, but may help us a lot in promoting new music.
We're talking to a multiple of them and I'm seeing right now, if any acquisition is possible at the valuation that makes financial sense. We continue with a cautious approach on Carvaan, and the focus will continue to manage our margins and not the top line. Carvaan will continue at least to do breakeven. The film series and the events vertical, I expect it to grow at 20%, 25% growth year-on-year, and we hope to make anything around 15% margin on this business.
The events verticals specifically will have ups and downs on the quarterly side depending on how many events in a quarter have you been able to go out there into. It will take a couple of years right now before the stability that comes in, and this will be a very low-margin business at least first couple of years. We will continue with this because strategically, it helps us a lot on our music acquisition side. Overall, I show you guys once again that we are well protected from the vagaries of advertising revenues going up and down on a quarterly basis. Yes, is the long-term impact on the economy, we will get affected.
But hopefully, we are well prepped and don't have that high cost structure for us to suffer in case things go dramatically wrong. I'm hopeful right now that we will maintain our profitability and the growth projections we have given you in short to medium term basis. That would be all. Thank you guys, bye-bye.
Thank you very much, sir. Ladies and gentlemen, on behalf of ICICI Securities that concludes this conference. Thank you for joining us. You may now disconnect your lines.