Euronet Worldwide Inc
NASDAQ:EEFT
| US |
|
Johnson & Johnson
NYSE:JNJ
|
Pharmaceuticals
|
| US |
|
Berkshire Hathaway Inc
NYSE:BRK.A
|
Financial Services
|
| US |
|
Bank of America Corp
NYSE:BAC
|
Banking
|
| US |
|
Mastercard Inc
NYSE:MA
|
Technology
|
| US |
|
UnitedHealth Group Inc
NYSE:UNH
|
Health Care
|
| US |
|
Exxon Mobil Corp
NYSE:XOM
|
Energy
|
| US |
|
Pfizer Inc
NYSE:PFE
|
Pharmaceuticals
|
| US |
|
Palantir Technologies Inc
NYSE:PLTR
|
Technology
|
| US |
|
Nike Inc
NYSE:NKE
|
Textiles, Apparel & Luxury Goods
|
| US |
|
Visa Inc
NYSE:V
|
Technology
|
| CN |
|
Alibaba Group Holding Ltd
NYSE:BABA
|
Retail
|
| US |
|
3M Co
NYSE:MMM
|
Industrial Conglomerates
|
| US |
|
JPMorgan Chase & Co
NYSE:JPM
|
Banking
|
| US |
|
Coca-Cola Co
NYSE:KO
|
Beverages
|
| US |
|
Walmart Inc
NYSE:WMT
|
Retail
|
| US |
|
Verizon Communications Inc
NYSE:VZ
|
Telecommunication
|
If you don’t study any companies, you have the same success buying stocks as you do in a poker game if you bet without looking at your cards.
Utilize notes to systematically review your investment decisions. By reflecting on past outcomes, you can discern effective strategies and identify those that underperformed. This continuous feedback loop enables you to adapt and refine your approach, optimizing for future success.
Each note serves as a learning point, offering insights into your decision-making processes. Over time, you'll accumulate a personalized database of knowledge, enhancing your ability to make informed decisions quickly and effectively.
With a comprehensive record of your investment history at your fingertips, you can compare current opportunities against past experiences. This not only bolsters your confidence but also ensures that each decision is grounded in a well-documented rationale.
Do you really want to delete this note?
This action cannot be undone.
| 52 Week Range |
92.68
116.58
|
| Price Target |
|
We'll email you a reminder when the closing price reaches USD.
Choose the stock you wish to monitor with a price alert.
|
|
Johnson & Johnson
NYSE:JNJ
|
US |
|
|
Berkshire Hathaway Inc
NYSE:BRK.A
|
US |
|
|
Bank of America Corp
NYSE:BAC
|
US |
|
|
Mastercard Inc
NYSE:MA
|
US |
|
|
UnitedHealth Group Inc
NYSE:UNH
|
US |
|
|
Exxon Mobil Corp
NYSE:XOM
|
US |
|
|
Pfizer Inc
NYSE:PFE
|
US |
|
|
Palantir Technologies Inc
NYSE:PLTR
|
US |
|
|
Nike Inc
NYSE:NKE
|
US |
|
|
Visa Inc
NYSE:V
|
US |
|
|
Alibaba Group Holding Ltd
NYSE:BABA
|
CN |
|
|
3M Co
NYSE:MMM
|
US |
|
|
JPMorgan Chase & Co
NYSE:JPM
|
US |
|
|
Coca-Cola Co
NYSE:KO
|
US |
|
|
Walmart Inc
NYSE:WMT
|
US |
|
|
Verizon Communications Inc
NYSE:VZ
|
US |
This alert will be permanently deleted.
Euronet Worldwide Inc
You don't have any saved screeners yet
Greetings. And welcome to the Euronet Worldwide Third Quarter 2021 Earnings Conference Call. At this time, all participants are in a listen-only mode. After the speakers’ presentation, there will be a question-and-answer session. [Operator Instructions]
It is now my pleasure to introduce your host, Mr. Scott Claassen, General Counsel for Euronet Worldwide. Thank you. Mr. Claassen, you may begin.
Thank you. Good morning. And welcome everyone to Euronet’s quarterly results conference call. We will present our results for the third quarter 2021 on this call. We have Mike Brown, our Chairman and CEO; Rick Weller, our CFO; and Kevin Caponecchi, the CEO of our epay Division on the call.
Before we begin, I need to call your attention to the forward-looking statements disclaimer on the second slide of the PowerPoint presentation we will be making today. Statements made on this call that concern Euronet’s or its management’s intentions, expectations or predictions of future performance are forward-looking statements.
Euronet’s actual results may vary materially from those anticipated in such forward-looking statements as a result of a number of factors that are listed on a second slide of our presentation. Euronet does not intend to update these forward-looking statements and undertakes no duty to any person to provide any such update.
In addition, the PowerPoint presentation includes a reconciliation of the non-GAAP financial measures we will be using during the call to their most comparable GAAP measures.
Now, I will turn the call over to our CEO, Mike Brown. Mike?
Thank you, Scott, and thank you everyone for joining us today. I will begin my comments on slide number five. I am so glad to be here talking to you today about these exciting double-digit consolidated growth rates, especially given the uncertainty of border openings, uneven vaccination efforts and increasing virus spread due to the Delta variant, which were all in the mix throughout the quarter.
