Costco Wholesale Corp

NASDAQ:COST

Earnings Call Analysis

Costco Q4 Fiscal Results Show Growth and Stability

In the 17-week fourth quarter of fiscal year 2023, Costco reported a significant rise in net income to $2.16 billion, up from $1.868 billion in the previous year. Sales surged by 9.4% to $77.43 billion. Comparable sales had minor increases, but adjusted for gas deflation and foreign exchange, U.S. sales grew by 3.1%. Membership fee income rose to $1.509 billion, marking a growth of around 7% adjusted for the extra week in the quarter. Membership renewal rates remained high in the U.S. and Canada at 92.7%, and the company experienced 7.6% growth in cardholders worldwide. Gross margins improved modestly, up 16 basis points excluding gas deflation, while SG&A expenses rose slightly, up 21 basis points without the gas effect. Moreover, interest income significantly increased this quarter, by $171 million year-over-year.

Company's Tax Rate and Net Income

The company’s tax rate for the fourth quarter increased to 27.1%, a rise of 1.7 percentage points from the previous year's same quarter, mainly due to higher international earnings which are taxed more heavily than in the U.S. Despite the higher tax rate, reported net income was up 16% year-over-year for the quarter, which would normalize to a 9% increase when adjusting for an extra week in the quarter.

Warehouse Expansion Strategy

Over the recent period, the company has expanded its physical presence by opening nine new warehouses, including international locations in China and Japan. With 23 new units opened for the full fiscal year '23 and plans to add 10 more in the first quarter of fiscal '24, the company is showing vigorous growth, particularly in Asia where new stores often attract tens of thousands of new members.

E-Commerce Performance and Digital Initiatives

Although e-commerce sales dipped slightly by 0.6% year-over-year, the trend shows improvement compared to previous quarters, and segments such as appliances surged over 30%. The company is also enhancing its digital and mobile experience, with upgrades to its app and website resulting in higher ratings and a significant 40% increase in unique site visitors year-over-year. These enhancements include a redesign of several features to improve customer engagement and in-warehouse shopping tools.

Cost Management and Member Profile

Despite deleveraging pressure on selling general and administrative (SG&A) expenses, particularly due to big-ticket items, the company maintains its customer service level and compensates employees well. They continue to attract younger generations, with the executive membership growing by almost 1 million members in the quarter. These members tend to start at a higher spending level and increase their spending over time.

Retail Innovations and Competitive Position

Company initiatives in areas like Retail Media and strategic partnerships, like with Instacart, help enhance the customer experience. They also maintain a strong competitive position with initiatives in areas such as gasoline sales. Even if sales are lower than the strongest quarter, which was the previous year, they are still quite profitable and their competitive spread has increased to mid-30 cents per gallon on average.

Financial Health and Future Investments

The company's solid ending cash balance of $13.7 billion hints at the possibility of future special dividends, a practice ingrained in the company's history. Inventory is well-managed, staying just under $16.7 billion, with payables slightly higher at $17.5 billion, showcasing strong inventory management relative to sales.

Global Expansion and Outlook

On the international front, the company maintains a strong growth trajectory with the strategic opening of locations in China, which is poised to reach seven locations by the end of the fiscal year, up from two a year and a half ago. This global expansion underscores the company's long-term vision and adaptability in a diverse market landscape.

Earnings Call Transcript 2023-Q4

[Operator]

Good day, everyone, and welcome to the Costco Wholesale Corporation Fourth Quarter and Fiscal Year 2023 Operating Results Call. Today's call is being recorded. [Operator Instructions] I would now like to turn the conference over to Richard Galanti, CFO. Please go ahead, sir.

[Richard Galanti, executive]

Thank you, Lisa, and good afternoon to everyone. I will start by stating that these discussions will include forward-looking statements within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. These statements involve risks and uncertainties that may cause actual events, results and/or performance to differ materially from those indicated by such statements. The risks and uncertainties include, but are not limited to, those outlined in today's call as well as others identified from time to time in the company's public statements and reports filed with the SEC. Forward-looking statements speak only as of the date they are made, and the company does not undertake to update these statements, except as required by law.

In today's press release, we reported operating results for the fourth quarter of fiscal '23, the 17 weeks ended September 3. These results and the figures presented today compare to last fiscal year's 16-week fourth quarter. Reported net income for the 17-week fourth quarter came in at $2.16 billion or $4.86 per diluted share compared to $1.868 billion or $4.20 per diluted share in the 16-week fourth quarter last year.

