Stericycle Inc
NASDAQ:SRCL
If you don’t study any companies, you have the same success buying stocks as you do in a poker game if you bet without looking at your cards.
Utilize notes to systematically review your investment decisions. By reflecting on past outcomes, you can discern effective strategies and identify those that underperformed. This continuous feedback loop enables you to adapt and refine your approach, optimizing for future success.
Each note serves as a learning point, offering insights into your decision-making processes. Over time, you'll accumulate a personalized database of knowledge, enhancing your ability to make informed decisions quickly and effectively.
With a comprehensive record of your investment history at your fingertips, you can compare current opportunities against past experiences. This not only bolsters your confidence but also ensures that each decision is grounded in a well-documented rationale.
Do you really want to delete this note?
This action cannot be undone.
| 52 Week Range |
44.3
80.3
|
| Price Target |
|
We'll email you a reminder when the closing price reaches USD.
Choose the stock you wish to monitor with a price alert.
This alert will be permanently deleted.
Stericycle Inc
Earnings Call Analysis
Q3-2023 Analysis
Stericycle Inc
The company reported a solid organic revenue growth of 7.5% since 2021, indicating a recovery and adaptability post-COVID-19. They credit this growth to their role in providing essential services, particularly within their Secure Information Destruction business.
Despite experiencing a decline of about 4% in service stops primarily due to customer site closures and reduced service frequency, the company is optimistic about the long-term contributions of Secure Information Destruction, emphasizing its commitment to employing technology and innovative customer insights.
The company completed several strategic divestitures and a targeted workforce reduction in continuation of its efforts to streamline operations and focus on core markets to drive margin expansion and enhance shareholder value.
Revenues decreased to $653.5 million in the third quarter compared to $690.3 million in the previous year. The company faces challenges with lower Secure Information Destruction revenues and commodity index fluctuations, impacting both service revenue and recycling paper revenues. They expect to buffer about 30% of the volatility from these declines for the rest of the year.
Income from operations saw a significant decline from the same quarter last year, stemming largely from lower commodity index revenues and margin flow-through impact. However, the company reports healthy operating cash flow, with a focus on using its financial resources judiciously, including debt repayment.
The company has revised their organic revenue growth rate downwards to 2% to 3% and narrowed the adjusted earnings per share guidance. Additionally, they have adjusted their capital expenditure guidance and free cash flow expectations, accounting for various operational factors such as settlements and targeted workforce reductions.
Focusing on portfolio optimization remains a key priority, with the company balancing between divestitures and strategic acquisitions to bolster its business model and market position.
You don't have any saved screeners yet
Good day, and thank you for standing by. Welcome to the Q3 2023 Stericycle Earnings Conference Call. [Operator Instructions] Be advised that today's conference is being recorded. And I would now like to hand the conference over to your speaker today, Mr. Andrew Ellis, Sir, please go ahead.
Good morning, and thank you for joining Stericycle's 2023 Third Quarter Earnings Call. On the call today will be Cindy Miller, our Chief Executive Officer; Janet Zelenka, our Chief Financial Officer and Chief Information Officer; and Cory White, our Chief Commercial Officer.
The discussion today includes forward-looking statements that involve risks and uncertainties. When we use words such as: believes, expects, anticipates, estimates, may, plan, will, goal or similar expressions, we are making forward-looking statements.
Forward-looking statements are prospective in nature and are not based on historical facts, but rather on current expectations and projections of our management about future events and are, therefore, subject to risks and uncertainties. Our actual results could differ significantly from those described in such forward-looking statements. Factors that could cause our actual results to differ are discussed in the safe harbor statement in our earnings press release and in greater detail within the risk factors in our filings with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.
Our past financial performance should not be considered a reliable indicator of our future performance, and investors should not use historical results to anticipate future results or trends. We disclaim any obligation to update or revise any forward-looking statement other than in accordance with legal and regulatory obligations.
On the call, we will discuss non-GAAP financial measures. For additional information and reconciliation to the most comparable U.S. GAAP measures, please refer to the schedules in our earnings press release, which can be found on Stericycle's Investor Relations website at investors.stericycle.com. The prepared comments for today's call correspond to an earnings presentation, which is also available at Stericycle's Investor Relations website. Throughout the call, we will reference specific slides from the presentation.
This call is being recorded, and a replay will be available approximately 1 hour after the end of the conference call today, until November 30, 2023. A replay of the webcast will be available on Stericycle's Investor Relations website.
Time-sensitive information provided during today's call, which is occurring on November 2, 2023 may no longer be accurate at the time of a replay. Any redistribution, retransmission or rebroadcast of this call in any form without the expressed written consent of Stericycle is prohibited. I'll now turn the call over to Cindy.
Thank you, Andrew. Good morning, everyone, and welcome to today's call. I'm pleased to share that in the third quarter, through the hard work and dedication of our team members and technology partners we successfully deployed the ERP system to our U.S. regulated waste and compliance services business. Today, almost all of our U.S. team members are leveraging the new technology. .