As I have reflected on these results a few key highlights stood out for me. First, we were able to achieve consolidated third quarter 2021 revenue that topped the same quarter in 2019, which is particularly impressive given that EFT is still being heavily impacted by the COVID travel restrictions. This means that the revenue from epay and Money Transfer has grown significantly, supporting our view that we will emerge from the pandemic stronger than when we entered.
Second, our Money Transfer network now has surpassed the 0.5 million physical network locations and our Money Transfer app now reaches 20 countries.
Third, epay recorded its fifth consecutive quarter of double-digit adjusted EBITDA growth, primarily from the continued strength of mobile and digital media sales through our digital distribution channels.
And our EFT transactions rebounded at a very strong pace as European borders were reopened to fully vaccinated passengers from inside of Europe and select countries outside of Europe. Moreover, we have seen some elongation in the travel season due to the pent-up demand for travel after nearly 18 months without it.
All of these achievements were made possible by our strong balance sheet, which has afforded us the ability to maintain our dedicated workforce, to continue to invest in our industry-leading REN payments platform, as well as our digital networks in both epay and Money Transfer, and also take advantage of the strategic opportunities that have been presented to us.
And while our Money Transfer results were a bit uneven with strong U.S. and Europe outbound growth, as well as digital transaction growth, we saw a stronger than expected negative impact from the continued COVID lockdowns in the Middle East and the Asia-Pacific region, and the continued pressure on the U.S. domestic business.
Aside from those two geographies, we have really continued to see very strong growth rates in our transactions and lots of good progress in Money Transfer, which I am excited to tell you about in the coming slides.
But first, let’s go to slide number six and we will talk about the European travel trends and the impact on our business. This is a lot more optimistic slide than the ones I have been showing you over the last couple of quarters.
Here on slide six, we have updated the graph we presented last quarter, which shows actual and projected European flight data for this year versus 2019, overlaid with our total international cash withdrawals for the same periods, as well as our transaction recovery from non-EU cardholders.
When we spoke to you on our second quarter earnings call this year, the EU had just decided to reopen the borders to fully vaccinated U.S. travelers. However, the status of the borders in the EU were changing every day, causing a lot of uncertainty about when, not if, but when tourists would be able to travel again.
As the graph shows, flight levels immediately responded to the opening of borders and our total international transactions responded almost as quickly. While we were very pleased to see our total international transactions return to about 70% of 2019 levels, the recovery of our EFT segment profits is a bit more nuanced than that.
Let me take a minute to remind you of our different transaction revenue types. As you can see in the chart on the right side, our lowest value transactions are recovering much faster than our highest value transactions. First, we have domestic interchange and domestic surcharge. These transactions recovered quickly as the in-country movement restrictions were lifted.
Next, we have the international interchange, which makes up most of the recovery in the international transactions, as these are largely EU citizens traveling to different countries within the EU. So these tourists who were able to travel for much of the travel season beginning in the third quarter.
Then you have the transactions that apply to cardholders with non-euro bank accounts, which are our most profitable transactions. The uncertainty of border openings, the quarantine requirements, as well as the late decision to open borders to only certain travelers outside the EU caused a significant lag in the non-EU based cross currency transactions. These transactions only recovered to about 40%-ish of 2019 level.
So while we were thrilled that our international transactions bounced back at similar levels to actual flight levels coming into the EU, the lackluster reopening caused a slower rebound of our cross currency transactions, which of course are the most profitable.
However, the good news is the European borders are now generally open to most vaccinated travelers and to people -- and people now have a year to plan their 2022 summer vacation. We are also starting to see certain countries in Asia starting to open their borders, which will further contribute to next year’s recovery.
We don’t control the virus and we don’t control the government actions related to the virus. So our field of vision is somewhat limited in what we know we will play out next. What we do know from the last two travel seasons is that when the travel restrictions were lifted people very, very quickly returned to travel and they still withdrew cash, in fact even more cash.
Right now the vaccination efforts continued to improve. Therapeutics are now becoming available and people want to travel. If these factors continue in a favorable line, we anticipate that our 2022 transactions will possibly recover to between 80% and 90% of 2019 level.
The results could be better than we expect, of course, and they were here in the third quarter versus the guidance we gave you on the prior calls or they could be worse, but right now this is our best view.
What I also know is that our ATM network is stronger and more far reaching than before COVID, and this travel season once again proved that travelers are still going to use ATMs. We are excited for next year when we hope that many of these hurdles will be behind us.
Now let’s move to slide number seven and hit some of the EFT highlights. Here are a few -- slide seven. Here are a few highlights from our EFT segment, during the quarter we launched merchant acquiring services at La Samaritaine, a high-end shopping mall in Paris. Euronet is now offering payment services there to more than 200 terminals within the mall.
We also launched card-less cash payout for BNP Paribas corporate clients in Poland further expanding our product offering in one of our most important markets.
In India we launched ATM switching and card management services with SBC Cooperative Bank and Wai Urban Cooperative Bank in India expanding our offering with the community banks in the country. We also signed an ATM recycler agreement with Vista Bank in Romania. Finally, we renewed several ATM and card agreements across Europe and India.