In terms of sales, net sales for the 17-week fourth quarter were $77.43 billion, an increase of 9.4% from $70.76 billion in the 16-week fourth quarter last year. Comparable sales for the fourth quarter and these figures are like-for-like number of weeks. In the U.S., reported was a 0.2% comp. Excluding gas, deflation and FX, in the U.S., it would have been at 3.1%. Canada reported was a 1.8% and excluding gas deflation and FX, 7.4%. Other International reported 5.5% and again, excluding gas deflation and FX, 4.4%. All told, total company reported 1.1% comp and a 3.8% ex gas deflation and FX.

In terms of e-commerce, that was -- came in at a minus 0.8% reported and a minus 0.6% excluding FX. Overall, for the fiscal fourth quarter, food and sundries were relatively strong once again, with fresh foods right behind and with some offsets on some of the nonfoods categories. In terms of Q4 comp sales metrics, traffic or shopping frequency increased 5.2% worldwide and 5.0% in the United States. Our average transaction or ticket was down 3.9% worldwide and down 4.5% in the U.S., impacted in large part from weakness in bigger ticket nonfoods discretionary items as well as the gas price deflation. Foreign currencies relative to the U.S. dollar negatively impact sales by approximately 0.3%, and gasoline price deflation negatively impacted sales by approximately 2.5%.

Next, on the income statement, membership fee income reported in the fourth quarter $1.509 billion or 1.95% of sales in the fourth quarter of this fiscal year compared to $1.27 billion or 1.88% in Q4 of last year, so a $182 million increase or 13.7%. If you adjust for the extra week, the 13.7% would be roughly a 7% ex that extra week. Excluding FX and the extra week, the increase would have been around 7.5%.

In terms of renewal rates, at Q4 end, our U.S. and Canada renewal rates stood at 92.7%, which is up 0.1% from the 92.6% figure as of the end of Q3. The worldwide rate came in at 90.4%, down 0.1%, reflecting the impact of increasing penetration of memberships from international, which renew at a lower rate in large part because of new openings internationally.

Membership growth continues. We ended the fourth quarter with 71.0 million paid household members, up 7.9% versus a year ago; and 127.9 million cardholders, up 7.6% and that's new openings over the past year of just under 3% increase in new locations. At fourth quarter end, we had 32.3 million paid executive memberships, an increase of 981,000 during the 17 weeks since Q3 end. Executive Members now represent a little over 45% of our paid membership and approximately -- paid members and approximately 73% of worldwide sales.

Moving down the income statement. Next is our gross margin. Our reported gross margin in the fourth quarter came in higher -- came in at 10.60%, up 42 basis points from 10.18% a year ago, and at 42 basis points is up 16 basis points, excluding gas deflation. As I always ask you to jot down a few numbers with 2 columns, both reported and excluding gas deflation, the first line item would be core merchandise, on a reported basis, up 51 basis points year-over-year in the fourth quarter and ex gas deflation, up 28 basis points; ancillary and other businesses, a minus 32 and a minus 38; 2% Reward, minus 4 and minus 2; LIFO plus 27 and plus 28, and you total that up, on a reported basis, gross margin was up 42 basis points year-over-year and ex gas deflation, up 16 basis points.

Starting with the core, again, up 51 year-over-year and ex deflation, up 28. In terms of core margin on their own sales, our core-on-core margins were higher by 35 basis points, with food and sundries and nonfoods being up and fresh foods being down a little. Ancillary and other business gross margin was lower by 32 basis points and lower by 38 basis points ex gas. This decrease was driven almost entirely by gas. If you look at the other components of ancillary and other, which would include pharmacy, e-com, food court, business centers, optical, all those things on a relative basis year-over-year were in a couple of basis points plus or minus from a year earlier.

2% Reward, higher by 4 and higher by 2 basis points, so a negative 2 basis points, excluding gas deflation. That represents higher sales penetration coming from our Executive Members.

And LIFO, of course, if you recall last year in Q4, we had a $223 million pretax LIFO charge. While there was a small charge this year of $30 million on a year-over-year basis, of course, that showed the basis point improvement in margin. While we continue to see sequential improvement in year-over-year inflation, I'll talk about that a little later. We still had a small amount relative to the first day of the fiscal year. That's the small charge in Q4.

A couple of final comments on margins. First, we are asked often recently about our inventory shrinkage results and whether it has dramatically increased in the past year versus historical shrink results. The answer is no. In the past several years, our inventory shrink has increased by a couple of basis points, in part, we believe, due to the rollout of self-checkout. Over the past year, it has increased by less than 1 basis point more. So no, thankfully, not a big issue for us.

And second, the year-over-year margin improvement has in part been due to fewer markdowns due to better inventory positions this year than last. Our inventories overall are in good shape.

Moving on to SG&A. Our reported SG&A in the fourth quarter, 8.96%, up from 8.53% a year earlier or up 43 basis points and ex gas deflation, up 21 basis points. Again, jot down the 2 columns of numbers, both reported and excluding gas deflation: operations, minus 37 basis points, minus being higher by, and without deflation, core would be minus 18; central, minus 6 and minus 3, and those are the really only 2 items. The others were all 0 stock compensation, preopening and other. So total reported margins were up 43 basis points year-over-year and ex gas deflation, up 21 basis points.