I'd like to take a few minutes to update you on the ERP deployment. I'm proud to say that we grew North America Regulated Waste and Compliance Services organic revenues by 3.9% in the third quarter in the midst of a major ERP deployment. To give you greater insights into the deployment, I'll speak to the operations portion, and then I'll turn the call over to Cory to provide an update from a customer experience perspective and how it has improved some of our commercial processes.
We continued to prepare for this deployment throughout the quarter as we finalize data conversion, training and facility upgrades. We launched the deployment in early September, when we began servicing our customers through the new technology.
From an operational perspective, we couldn't be more pleased with our team members' ability to continue to serve our customers since the system deployed. We experienced the typical start-up learning curve that comes when processes change and are infused with new technology.
For our frontline workers, this resulted in an anticipated and temporary reduction in productivity. As the team has become more familiar with the changes in processes and procedures, we are seeing continued improvements, and we expect that this new technology will contribute significantly to our ability to achieve the margin expansion embedded in our long-term outlook.
I'll now turn the call over to Cory, who has been deeply engaged in helping our U.S. regulated waste and compliance services customers transition onto the new ERP. It will provide insights from our customers.
Cindy, thank you for the opportunity on today's call to share our customers' experience throughout the ERP journey, and highlight some of the exciting ways this new technology will help us improve commercial execution.
Overall, the rollout of the ERP was a success. We have had no significant system issues. Orders are being created, stops are being routed, containers are being tracked, waste is being picked up, treated and properly disposed and invoices are being created and processed for both regulated waste and compliance services and secure information destruction customers.
Along this journey, we have been in frequent contact with our customers, and they are not reporting any major disruptions. We track customer satisfaction trends weekly across our customer base.
During the first couple of weeks of September, our customer satisfaction scores understandably dropped as some of our customers experienced short-term disruption. Our scores have since improved and are already above pre-go-live levels.
Following the deployment for the first time, we now have real-time capability to see order completion in the system. We are pleased that an overwhelming majority of orders are serviced seamlessly.
We have seen an expected increase in our customer call center volume. Importantly, the majority of this increase is from customers requesting assistance, understanding the new invoice format, enrolling in the customer portal, setting up autopay or verifying new account numbers. We view these interactions as a favorable sign of our customers' engagement with, and adoption of the new platform and how smoothly the ERP deployment has gone for the vast majority of our customers.
I'd now like to highlight a few ways in which we have modernized and improved the customer experience through the ERP deployment. One, we've added important digital enhancements, including redesigned portals that act as a one-stop shop for customers to view account information, receive consolidated billing for services and sites and pay for their services.
Two, for our compliance services customers, we integrated the portal with our compliance training platform to create a single solution to meet their needs.
Three, customers now receive automated advanced service notifications to help them better plan their days, a feature requested by our customers so they know when they will be serviced.
Four, we also made enhancements to our secure chain of custody, and can now track waste at the container level through the entire service life cycle in real time.
Five, in the near future, we expect that our portal will provide new and enhanced reporting features that will allow customers to easily access weight and volume metrics, benchmark and optimize waste streams and gain greater insights, which can be used in pursuit of their sustainability goals.
Over the past few months, I've met personally with well over 100 customers during face-to-face meetings as well as lunch and learn events to elicit their feedback, which has been overwhelmingly positive. They have been supportive of our move to new systems, and are clearly excited about how our new capabilities will unlock opportunities to better service them.
Recently, one of our key customers told me how pleased they were with the deployment. They appreciated the proactive communication on changes we made to their account and like the enhancements we made to the portal. They also said they did not get any negative feedback from their internal stakeholders. They saw this as a sign of a successful deployment, citing that Silence is Golden for managing these kinds of major changes.
I'd like to take a moment now to talk about how our commercial organization is using the technology to become more nimble and efficient. All of our salespeople in the U.S. are now utilizing the new system for 5 key processes: lead development, pipeline management, performance management, reporting and contracting.
This is a major step forward on our quality of revenue journey and our ability to execute on key business priorities, which includes expanding service penetration, improving customer implementation velocity and deepening our customer partnerships by developing enhanced customer solutions.
By operating on a common platform, we are improving our proficiency and selling effectiveness for both the Regulated Waste and Secure Information Destruction businesses, while driving greater consistency and accountability throughout the sales process. The platform also lays the foundation for future enhancements like digital and guided selling capabilities and additional call center automation.
Finally, by unlocking data and related insights, we expect this will lead to more intelligent sales decisions, new product development and service enhancement opportunities as we continue to listen to the voice of our customers.
I'll now turn the call back to you, Cindy.
Thank you for that update, Cory. Turning to our third quarter results. I'm pleased to report that in the third quarter, Regulated Waste and Compliance Services continued its organic growth trend, increasing 4.1% globally even during a period of ERP deployment.
Growth this quarter has primarily come from our pricing levers. This has been partially offset by challenges in national accounts, which includes customers like retail pharmacies and nationwide health care service providers. These customers have remained very sticky despite the economic headwinds they are facing.
As our customers reduce their footprint, our service stops in this channel have also contracted. We remain encouraged that the critical services we provide remain a priority for these customers.