As we continue to see the flights increase and more tourists on the ground in our countries, we invested further in our ATM network by adding more than 1,300 ATMs and we reopened about 730 ATMs that were previously closed.
We also lost about 161 outsourced ATMs, bringing our total active ATM to 45,520. We still had about 1,950 ATMs in closed status, either due to seasonal closures or because of COVID-19 lockdowns, bringing our total ATM network to 47,474.
With some elongation of the travel season I mentioned earlier, we have kept more ATMs open than we historically have had as of September 30th. However, as we move through the fourth quarter and tourism starts to slow down for the winter, we will expect to seasonally close some of our ATMs like we have always done.
You know, from previous quarterly earnings updates, the EFT segment has been significantly impacted by COVID, so we were pleased to see such a strong rebound in our transactions as movement restrictions were lifted from around the globe.
As we have shared with you over the last 12 months or so, we believe then and this third quarter transaction trend certainly confirms tourism will return and we will have a strong balance sheet -- and we have a strong balance sheet that we will be able to strengthen our network, adding more countries and adding more high value ATMs. We are looking forward to 2022. We will be ready to reopen all of our ATMs for the entire travel season if COVID conditions continued to improve as we have seen so far this year.
So now let’s go on to slide number eight and we will talk about epay. In this third quarter, our epay team continues its nice rhythmic beat, the fifth consecutive quarter of double-digit operating income growth.
So how is this possible? Several years ago, excuse me, epay disrupted the traditional content distribution market by recognizing the need to create digital distribution for items that had traditionally been distributed as a physical product, including gift cards, software and gaming.
epay re-imagined the way these things were purchased around the world by digitizing the barcode, which eliminated the need for a physical plastic gift card or a CD to install new software or a new game.
In addition to the digital delivery of all types of contents, epay developed an industry-leading technology platform that can be leveraged to deliver this content to banks, mobile operators, e-commerce sites or mobile wallets, all in addition to the traditional physical retail distribution.
Today we see a major transition in the traditional payments landscape. According to the most recent McKinsey study, over the next five years acquirers will grow by 40% from non-acquiring revenue. For years, we have been actively positioning epay to make these types of non-plastic alternative payments and provide our merchants more ways to make money and for consumers a more efficient way to get their products.
Additionally, we have the technology in place to connect with emerging fintech to achieve real-time payments and offer their customers more value-added products. In some cases, we are even doing two transactions in one. We are providing the content that the fintechs can offer their customers to purchase and we are processing real-time payments of these transactions through our real-time payment engine.
We know that the future embraces digital. We have superior technology and connections to mobile wallets around the world, which combined with our leading physical retail network places epay in the prime position to continue to grow well into the future.
This quarter, we launched several new agreements, including Microsoft XBOX Subscription Services with Telefonica, one of the largest mobile operators in Spain. We expanded distribution of Microsoft Office 365 to fnac, the online store of one of France’s largest retailers. We also expanded digital distribution with Media Markt in Poland and mobile content distribution with Agibank, a Brazilian bank with more than 3 million customers. In Italy, we signed an agreement with LIS, formerly known as Lottamatica to distribute Nike, Helbiz Live, AirBnB and Blizzard. And in New Zealand we signed an agreement with BP, a large petrol station chain to manage their gift card program.
Our epay teams continue to innovate our technology platforms, which in turn expands the services which we were able to provide to our fintech, retail and content partners. And the fruits of their efforts show up in their earnings, where they have posted double-digit growth for the past five quarters, good for pay.
Now, let’s move on to slide number nine and we will talk about Money Transfer. Our Money Transfer network has eclipsed 500,000 locations. I’d just like to take a step back and remind everyone that when we bought REN, we were a very distant third in the Money Transfer industry with 42,000 locations, mostly in Latin America.
We have grown that network more than a 1,000% and built an account deposit network that now reaches 3.6 billion bank accounts and 416 million mobile wallet accounts. And in fact our account deposit transactions grew 31% during the quarter versus the prior year and our account deposit volume now represents 29% of our overall cross-border principle flow.
This physical network combined with our digital payouts and that reach gives us the most far reaching Money Transfer network in the world and that is one of the key drivers was behind our seven-fold Money Transfer earnings growth since the acquisition in 2007.
During the quarter, we significantly expanded our wallet presence with service into five strategic wallets, GCash and PayMaya in the Philippines, IME Pay in Nepal, WiPay in Trinidad and Tobago, as well as PayTm in India, which is one of the largest mobile wallets in the world. Our partnership with PayTm is groundbreaking as PayTm becomes India’s first platform to accept international remittances directly into their digital wallet.
I’d like to note that while PayTm has more than 330 million users currently only 115 million of those have been fully KYC verified, so those are the only accounts we include in our digital wallet reach. We will add the other 215 million and growing into that account as they become fully verified and eligible to receive international remittances.
Over the last few years, we have expanded with several post offices around the world. It’s been a couple of quarters, so let me remind you that outside the U.S. these post office locations are like large retailers here in the U.S. and that they are the largest agents for Money Transfer in their country and customer choice has historically been limited to just our other two Money Transfer competitors.
We continue to disrupt the status quo and this quarter we expanded our post office networks with cash pickup services in four more countries, including the India Post, the Vietnam Post, the Uganda Post and the Bhutan Post.