In terms of the core operations being higher by 18 ex gas deflation and on a reported basis, higher by 37, this negative included the impact of lower sales growth as well as the impact of 8 weeks of additional top-of-scale wage increases that went into effect July 4, 2022, so midway through Q4 last year, and a full 17 weeks of this past March is higher than normal top-scale increase. Central being higher by 3 basis points ex gas deflation, again, not a lot of sales operating leverage there. And again, as I mentioned, the other line items that I typically read out were flat, both with and without gas deflation, so 0 year-over-year change.

Below the operating income line, interest expense came in at $56 million this year versus $48 million a year ago, 1 extra week of course. Interest income and other for the quarter was higher by $171 million year-over-year, $238 million this year versus $67 million last year. This was driven in large part by an increase in interest income due to both higher interest rates and higher cash balances as well as the extra week. In addition, FX was slightly favorable year-over-year.

In terms of income tax rate, our tax rate this year in the fourth quarter came in 27.1% compared to 25.4% in Q4 last year, so a full 1.7 percentage points higher year-over-year. This increase in our rate as of Q4 is primarily attributable to an increased penetration of international earnings, which overall incurs a higher income tax rate than in the U.S. Overall, reported net income was up 16% year-over-year in the quarter or 9% if you adjust for the extra week this year in fourth quarter versus last.

A few other items of note. In the fourth quarter, we opened 9 net new warehouses, including 5 new buildings in the U.S., 2 in China and 1 each in Japan and Australia. That -- for the full fiscal '23 year, we finished with 23 net new units as well as we did 3 relocations. And for the first quarter, the first 12 weeks of fiscal '24, we plan on opening 10 net new units and as well relocating 1 unit. All 10 locations, net new are -- 9 are in the U.S. and 1 are in Canada.

Regarding capital expenditures, we've actually included the cash flow in the quarterly report, but CapEx spend in Q4 was approximately $1.56 billion. And for all of fiscal '23, it totaled $4.32 billion.

Turning to e-commerce. E-commerce sales in the fourth quarter ex FX, as I mentioned, decreased 0.6% year-over-year. While still negative, relatively speaking, our e-commerce showed good improvement -- results showed good improvement this quarter versus our year-over-year results in Q2 and Q3. In the previous 2 fiscal quarters, big ticket discretionary, majors, home furnishings, small electrics, jewelry and hardware were down 15% and 20% year-over-year, respectively, and down just 5% year-over-year in the fourth quarter, with those big ticket departments making up over half of our e-commerce sales.

A couple other items of note. Within the sales of big ticket discretionary, appliance were up over 30% in the quarter. Second, I've gotten a couple of calls that people have seen online that we've been selling 1-ounce gold bars. Yes, but when we load them on the site, they're typically gone within a few hours, and we limit 2 per member.

And lastly, I'll point out Costco Next. We continue to grow that. We currently have 62 suppliers on costconext.com, and we're continuing to onboard additional ones in many product areas from home improvement to apparel to pet to home and kitchen to electronics and accessories to sports and bicycles and toys and the like.

Now a few comments on e-com mobile digital efforts, which we're always asked about. As I discussed during the last quarter earnings call, when I said that we were in the early innings of our digital mobile transformation efforts, progress is being made. In terms of recent additions and upgrades, we recently redesigned the account page in the digital membership card. We also redesigned a header with larger search bar and expanded selling space. We've added an app box for messages and advertisements right in the app. We've recently, a few months ago, opened an optical digital store where you can virtually try on glasses and then order them for pickup, prescription glasses.

And lastly, there are ongoing improvement in our Costco app, offering in-warehouse shopping tools to our customers such as a digital membership card, managing shopping lists, viewing warehouse savings, seeing the gas prices to the extent there's a gas station there. And soon, you'll be able to search warehouse inventory and scan barcodes from the app. With the improvements made thus far over the past year, our App Store rating has gone from a dismal 2.3 stars to currently 4.7 stars. Unique visitors in the site are up 40% year-over-year, and the Costco app installs are up 46% year-over-year. So all in all, progress is being made.

Lastly, a couple of comments regarding inflation. Most recently, in Q3 '23, we had estimated that year-over-year inflation was in the 3% to 4% range. Our estimate for Q4 was inflation in the 1% to 2% range, and it's actually trended downward during the quarter. So hopefully, these inflation trends will continue. We'll have to see.

Finally, in terms of upcoming releases, we'll announce our September sales results for the 5 weeks ending Sunday, October 1; on Wednesday, October 4 after the market closes.