Secure Information Destruction organic revenue declined 11.6%, mainly due to lower commodity index revenues, including lower RISI rates impacting sorted office paper and lower fuel and environmental surcharges. Although this revenue channel was down year-over-year, the third quarter of 2022 had significant organic revenue growth of 32.3% on the strength of commodity-related pricing. When considering Secure Information Destructions organic growth over a 2-year compound annual growth rate, it grew organic revenues 7.5% since 2021.
Similar to regulated waste, our national Secure Information Destruction customers are experiencing a reset in their post-COVID pandemic office footprint. Across the Secure Information Destruction business, we believe we remain an essential service and are retaining these customer relationships, but have seen service stops decline year-over-year by about 4%, mainly driven by customer site closures and reduced service frequencies.
In the long run, we believe Secure Information Destruction will contribute to our long-term growth trajectory by leveraging technology, deeper customer insights and new service offerings.
Regarding our operational efficiency, modernization and innovation priority, most of our engineering team members were squarely focused on deploying the ERP and executing our facility modernization plan. During the deployment, our engineering team supported all aspects of field operations, such as training, communication, site visits to ensure technology was working as designed and identifying and driving performance opportunities.
Additionally, construction of our incinerator in McCarran, Nevada remains on track, and we continue to expect the construction phase of the project to be completed in the first half of 2024.
As mentioned during our second quarter earnings call, we completed 2 divestitures in the third quarter, with the sale of our dental recycling business in the Netherlands, which closed in July, and the sale of our Secure Information Destruction joint venture in the United Arab Emirates, which closed in August.
In early October, we also divested our Regulated Waste business in Romania, our 19th divestiture since 2019.
In October, we substantially completed a targeted workforce reduction that we expect will generate annual savings of approximately $8 million and resulted in an approximate $3 million charge.
As we look to drive long-term margin expansion and shareholder value, we have a host of levers available. These levers are further enabled by our investments in our ERP technology and infrastructure and include strategic initiatives, careful hiring, attrition and targeted workforce reductions to align our operating model with the performance of our business.
I will now turn the call over to Janet to discuss our third quarter financial results in more detail.
Thank you, Cindy. I will start by summarizing our third quarter financial results. As noted on Slide 5, revenues in the third quarter were $653.5 million compared to $690.3 million in the third quarter of 2022. The decrease was mainly due to divestitures of $32.4 million, which was partially offset by favorable foreign exchange rates of $6.1 million.
Organic revenues in Regulated Waste and Compliance Services grew $17.4 million, while Secure Information Destruction organic revenues declined $27.9 million. Secure Information Destruction was mainly impacted by lower commodity index revenues of $30.1 million, including lower RISI rates, impacting sorted office paper and lower fuel and environmental surcharges.
As noted on Slide 6, Regulated Waste and Compliance Services revenues were $439.9 million compared to $447.8 million in the third quarter of 2022. Excluding the impact of divestitures and foreign exchange rates, organic revenues increased 4.1% in the third quarter.
In North America, Regulated Waste and Compliance Services organic revenues increased $13.9 million or 3.9% during the quarter of the ERP deployment, mainly driven by our pricing actions.
International Regulated Waste and Compliance Services organic revenues increased $3.4 million or 5.4%, mainly driven by our pricing levers, partially offset by lower waste volumes compared to the third quarter of 2022. International waste volumes continue to be impacted by health care staffing shortages and intermittent strikes.
Secure Information Destruction revenues were $213.6 million compared to $242.5 million in the third quarter of 2022. Excluding the impact of foreign exchange rates, organic revenues decreased 11.6%, mainly due to lower commodity index revenues, reflecting more than a $100 reduction in sorted office paper pricing per ton year-over-year.
In North America, Secure Information Destruction organic revenues declined $25.5 million or 11.9% compared to the third quarter of 2022. In the third quarter, recycling paper revenues were down approximately 7.6% or $16.3 million due to lower RISI rates affecting sorted office paper pricing and lower tonnage.
In the quarter, service revenue was down approximately 4.3% or $9.2 million, mainly driven by lower fuel and environmental surcharges and lower service stops, as Cindy mentioned. Excluding these surcharges, service revenue was up $2 million.
Approximately 1/3 of the lower sorted office paper recycling revenue was offset by our recycling recovery surcharge reflected in service revenue. Under more normal RISI rate circumstances, when sorted office paper prices are below $192 a ton, we are able to offset approximately 60% of the reduction in paper prices.
Given that the year-over-year decline in paper prices was over $100 a ton, we were able to offset approximately 1/3 of the lower SOP recycling revenue through our recycling recovery surcharge reflected in service revenue in the third quarter. This is due to the nature of the index for this surcharge, and we expect it to offset about 30% of the volatility when comparing to last year for the rest of 2023.
Our international Secure Information Destruction organic revenues decreased $2.3 million or 9.2% compared to the third quarter of 2022, mainly due to lower recycling revenues and fuel and environmental surcharges.