We also signed a partnership agreement with Noble Financial to transition all of its 117 agents in the U.S. to the Ria brand platform and network. Noble is an important brand and multi-industry conglomerate in the Liberian market and had developed a loyal following of Money Transfer customers in the U.S.
We launched Money Transfer services to the 500,000 users of Bnext, a Spanish neobank. We signed an agreement with Azimo, a U.K.-based digital Money Transfer provider to supplement its pay network.
We also signed an agreement with Microsoft Dynamics to enable Xe’s payment offering with Microsoft Dynamics 365 platform and launched an agreement with Sage Intacct to enable Xe’s payments offering within its enterprise resource planning tool, which is used by small- and medium-sized businesses.
All of these agreements are examples of companies needing real-time cross-border payments for their customers and realizing that our Money Transfer network can provide the most efficient and cost effective manner in which to send these transactions. We continued to work on expanding this product offering and we look forward to sharing more news on it in the near future.
Now let’s go on to slide number 10 and we will talk about our REN technology. As you reflect back to the comments from each of our three segments, you can’t help but hear the significance of the role our cutting-edge technology is playing in our success and to further underscore our technology success, I’d like to highlight here on slide 10 a couple of the exciting new agreements for our REN technology.
We have signed an agreement with Jalin, the national switching system of Indonesia, which you may remember is the fourth largest population in the world. Euronet will deploy REN to modernize one of the largest switching infrastructures in the Southeast Asia replacing two competitive technology installations, when fully implemented REN will drive approximately 43,000 ATMs in this country. This is very exciting and this new installation of our REN technology comes on the heels of a successful project in Mozambique.
Additionally, you may have read the press release announcing our signing of a REN implementation agreement with Marker Trax. Marker Trax is disrupting the market with its first of a kind regulatory compliant and cashless alternative to the traditional casino marker. With this implementation, REN is serving as a fintech enabler by powering the entire Marker Trax solution. This is the first use of REN in a non-bank setting and will be a game changer in the gaming market, where casino patrons are forecasted to spend $516 billion globally and $150 billion just in North American market alone in 2021, with significant growth expected as more states open the opportunity for online customers.
Once fully implemented in the Marker Trax cloud environment, REN will provide scalability for the growing user base in physical and online environments, as well as transaction speed for enhanced user experiences and other key features including patron identity verification, credit scoring, portfolio accounting, underwriting, ACH payments and processing and more. This is an example of a fintech using REN’s comprehensive suite to quickly scale to meet their growing demand.
When I think about my original mission when I founded Euronet, it was to bring payment convenience to those who have not had it before. As the payment industry has rapidly evolved, so have we and I think a quote from Gary Larkin, the Chief Strategy Officer at Marker Trax summarizes our future the best. He said, we are also extremely excited to be the first to leverage the fintech enabling technology of REN in a new market vertical like gaming that needs an innovative platform to support its rapid transformation to a cashless environment.
That really summarizes the power of this technology, our network and our assets. We can not only use them to further our core business, which continues to thrive, but to also position other fintechs and neobanks to rapidly expand their businesses, because we have an entire suite of products, including issuing, transaction processing, settlement, compliance, reconciliation and more, which will allow fintechs to grow and achieve their goals. And we are just starting at the starting line. Stay tuned for more exciting announcements on the REN and that technology to come.
With that, I will hand it over to Rick.
Good morning and thank you everyone for joining. I will begin my comments on the balance sheet on slide 12. As Mike mentioned, we were able to achieve third quarter 2021 consolidated revenue above 2019 levels. The mix of revenue is changed, but to achieve more than 2019 levels, while still in the midst of this pandemic was only possible because of the strength of our balance sheet, which allowed us to invest in our digital and physical networks, and take advantage of opportunities.
As you can see we ended the quarter with more than $1 billion in cash. The sequential increase is the result of cash generated from operations during the quarter of nearly $120 million. ATM cash increased in line with borrowings on the revolving credit facility to fund the seasonally higher ATM cash needs for the peak travel season.
Next slide, please? I am on slide 13. For the third quarter we achieved revenue of $816 million or 104% over the third quarter 2019 revenue, with one segment still significantly impacted by COVID related restrictions. Now that’s impressive.
We also achieved operating income of $114 million and adjusted EBITDA of $155 million. Those better than expected consolidated growth rates were the result of outperformance of our EFT segment, where we saw international transactions rebound at a faster pace than expected as borders were partially reopened to fully vaccinated individuals, those with a negative COVID test or the COVID recovered travelers. We delivered adjusted EPS of a $1.77, a 58% increase over the $1.12 in the third quarter last year.
Next slide, please. Slide 14 shows our three-year transaction trends by segment. EFT transactions grew 29% as a result of more domestic and international cash withdrawal transactions together with a continued benefit of a significant volume increase in low value point-of-sale transactions in Europe and low value payment processing transactions from an Asia-Pacific customers’ bank wallet and e-commerce sites.
epay transactions grew 23%, driven by continued strength in mobile top up and digital media content distributed through digital channels. Money Transfer transactions grew a net of 10%, including 18% growth in both the U.S. outbound and European outbound transactions, and 58% growth in direct-to-consumer digital transactions. This growth was partially offset by declines in the domestic business and a 32% decline in transactions from the Middle East and Asia due to strict government mandated lockdowns, which remained in place throughout the quarter.
On slide 15 we present our results on an as reported basis. Year-over-year nearly all the currencies in the major markets where we operate increased in the low-to-mid single-digit range, overall about a 1% or less impact on our consolidated results. To normalize the impact of currency fluctuations, we have presented our results on a constant currency basis on the next slide.
I am on slide 16 now. EFT revenue grew 56%, operating income grew 908% and adjusted EBITDA grew 207% as a result of increased domestic and international cash withdrawal transactions, benefiting from the partial lifting of travel restrictions across Europe and new ATM deployments as we continued to prepare for the full travel recovery.
epay revenue grew 19%, operating income grew 17% and adjusted EBITDA grew 16% from increased digital distributions of digital media and mobile content. The lower growth rates in operating income and adjusted EBITDA reflect an investment in our teams and the technology to expand our market-leading digital distribution platforms. Overall, a nicely balanced quarter for epay.
Money Transfer revenue grew 8% from the strength of 18% growth in U -- both the U.S. and European outbound transactions, as well as 58% growth in direct-to-consumer digital transactions.
Revenue growth was offset by weakness in the domestic business and larger than expected declines in the Middle East and Asia-Pacific transactions. These factors, together with the FX rate volatility benefits realized in the third quarter last year, higher compensation costs and investments in our network and new products in the third quarter of this year contributed to the adjusted operating income and adjusted EBITDA declines of 23% and 20%, respectively.
While we always see pockets of price pressure, when setting aside the FX volatility rate benefits we realized in the third quarter last year, our Money Transfer segment saw relatively consistent revenue and gross profits per transaction when looking at it year-over-year. Moreover, when looking at sequential quarterly results here too we saw relatively consistent revenue and gross profit per transaction.
Now, shifting gears a bit, with regard to looking ahead, as we provided in the press release, our best insight into the fourth quarter would yield revenue relatively in line with the third quarter producing adjusted EBITDA in the range of $120 million to $130 million. Moreover, with the results of our seasonally strongest third quarter in the history books, we began to think about what next year might look like.
As Mike mentioned earlier, based on the tourism of this third quarter together with continued increases in vaccination rates across the globe, new therapeutics being introduced and fewer border restrictions, it appears to us we could see 2022 tourism transactions breakthrough 80% of 2019 levels, maybe higher.
If we see that level of travel, tourism recovery, together with the excellent growth we have seen from our epay and Money Transfer businesses, we could see 2022 revenue approximately 30% higher than our 2019 revenue, producing earnings similar to those of 2019, fully recognizing that we are not expecting a full recovery of our most profitable cross currency transactions next year.
So as I draw my comments to a close, I think it’s worth repeating that this was a great quarter for Euronet, where we delivered revenue above pre-COVID 2019 levels, signed and launched several new agreements, expanded our technology to new countries and new verticals, and continued to grow our digital distribution and networks.
With that, I will hand it back to Mike to close out the quarter.
Thanks, Rick. I’d like to close by emphasizing that all of these highlights were accompanied by a very strong set of financial results, which show that Euronet emergence is not only as a leading fintech, but it further demonstrates our rapid evolvement into being -- becoming a fintech enabler. We have been able to transform ourselves because REN our modern, flexible and powerful technology together with our global reach and our strength -- and our strong portfolio of assets.
We have built the most powerful and broad reaching Money Transfer networks in the world. It appears that travelers are coming back. We expect this to continue as vaccination rates continued to improve and but as therapeutics come to the market now and because economies need travelers.
And epay continues to develop digital distribution and merchant solutions that can directly compete with acquirers today. We have a lot to be proud of and even more to be excited about. With this quarter now closed, I look forward to telling you more in next quarter.
And finally as we alluded to in the second quarter investor update call, we continued to make great progress in introducing new ways to leverage our collective existing assets into new B2B product offerings. We are crossing the Ts and dotting the Is. So I hope to be talking to you more about some exciting things in the near future, stay tuned.
With that, we will be happy to answer your questions. Operator, will you please assist?
Thank you very much. [Operator Instructions] Your first question comes from the line of Andrew Schmidt from Citi. Your line is open.
Hey, Mike. Hey, Rick. Thanks for taking my questions. Good to see the step-up in earnings power here and the significant expansion use cases across the platform. It’s good to see. I just want to start off with just a clarification question. Rick, I think, you mentioned, the expectation at least right now on a preliminary basis, understanding it’s still a little bit early, the 2022 earnings would be similar to 2019. Are you referring to adjusted EBITDA, operating income, net income, just as a quick clarification there to start-off?
I was really kind of going down to the adjusted cash EPS number, Andrew, kind of to rattle it all the way down the income statement.
Perfect. Super helpful. And then when we talk about 80% and 90% of transactions recovered versus 2019 in EFT, how does that translate to EBITDA, because I know there’s some mixed assumptions that need to be made in terms of domestic versus cross-border and other products in that segment. So what’s the right way to think about that in terms of translating EBITDA as a percentage of 2019 bases?