Income from operations in the third quarter was $24.2 million compared to $50.6 million in the third quarter of 2022. The $26.4 million decrease was mainly due to lower commodity index revenues and the corresponding margin flow-through impact of $22.2 million. The decrease was also due to anticipated higher incentive and stock-based compensation of $7.2 million and a self-insurance settlement of $2.2 million. These were partially offset by cost savings of $8.6 million and lower bad debt expense of $3.2 million.
Net income was $2 million or $0.02 diluted earnings per share compared to $28 million or $0.30 diluted earnings per share in the third quarter of 2022. The $26 million decrease was mainly due to lower income from operations of $26.4 million, as I just explained.
Cash flow from operations for the 9 months ended September 30, 2023, was $193.3 million compared to $43.1 million in the same period of 2022. The year-over-year increase of $150.2 million was mainly driven by lower FCPA settlement payments of $72.8 million, improved accounts receivable collections net of deferred revenues of $55 million and lower annual incentive compensation payments of $22.3 million.
Adjusted income from operations was $70.3 million or 10.8% as a percentage of revenues, down from $92 million or 13.3% as a percentage of revenues in the third quarter of 2022.
Adjusted income from operations decreased 250 basis points as a percentage of revenues due to the following: lower sorted office paper and fuel and environmental surcharges and their corresponding margin flow-through impact of 340 basis points, higher incentive and stock-based compensation of 110 basis points and a self-insurance settlement of 30 basis points. These were partially offset by cost savings and margin flow-through of 150 basis points and lower bad debt expense of 50 basis points.
As noted on Slide 8, adjusted diluted earnings per share was $0.43 compared to $0.65 in the third quarter of 2022. Excluding the impact from divestitures and foreign exchange rates of $0.02, the remaining $0.20 year-over-year decline was driven by lower commodity index revenues of $0.19, higher incentive and stock-based compensation of $0.06, higher taxes, interest and other of $0.03 and a self-insurance settlement of $0.02. These were partially offset by cost savings and margin flow-through of $0.07 and lower bad debt expense of $0.03.
Capital expenditures for the 9 months ended September 30, 2023, were $102.2 million compared to $106 million for the same period last year.
Free cash flow for the 9 months ended September 30, 2023, was an inflow of $91.1 million compared to an outflow of $62.9 million in the same period of 2022. As noted on Slide 9, the year-over-year improvement of $154 million was mainly due to higher cash flow from operations of $150.2 million.
DSO was reported for September 30, 2023, was 63 days or 55 days net of deferred revenues. During the third quarter, we began to invoice certain regulated waste and compliance services subscription-based customers in advance, which contributed to the higher as reported DSO for September 30, 2023. DSO was recorded for September 30, 2022, was 63 days or 62 days net of deferred revenue.
The September 30, 2023 DSO, net of deferred revenues was lower as compared to the same period in 2022, mainly driven by the improved timing of FID customer billing and collections.
As shown on Slide 10, at the end of the third quarter, we maintained our credit agreement defined debt leverage ratio below 3x, achieving a ratio of 2.84x.
As Cindy noted, we recently completed 3 divestitures for a total of 8 divestitures in 2023. In 2022, the Romania medical waste business and the Netherlands dental recycling business collectively contributed less than 1% of revenues and had approximately breakeven adjusted EBITDA.
On Slide 11, we have removed the divested revenues from our 2022 baseline. The joint venture in the UAE was accounted for as an equity investment and included in noncontrolling interest. Collectively, these businesses were sold for a nominal amount of net proceeds.
As noted on Slide 11, we are providing our updated 2023 guidance, taking in consideration our expectations for the fourth quarter. We have lowered our organic revenue growth rate range to 2% to 3% from 3% to 5%, mainly due to the impact of commodity index revenues.
We have narrowed our adjusted earnings per share guidance range to $1.80 to $1.95 from $1.75 to $2.05. This updated range reflects the impact of a self-insurance settlement in the third quarter and potential commodity volatility that I mentioned earlier.
We have narrowed our capital expenditure guidance to $135 million to $145 million from $125 million to $145 million. This reflects our expectation on the timing of cash outlays associated with the McCarran incinerated project.
We have modified our free cash flow range to $170 million to $190 million from $175 million to $205 million. This is mainly driven by our expectation that we will be at the high end of our capital expenditure guidance range, the self-insurance settlement and severance associated with our targeted workforce reduction mentioned by Cindy. These 3 items could potentially result in an incremental cash outflow of approximately $10 million to $15 million in the fourth quarter, higher than we previously planned.
Excluded from our free cash flow guidance as adjusted litigation payments of which we paid approximately $13 million in the third quarter and expect to pay approximately $5 million to $12 million in the fourth quarter.
I will now turn the call back to Cindy.
Thank you, Janet. One of Stericycle's core values is that we embrace diversity and inclusion. Aligning with this core value, I'm excited to share that earlier this week, we were recognized for the third consecutive year by Women in Trucking as one of the top companies for women to work for. This award highlights our focus on creating a rewarding and positive work environment for all of our team members.
And as always, I'd like to thank our customers, team members, the communities we serve and our shareholders for their continued trust in having Stericycle protect what matters.