Well, it’s real -- I will let Rick get right down to the nuts and bolts, but the reality is, our most profitable transactions are cross-currency transactions, right? And so when you saw that our cross-currency international travelers, so anybody like going into Europe from outside of Europe is a cross-currency guy, right? And those are our most profitable transactions, but those only recovered this year, 40%.
When we saw our intra-European recovery in the neighborhood of 60%, 70% and 80%, depending up on their domestic or international, so those are really profitable transactions. That’s the only difference, really if you get down to it between 2019 and this last quarter. So if we can get more people going overseas flights, we will really be cooking next year.
To kind of add to Mike’s comments, it gets to be some rather, let’s just call it, evolved -- involved or complicated math, let’s say, more fully answer your question. But from a really macro perspective, I think, as we have shared with folks before, the richness of these transactions come into our P&L at about a, let’s call it, roughly an 80% margin rate.
And so, you can see that if we can move the needle a bit on the volume of these transactions, and certainly, you could see in our third quarter results that as these transactions come in better than expected, they contribute nicely to the bottomline.
And then, if you kind of do a little bit of macro kind of math and looking at that next year number and kind of seeing where our epay and Money Transfer business has grown, you can see that that kind of margin leverage comes through on EFT to be able to get us to a 2019 earnings kind of level.
So, I guess, the -- in summary, I would be with the view that that the way you should think about it is, as we see those transactions come through, they are going to come through with some very rich margin levels and really nicely contribute to that bottomline.
Very helpful. And then, it’s great to have an EPS baseline out there for 2022, but it’s obviously still little bit early. But -- so I would imagine that you probably take a good level of conservatism in here. It just makes sense to be prudent. But if you can just sort of clarify that a little bit, is there a level of conservatism that’s taken here just, because we are not even in 2022...
Well, we have -- we have to. We have to, Andrew, because we just -- we don’t know and we do know that when Americans want to travel abroad, it takes a lot more thought preparation and kind of whom to do that than if you are just flying within Europe. And it’s a lot easier for us…
Yeah.
… to go to New York than it is for us to go to Rome. So we bake that in there. We don’t know it could be better. All of us are going to watch the tracker on how many across ocean reservations are being made, but that will change things markedly.
And if you look at the average revenue per transaction of anything that is cross currency, we have probably make -- we make about a little over $1 on a -- on an international interchange transaction. We might make $2 or $3 on a surcharge transaction. But when we get to make a spread on foreign currency, I mean, those transactions could be $5 to $10. So you can see it doesn’t take too many of those transactions…
Yeah.
…but really pop the top off.
Right. So it sounds like its more prudent expectations about mix in 2022.
It’s all about mix. It’s 100% about mix.
Yeah.
Exactly.
Absolutely. Perfect. Well, thanks a lot, guys. It’s great to see the progress. I will jump back in queue, but cracking the quarterly results. Thanks a lot.
Next question, Operator?
Yes. Your next question is from Andrew Jeffrey with Truist. Your line is open.
Hi. Good morning. I appreciate you taking the question. Mike, a question on Money Transfer and a question on epay. Can you talk a little bit about the investments you are making in the Money Transfer segment and how you think you are going to be able to monetize these connected wallets and the connected bank accounts and can you give us a little color on the volume that’s going to bank accounts. But can you talk about, I guess, one, specifically, where you are investing, and two, whether or not you think monetization of some of these digital accounts and deposit -- account deposit in particular Money Transfer can drive yield and drive growth?
Well, I mean, you saw our numbers just over this last quarter where our account deposit transactions grew 31% during the quarter versus prior year and account deposit volume now represents at almost 30% of our total volume.
So what that’s telling you is this huge asset that we have with basically 4 billion digital ways to drop money into an account or a wallet has accelerated our growth. And you have seen also the huge growth in our direct acquired app Money Transfer transactions as well.
So the deal is, if you want to grow into the future, everybody goes digital, digital, digital, but you have got to have the endpoint. And that’s our magic right now as we continue to build out those endpoints both for consumers and in the future we have been mentioning this before where we intend to repurpose those for B2B kinds of transactions, because that market is many, many times bigger than the family remittance markets. So having this head start, having the world’s leader lead in that area is going to be an asset and that’s worth making investments in.
Andrew, I would go on to elaborate on some of the technology comments, Mike made is that, we have built a wonderful platform of technology that is easy to connect to. And no different than some of the fintech players that we mentioned that we have signed agreements with is, there’s lots of folks out there building things in the garage so to speak on ways to meet customer needs more efficient, eloquent ways to get to the customers. And when they do that they then need to make payments around the world that’s at least some of their opportunity and we have got the best network in the world.
The other important part about it is not just the ease of integrating to our technology is that we cover all the payment a mean, it’s not just that you can send it to a card account or you can send it to a bank account, we can send it to wallet accounts, you can pick it up in cash, we can put it into crypto if we want to, okay.
We can move the money any way that somebody wants to be able to receive it and we can get it to damn near everyone, anyone in the world. I mean the -- it’s a little bit of that the few corners of the world that you can’t, but we have got truly the most impressive network.
So how we monetize it is a combination of several of those things and it really starts with our technology being able to integrate into that technology, which then opens up and exposes the opportunity for all of our assets to be taken advantage of.