Operator, please open the line for Q&A.
[Operator Instructions] Our first question will come from Sean Dodge of RBC Capital Markets.
Yes. And I'll start by asking my congratulations on the successful ERP deployment. I know that's been a big lift. So it's got to feel really nice to have that done now.
Thanks, Sean.
On the -- you all shared the update there. It sounds like so far, so good, being now more than a full month into that, having used it, are we pretty much out of the woods now as far as figuring out if there are any glitches or bugs left or not? And I guess, at what point can we declare all clear here? And then where do you think the dangers or risks still lie going forward?
Yes, Sean, thanks for that question, and thanks for the congratulations. I can tell you the -- we are tremendously proud of the overall journey that our team members and support folks have had. It was quite a learning for us, putting a company with no technology really onto a platform a couple of years ago, and the amount of lessons learned leading up to putting this business unit on which had far more complexities. And for it to have gone as well as it has, and continues to. We're really very, very happy about it.
And I think the good news is, as Cory had said in his remarks, there isn't customer disruption. Most of everything has gone off pretty seamlessly. And I think the testimony to that is do we still have -- are there major issues? I think we've put those to bed. We know where they are. We're still fixing a few things. But I think for us, we're now almost morphing from worrying about where are the ghosts in the system to correcting the problems that we've identified, and now even moving towards, all right, where are the next enhancements? And any time you do that in the system, the sooner you can get to your enhancements, the things you forgot, the thing that would make something a little bit more intuitive, the suggestions back from the field, I think we've gotten to that point certainly much faster than any of us anticipated, which is really, really good news.
So Janet, any other insights?
I think, Cindy, you said it very well. We have actually also billed. And as a reminder, about 70% of the billing is subscription-based. So we have gotten those [ billed ] out actually at the start of the month and continue to [ bill ] that through.
If there's anything we're looking at, it's being very thoughtful of the transactional billing that's going down to make sure it's accurate, but don't anticipate that to be a big issue. And to Cindy's point, we are moving into where can we enhance the system for -- rather than where is it broken. We do have a few incidents left, as you would expect, the lower the volume than we expected to have at this point in time.
And I think, Sean, one last thing, just to wrap that up. Right now, everybody at least understands how to use it, but everybody hasn't really developed their own. We all develop the routine and the nuance of how we make it work faster or how we know to click through things. I think we're developing that right now. And so there's still some learning, there's still some change management to go on. Not everybody has adopted it or has become as proficient as everybody else at the same time. But for the most part, I think major, major potential issues with customers, with revenue recognition and those types of things, I think those are well behind us.
And I think to your point, as you mentioned that we went live actually running the trucks at the beginning of September. The quarter was spent in getting ready, but the truck started rolling in the beginning of September. So we do have a good month and more under our belt, a month in the quarter and more than that as we talk today.
Okay. Great. And then, Janet, on both the EPS and the free cash guidance for Q4, implies a bit of a step-up from Q3. Can you just walk us through what's expected to drive that, anything you have about visibility there? Is this kind of the benefits of the workforce reduction kind of improving productivity? Anything else?
Yes. So we have some real key items that will help us drive there. One is we've had that incentive comp, which underneath that is a stock comp acceleration that was due to retirement benefits I mentioned earlier. That basically ends in the fourth quarter. So that's a few cents of uplift.
We had that onetime self-insurance claim that won't repeat, and that will be an uplift, if you're looking quarter-to-quarter. We see fuel helping us a bit in the quarter as you see that it has been mitigated as the price, and then we can see continued [indiscernible] and bad debt from quarter-to-quarter.
So those are some of the key [indiscernible] and I'm not even talking about the continued to improve as we get more confident on the system and from the learning curve that Cindy mentioned. So we see a good line of sight to that EPS and then the cash flow, similar sort of some of the follow suit.
Okay. Great. And then congratulations again.
Thanks, Sean. Appreciate it. .
One moment please for our next question. And our next question will come from Scott Schneeberger of Oppenheimer & Company.
I'd like to share my congratulations. I know how much the whole organization has worked hard in preparation for this. So great that you've followed [indiscernible] the switch. I'm curious, is there -- you covered a lot of the updates very well. I believe you were running on parallel systems throughout the process. Could you give us an update on how dependent you are still on parallel systems? And a follow-up to this, getting onward and upward. Is this thinking about international and time line we should consider now that you're off and running in the U.S.?
Yes. Scott, what I'll do is I'll take that international portion of the question on 2 fronts. And then in terms of the duplicative systems that we have, the legacy and the new one, I'll let Janet handle that.
In terms of international, a couple of things. We've now had 19 divestitures since 2019. And that's done a few things. Number one, certainly, from an overall portfolio, our ability to manage things, that has certainly helped us. But the other thing it's done, as you can imagine, is tying into the answer Janet is going to give you is, we've got 19 less countries and places and geographies and business units that we have to figure out how to put on this new platform.
So this has afforded us an opportunity not just to improve balance sheet, not just to improve oversight, not just to manage the business better, not just to use proceeds to pay down debt, this has also afforded us the opportunity to shrink the footprint of what's going to be required that's going to have to continue to go on to this new platform.
So I think -- and then in terms of actual portfolio optimization, which is one of the key priorities, we still leave that on there, because I did talk about 19 divestitures, but we've also had an acquisition. So -- and Scott, you've been on the journey with us since the beginning. We originally talked about portfolio divestitures. Then we morphed it to optimization figuring that at some point in time, we might get a stable enough balance sheet where we would have options to not just be focused on divestiture, but also become focused on potential tuck-in acquisitions.
Now that we understand more about the business, where are our strengths, where do we have a great footprint. So I think we're leaving it on there for both things, potentially divestiture, but then also from an acquisition perspective.
So now I'll morph it back to Janet. Janet, with reference to the duplicative systems, how much more to go on? And what do you see?
Yes. So we put the U.S. on. Meaning, we put all the revenue on and we put all our core waste processing. So all the waste stations, everything that is a [indiscernible] incinerator is running on it. We have a few, what I'll call edge cases of hybrid model where they're actually partially using the system, but have some small unique areas that we need to still put on, but that should be not a long putt to get there.
Now we do have Canada, which is a much smaller part that is on our journey to move. But I would call the ERP in the U.S. and what we're looking for in North America largely done, which is very exciting.
In terms of the legacy applications, they are still used right now in Canada, as I mentioned, but also internationally. So that is the next journey we're on, and the international team is very active working on the data cleanup and starting to start requirements next year, with a goal to start moving off of that around the 2025 time frame.
Meanwhile, while we continue to take that $20 million to $30 million out in the longer term, we are looking for ability to rightsize the legacy platform, which may give us some opportunity next year as we continue to look at it.
And I think one thing, too, just as a point, Scott, just a little bit more than 80% of all of our volume runs through the platform currently. So I hope that puts some things into perspective, too, in terms of size.
Yes. And just for Canada fit is on the platform, Secure Information Destruction, so I'm only talking about RWCS is the only piece left for Canada.
Yes. Got it. That's very helpful, very comprehensive. I -- another 2 parter as my second question. The first part is, what are you anticipating for sort of office paper going forward? Just what are the trends that you're seeing? What do you expect as you look ahead here, what's implicit in the fourth quarter? Janet, I guess that's mostly for you.
Cindy, you had mentioned that -- let me go back to the notes. The -- a few sites, a few customers. This is on information construction. A few site closures in this post-pandemic period and lesser pickup frequency. I just wanted to -- will turn to that for a second. I don't think I've heard that from you all before. I just want to hear what -- how you feel about that trend? Is that something new? Or is that something you've seen consistent? I just want to delve in a little bit more on that.
Got you. And Scott, I can kind of help you with both of them. First of all, in terms of the RISI rate, what I think -- I said coming out of pandemic, we were going to learn a lot. And I think now a few years out, here's what we've learned. I think 2022 is the anomaly. That year, the average price of paper, with people figuring out who's coming back to work, who's going out to eat, what's the demand on travel, what's the demand on all these things? It really put an immediate pressure on a lot of commodities, specifically paper that's used in a lot of the essential things that we use, and I think it averaged the year somewhere around 235. That in and of itself is an anomaly. But Q3 last year versus Q3 this year, it's a difference from -- we're looking at $254 in September last year, down to $140 in October of this year.
But the trend that we're seeing, and here's, I think, the good news. The good news is prior to 2022 being now just a complete outlier, prior to that, the 15-year average has been about $150 a ton. And right now, today, it's about $140. That seems pretty reasonable in terms of if you look -- if you take 2022 out of there, it's now more normalized, which I think is a good sign for society. It's a good sign that we've gotten into a rhythm of where is demand. So I think we need to level set that.
What are we seeing going into Q4? Right now, it's maintained around $140 over the last several months, which is a good, stable number, I think, in terms of showing that it isn't showing the wild swings as much as it had over the last, let's say, 6, 7 quarters. So I think that's really good news there. And we know how to manage at that. That's more normal for the business. And quite frankly, once the RISI rate gets below $192 a ton, our surcharge will help mitigate more like about 60% of whatever the volatility is. So I think all that's good.
If I go to the second portion of the question about that national channel, that national account channel base that we have, we're seeing similar things for the national accounts in both regulated as well as shred. And what that nuance is, we've seen it over the course of the last couple of quarters, and what it's been is on the regulated side, those national accounts, those large retail pharmacies, you read headlines, I read headlines.
There's an awful lot of store closures. There's potential bankruptcies. There's a lot of things that are going on in that space. And quite frankly, that space not only uses us for regulated, but they also use us for shred. And when you have a footprint which is thousands of stores and you choose to close down 1,000 of them, that definitively means we -- they still use us. They just don't have a facility in a particular town that requires that service anymore. So -- and we're seeing that on regulated.
And then on the shred side, when we take a look at shred, we're looking at that customer base that is now figuring out, hey, most of our people are now back at work. This is going to be our new rhythm for right now as they continue to figure out how to cut their costs, how to right -- how to reset their future so that they can position themselves to grow. So they may have closed down some sites, they may have reduced some frequencies, still requiring our service, but getting used to whatever their new normal is.