I mean we really like the fact that a lot of companies are out there, very well-funded, attracting customers with their, you might call, their mousetrap to attract customers and do transactions. But all of them need a payment methodology and we handled the whole thing, soup to nuts, compliance and everything.
So and then remember, on a REN technology, we are putting our REN tech into both banks and central banks to do real-time payment. So as the world moves towards RTP systems, I mean, who’s got the expertise? We do. We are installing that stuff.
Right now in that piece of the business that is one big advantage we have in our company that we are not just a Money Transfer company, we are a technology company and that we are enabling people to do that. So these things really work hand in glove and give us just an edge over everybody else.
Okay. That’s helpful. And I guess to put a finer point on it, should we expect to see all that translate into better yield, Rick? I mean, it’s one of the questions we get when we think about the tension between traditional or legacy Money Transfer, say, cash-to-cash versus digital. I mean, do we start to tip over to better unit economics at some point here?
Yes. Because, I mean, as Mike said, as you focus on B2B and you move up that market it’s -- they get to be bigger transactions, the cost --our cost to terminate one of those transactions is rather small. And so there’s opportunity where if you take a look at what the, let’s say, just average achievement on sending money.
And I am not talking about per se remittance money, but moving money around the world is in excess of 1% of the money moved. So you can easily now start seeing that if you move a $10,000 or $20,000 or a $50,000 transaction and you have got 1% or even a 0.5%. Those are nice transactions. So, yes, it really does contribute to the ability to leverage the bottomline margins for this business.
All right. Thanks. Appreciate that, guys.
Yeah.
We have a question from Darrin Peller with Wolfe Research. Your line is open.
Thanks, guys. Yeah. The…
I didn’t hear what your name was. Who is this?
Hey. It’s Darrin. It’s Darrin Peller with Wolfe.
Oh! Darrin. Oh! Okay. Hi, Darrin.
Hey, Mike. When we -- guys when we look at the normalized potential of the business now, so you talked about the magnitude of improvement we have seen in epay and Money Transfer through the last one and a half, two years. Just give us a sense of what you think based on the different trends around challenger banks requiring more and banks pushing back on needing more opening up surcharging rules new governments? I mean what would you say in a normal world is the size of the EFT business versus 2019 from a revenue and profitability standpoint? Because we can figure out, we can see the acceleration on the Money Transfer and the epay sides of the business. I am curious what a normal sized business could look like for you if one day you have got…
Well, take a look, I mean it is taking us about eight years to build out Europe and you saw the profits that Europe generated in 2019 for doing those kind of transactions and maybe that was around $300 million in EBITDA.
Well, now that Visa has changed its rules and allowed us to accept similar kinds of transactions not just like we do in Europe, but everywhere in the world, where there’s a Visa card or a MasterCard card. I mean the whole rest of the world is our oyster. Wherever there’s a tourist on this planet I should go after them. Give me some sand and a beach and I will be there.
So as I look at this, there could be every bit of another $300 million or more out there to go after and we are just beginning to do that. We are live with just one country in Southeast Asia right now that we will be announcing. At some point in time we had 150 ATMs there before COVID hit and they are extremely profitable ATMs.
So we know that we -- that we have got something that works. We will be announcing other countries in the coming quarters and so the whole -- our challenge is just get ourselves expand it. We have got licenses in these countries. We know how to manage all the sub-pieces of delivering the money to the ATMs and reconciling and all that stuff. So there is -- it’s big. That’s probably people keep saying, well…
Yeah.
…how long will it take you to get back to 2019 levels, I can -- we will get there. The question is, what are you going to look like in 2022 or 2023 or 2024 or 2025…
Right.
…and maybe we are twice that big.
We have invested in those markets…
And we continued to invest. Yes, we are.
Okay.
Had we not? We were actually on this whole idea long before two years before Visa even started to change its rules, because we felt like they were going to have to. So as they change where we are now getting the licenses in some of these new markets and they will be very lucrative for us.
Yeah. When we think about the epay and Money Transfer segments being somewhere around 40% or maybe more than that versus higher than 2019 levels already trending that way at least for 2022, again the EFT side of the business is kind of the question given the profitability level there and so if we were to normalize, I remember the estimates were expected to be somewhere around 20% higher for 2022 pre-COVID than there -- than the street estimates are now and probably 30% higher than what you just said if it’s similar to 2019? So I guess the bottomline question is, do you envision a normal scenario and can you move fast enough on all the redeployment on ATMs to make that happen if we get real resurgence on travel?
Oh! Absolutely. And in fact, they are already there. The ATM, we have added more ATMs than we had in 2019 and all we got to do is turn them on now. Some of the ones that we have got closed are just -- they are just not cash, they are cashed out. But they are technically live and we can respond not quite instantly, but pretty darn fast.
Got it.
Yeah. I mean it’s…
Just one quick…
…when you say, normal, like, it’s always hard to compare what normal is, but if you look at our at our 2019 revenue numbers for the EFT segment and using your assumption or your stated assumption of, if we get back to travel at the same levels? Well if -- I would tell you that if we were at the same travel levels as 2019, no restrictions, full movement of people that we would with our current set of assets, it’s quite likely that our revenue numbers would exceed 2019 numbers for EFT.