So I don't see any of those themes as anything that's lingering, anything that's going to continue to a great degree. I think we've seen this shift and this change through our larger national account channel base, and I see now an opportunity for that to stabilize. And now I can tell you, Cory and his team are just positioned to grow. So that's where we sit and that's the trend that we see.
And one moment, please for our next question. Our next question will come from Dave Manthey of Baird.
Mr. Manthey, if your line's on mute, please unmute your line. If using a headset, please put on your headset.
Hello, Sir. Are you able to hear us? Mr. Dave Manthey?
Speaker's [indiscernible], I'll move to the next person.
Our next question will come from Michael E. Hoffman of Stifel.
Cindy, Janet, I was never in doubt. So well done.
Thanks, Michael.
Well, you tested the bejesus out of it. So I knew you had pushed it and pulled it and tugged on it a lot. But to that end, again, we're right in the beginning of billing, and billing was a challenged [indiscernible] it. You fixed it. You tested that really hard in Puerto Rico. What are you seeing relative to that sort of baseline of knowledge? What are you seeing at the moment?
We're seeing a much more astute understanding and we have reporting in place to track billing and pricing and contracts and everything that impact billing from day 1. And I think that's the big difference that we see because we knew what to look for. There's a lot of complexity in RWCS in terms of its contracts and pricing.
So -- but there's also -- when you get to the transactional piece, but there's also the service revenue side that is a subscription base that is actually easier. And as you heard me mention, we actually did -- that we moved that to be a month ahead of time for most of our customers. So that was a switch we did. So that needs -- that's a little customer change management that we're watching, but so far so good. That has the potential in the long term to be a cash flow benefit for us.
And then we've been very thoughtful and been auditing all the transactional revenue that we're sending out through billing, and putting what they call payer blocks or other blocks on to make sure it's right before it goes out. So there's been a lot of thought on the team.
So far, so good. We may have some of the transaction be a little later. We'll have a subscription be a little earlier, and I think we'll wash out very well.
All right. Cool. And then beginning of the year, you revised some of the parameters around your outlook, and you've reaffirmed those in this document today, 13% to 17% EBITDA, 50% free cash. When do we start seeing that happen, now that 80% of the volume is on one platform and a lot of people can be held accountable in a good way. When do I start seeing the benefit of that 13% to 17% and that 50% cash conversion?
Yes. I think what we've talked about is taking year-end 2023 and then build from there. And more of that is based off of the timing of this ERP, the focus that we can then put into maturing that process as well as several others.
So a couple of things we talk about as being levers that we have. Right now that the ERP is in and as we mature with this and that folks get back -- get better, get smoother, we put in a few enhancements to help really facilitate things working and going -- flowing through our plants and out the customers a little easier.
There's an opportunity then for us. We've been leaning into attrition, and we talk about removing the manualness. I've often said, at some point in time, when you get a technology system that can move data for you as opposed to needing to move it paper or needing to move statistics or needing to swivel chair things from one system to the next, that there should be a removal of a lot of that manual intervention.
So for us, I think we've got a continued -- or maybe an additional targeted workforce reduction as we continue to develop these things. And like I said, we will still lean into attrition with controlled hiring. I think as we get better with our infrastructure, with any of the operational improvements, the ERP improvements that we can continue to fine-tune for efficiency, for productivity, for scheduling, for engagement with customers, I think all of those things in combination are things that we will enact in 2024 moving forward.
And then we continue, Michael, as you know, then at some point in time, McCarran comes on. At some point in time, we retire the legacy system. Those are some pretty big levers that I think are -- that are at our disposal in order to make that adjusted EBITDA margin hit the long-range targets that we've put out there.
Yes. And just to add to that. 2023 is the base year for that 13% to 17% annual adjusted EBITDA growth rate that we expect to see. So you'll see it in 2024, and the 3% to 5% is a CAGR growth rate. So 2024 is when you should start seeing it directly Michael, to that question.
In Q1, if you look at the commodity headwinds on paper, you will see some of that continue in Q1. But we have the system now. We have a great variable cost model. So we're looking for that to begin in 2024.
Okay. That's what I was looking for. This is iterative every year, not all back-ended on the multiyear compound that you [indiscernible]
Correct.
Okay. I think this is a big part of this is the market is going to see evidence that all of this effort is beginning to pay off in '24.
And as Cindy mentioned, we already have put in a targeted workforce reduction that we executed in the [indiscernible] fourth quarter that will generate $8 million next year. So those are some of the layers that we have as we drive efficiencies.
She also mentioned careful hiring, attrition. We have strategic initiatives that drive efficiencies and improvements, and then our modernization efforts in our facilities are starting to take hold. You combine that with the systems, you just sort of get a compounding effect on efficiency being able to be driven.
[Operator Instructions] And again, we have Dave Manthey of Baird.
Dave? Mr. Manthey? Please unmute your line. Mr. Manthey?
Do you hear me now?