Because we have taken some, let’s call them, some of these outsourced ATMs that were brought back in-house because of some acquisition. Those one out and we have continue to replace them with our own ATMs and opening up in new countries that we have seen spectacular results out of. So my sense is that we -- if we had no travel restrictions, as you said, and it was back to business as normal, our number for revenue on that EFT segment would exceed 2019’s number.
Okay. Okay. All right. My last quick follow-up more a little more pointed on the Money Transfer segment, given the volatile you have had in the last couple of days on competition concerns and pricing. So to be clear, I mean, you have Wai’s [ph] out there lowering price and you have Facebook and others trying new things with lower price alternatives potentially. And so, you guys are already generally lower, do you consider yourself already a generally lower priced than others in the industry and lower margin and higher commission payout. I am curious how you think you would stack up in a world where some competitors have to lower?
Well, first of all, you got to remember, this is a dog-eat-dog business, it is the family remittance business. We are out there competing every day on every street corner and on the digital side. So that doesn’t really bother us, and actually, if you take a look at our numbers and you kind of dig deep into our numbers, there’s been some kind of squirrely things that have happened because of COVID and we had a lot of good currency volatility last year that allowed us to make money. But as Rick said in his early part of this discussion, the reality is, our -- we haven’t really felt much pricing pressure. So this idea that all of a sudden we are under the gun on pricing I don’t think is accurate.
Yeah. I mean, as we said, we see pockets of pricing pressure all the time. I mean, this is a competitive world and we operate around the globe. So there’s always going to be someone that’s offering something for free or something else like that and we have to respond to that.
And our response comes in different market, ways we deliver the products. When Mike mentioned that, we are doing nearly a third of our business is paid out to bank accounts now. That’s a more efficient way to pay out on and gives us some better economics on that type of stuff. And so it -- since 2007, we have been out there and competing and we have always generally been a better value play than the bigger guys in the market out there. So we have kind of, let’s say, already been at a more competitive point.
As you know, and I have not yet found a business that can survive with just given all of its product away free. Somewhere you have to be able to make money. We have often seen where new entrants will come in at a very, very compelling free offer.
But at some point reality has to set in and you have got to be able to make money in this business, because there’s cost of compliance. Maybe some of these folks aren’t doing compliance, right? It’s cost of compliance. It’s cost of building out a network. It’s cost of competing every day. So we see it out there, but we respond to it every day.
And let’s not forget even just looking at the family remittance market, we have about 5.5% to 6% of that. So, we look at it as there’s 94% to go. We have got a big market out there.
Great. Thanks, guys.
And we will take one more question, I think, Operator, before we are going to have to end it.
Okay. Your last question is from Mike Grondahl with Northland Securities. Your line is open.
Hey, guys. Congrats on Jalin and Marker Trax. Could you kind of help us understand the revenue model a little bit there like per ATM or per transaction? How do you envision that working?
Yeah. So -- this is Kevin. So we have got two revenue models associated with REN. One is our traditional software and license model, and the other is a transaction revenue share model. In the case of Jalin, it’s more the traditional software license model. In the case of Marker Trax it is a revenue share related to transactions.
Got it. Got it. That’s…
In a lot of our installations, we kind of want to especially into these places that are putting in real-time payments or connecting the real-time payment engines we are a little bit more transaction-based than a software-based because the transactions are low, we can kind of grow -- the expense can grow along with the assets.
Yeah. A lot of the fintechs we are working with Mike prefer a transaction based, because they want to preserve a capital. So we are finding a lot of great opportunities to get them in low with a transaction model and then share in the profitability as they grow we get to grow, which we really like, because we believe in the partners that we are picking with regards to providing the technology stack.
I mean, on average we would say that our bias is always going to be toward transaction based, because we also think that it’s very lined up with the partners we are dealing with. We are kind of going into it with more skin in the game, more risk taking if you will at the beginning of the transaction, because we are not walking out of there with a big software fee and then we benefit on the growth of it.
So I think that our interests are more aligned with the partners when we have a transactional based process and it certainly helps them get into the business easier if they don’t have to write a big cheque, and as Kevin said, use a lot of pricey capital to be able to get the business going.
The Marker Trax thing, we put out a press release about it a week or so ago, and then Mike referenced it in his -- in a review. We are particularly excited about that because they are playing in such a large market, hundreds of billions of dollars. That that market hasn’t changed in decades and there’s a push to try to move to cashless.
And in our opinion these Marker Trax guys have got a great vision for the industry and where it’s going, and we couldn’t be more thrilled to be part of it and act as our technology service provider. I think that’s got a lot of potential.
Got it. And just lastly as a follow-up with Marker Trax, do you guys know like how many casinos your product is in and what that rollout might look like?
We do. We are not at liberty to discuss it, but I will tell you Mike that, the list is greater than our ability to implement.
Got it. That’s helpful. So thanks guys.
The sales pipeline is extremely strong and we are having to pick and choose, because there’s more opportunities to deploy than we have the capability right now to deploy it into.
Good to hear. Thanks, guys.
Excellent.
All right. Well, with that last question, I want to like to thank everybody once again for joining us on the call today. We will look forward to giving you an updates in another 90 or so days. Thank you very much.
This concludes today’s conference call. Thank you for joining. You may now disconnect.