[indiscernible]
We can hear you.
I'm going to talk that up to user error. All right. Well, congrats on the ERP. My question, I'm going to talk about the paper. And Cindy, you talked earlier about the long range paper pricing being in the 150 range. What's magical about [ 192 ] and 60%? I would have thought that over time as you cycle in new contracts and sign additional customers and lose some that, that number would move around, like you'd be able to move the 192 set point lower and get a lower percentage of absorption. Can you talk about that formula and why that number hasn't changed in a while?
Yes. Dave, great question. So I think in terms of that, while anybody can set numbers and set ranges, what we actually tried to do was take market data and an understanding of what's going on in the marketplace. And we took this whole recycling revenue surcharge and put that onto a scale, unlike anybody else in the marketplace on that side of the business. That was purely putting out a recycling surcharge fee, whether it's a flat 10%, if it's 20%, whatever it is.
We felt that this one, the scale that we've designed, we looked at the market in general to see what do we think -- where is the opportunities for us to develop the scale where we believe we can win? We can still be competitive, we can still get paid for the value of the service that we provide, and pretty much through all of that is where that sliding scale came.
And as we do talk about 60% of the volatility being covered. There is -- that's a general number, but you are correct. As we continue to win new customers, as we continue all new contracts go out with some type of acceptance or adoption of this surcharge, but we also have legacy customers out there that continue to negotiate.
So I think it's not just a combination of where do you want to be, it's a combination of where you want to be and how competitive do you want to be in markets all across the U.S. And it depends on who the competitors are against whom we play.
So I think if you take a look at the national account perspective, a national account has potentially a little bit of a lower adoption in terms of that versus some of the independents or some of the larger customers. So that's, I think, pretty much where that came from as opposed to just being, here's where we think we could mitigate 100% of the volatility.
Okay. And then second, on the ERP. I understand that you were not standing still before you book the switch on the system. But what are the key changes, the early wins that you can get out of the ERP system? So if we look to year 1 based on your experience with SID, what should we expect in RWCS.
And related, is there any reason why we shouldn't see margins just steadily tick higher from here? I mean it seems like with all these behind you, you can start folding up some of those legacy systems, and you've already done the risk, maybe there's more behind that. Is there any reason we shouldn't see sort of up and to the right as it relates to margins from here?
Dave, great question. And I think what we focus on are -- unfortunately, during this journey that we've had at Stericycle, it's been quite a turbulent 5-year time period, at least for me, in terms of things that have been maybe, let's say, a bit outside of our control, whether it's been pandemics and hyperinflation and war in Ukraine and Russia and supply chain issues and now another breakout.
So I think you are correct. When I look at the things that we can control, here's some things that the ERP system affords us an opportunity to do right away. We get better with scheduling. We get better with routing, we get better with overtime. We get better with staffing. We get better with plant utilization. We get better with engagement with customers. We get better and we get more nimble when a customer wants to put on a service or add a container or schedule an additional pickup, we get better at those things because we get faster. And any time we get faster on those things, it affords us an opportunity to get to revenue quicker to match the effort and the energy that we're putting on the operations side from a cost perspective.
So our expectation and what we do see and what we have seen.
[Audio Gap]
One moment.
You will see that. So Dave, you're thinking about it correctly. And again, the caveat is for things that we can control, I'm very proud and very confident in the development of this culture and who we are and how we handle things to get better every day. So I'm excited about that.
Janet, a couple of things?
Yes. So -- and Dave, just to reiterate, we said that 2023 was the base year of our long-term outlook, which includes a significant margin expansion with adjusted EBITDA growth rate of 13% to 17%, which we expect to start seeing next year. And due to all the things and levers that Cindy has mentioned as well as the commercial levers, who, Cory, sitting right next to me, mentioned. On the call that give us confidence in that number. And then the legacy systems in international start to come up out in '25, we see some opportunity for adjusting IT costs as we go through this. So we still need to be [indiscernible] on.
I will point out there'll be some timing next year, a little bit in the first quarter. There will be that continued headwinds from the paper, but we have a great variable cost model, as I mentioned, and we can drive through that. But from a top line perspective, you still may see some year-over-year choppiness on RISI rate in the first quarter.
Yes. And I think Janet brings -- Dave or -- I know you're very in tune to the RISI rate. Just kind of on average, Q1, 2Q next year would be comparisons to Q1, 2Q obviously this year. When the average for both of those -- Q1 was probably about 225. Q2 was close, let's say, 186, somewhere around in there, 187. So still some stiff comps, I would say, for Q1, Q2. But then by the time you get to Q3, it obviously it comes down. It's about 146. And I think that's where you finally get a decent year-over-year comparison from a commodity perspective, at least with respect to RISI and the top line.
This will end the Q&A session. I would now like to turn the conference back to Cindy Miller for closing remarks.
Thank you. And as always, we'd like to thank the investors. We'd like to thank our employees, our customers, community that we serve for their continued interest in Stericycle. So thank you all very much.
This concludes today's conference call. Thank you all for participating. You may now disconnect, and have a pleasant day.