With that, I will open it up for Q&A and turn it back over to Lisa. Thank you.

[Operator]

[Operator Instructions] We'll take our first question from Simeon Gutman with Morgan Stanley.

[Simeon Gutman, analyst]

I guess my first question, I don't mean it tongue-in-cheek but is -- I guess, is a membership price increase part of the fiscal plan? And then part of the question is, is there a point at which this membership increase is part of, I guess, a hedge against inflation? Is there a point at which model feels more weight without it? In other words, can you go another year without it?

[Richard Galanti, executive]

Well, my pat answer, of course, is it's a question of when, not if. It's a little longer this time around since June of '17, so we're 6 years into it. And -- but you'll see it happen at some point. We can't really tell you if it's in our plans or not. We'll let you know when we know. We feel good, say, about all the attributes of member loyalty and member growth.

And frankly, in terms of looking at the values that we provide to our members, we continue to increase those. It's certainly a greater amount than even -- more than if and when an increase occurs. So stay tuned. We'll keep you posted. But there's not a whole lot I can tell you about that.

[Simeon Gutman, analyst]

Fair enough. And then ultra short term, as gas prices have moved up, have you seen any effect or impact on spending at the store?

[Richard Galanti, executive]

No. I mean, if you look at the numbers over the last few months that we report monthly and quarterly, there's not been a heck of a lot change. Big ticket discretionary, while improved relatively as I mentioned online -- those online items, we've seen the number of items in the basket tick up a little in the last few months, but I think that has more to do with the fact that we consciously added -- I think I mentioned in the last call, we consciously added 40 or 50, what I'll call, smaller ticket indulgent items, whether it's snack items and the like to just impulse items. And so that's what we do as merchants. But overall, we haven't seen any big change or have been able to correlate any big change to what's happened with gas prices.

[Operator]

We'll take our next question from Michael Lasser with UBS.

[Michael Lasser, analyst]

Richard, you ended your prepared remarks saying that this quarter or this month, inflation is on pace to be 1% to 2%, and you suggested it may be even lower than that. So should outside of the reverse, be prepared for the prospect of deflation either because that's what's happening with some underlying costs that Costco has been experiencing? Or Costco will look to invest in price as a way to continue to drive volumes, especially at a time when core-on-core margins are expanding so nicely?

[Richard Galanti, executive]

Well, first of all, the comment that was 1% to 2% but then as we look at the 17 weeks, if you were -- or the 4 months roughly, we saw -- if we looked at it internally at each of the end of those 4 months, we saw the level -- that 1% to 2% is from the beginning to the end of the year -- I'm sorry, the beginning of the end of the quarter. But during the quarter, we saw that trending downward, if you will, a little. And when I talk to the merchants, on the fresh side, it's flat to down a little right now on the food and sundries side.

It's up a little, primarily on some of the CPG stuff. And on big ticket -- or not big ticket but on nonfoods, partly because of freight, which is down year-over-year in a nice way and in some cases, some of the commodity costs on steel and the like, that's come down. So that being said, not a big change, but at least it's trending that way. Who knows what tomorrow brings?

And as it relates to us, we're always pushing prices as fast as we can. We want to be the first to lower them when those things happen and drive sales. I think we've seen that with our traffic.

[Michael Lasser, analyst]

So just to clarify, what you're saying is food and sundries, prices are down on average year-over-year. Shelf-stable products are up year-over-year. Gen merch is down. So in totality, it would seem like the store -- the box is deflating. Does it get -- does the rate at which you see deflation continue to increase from here? And would you expect that to be just driven by the factors that you mentioned? Or are you driving that as a way to drive this traffic?

[Richard Galanti, executive]

Well, first of all, I want to correct one thing that maybe I misstated or you misunderstood. In terms of fresh, fresh is pretty much flat. Food and sundries, which is everything from sundries and packaged goods and CPG goods, that tends to be up a little bit. And I'd like to think that we're pushing the envelope as much as we can with our suppliers, that as certain freight costs have come down, recognizing the headline today in the paper is oil is approaching $100 a barrel. So who the heck knows what will happen tomorrow?

[Michael Lasser, analyst]

Okay. My follow-up question is, as long as you see big ticket under pressure or discretionary under pressure, which influences your total sales because it's important for your member to come in and buy these big ticket items, is this going to influence how you think about managing labor in the store? Should the market just anticipate that labor and other SG&A is going to delever as long as big ticket's under pressure?

[Richard Galanti, executive]

Well, I think we've seen that over the last year, frankly, we had such operating leverage over a couple of years when we had outside sales during the kind of the 2 years of COVID, call it the spring of '20 to the spring of 2022. And it was before COVID when our SG&A was over 10%, slightly over 10%, and we said would it ever be able to get below that. It's now still below 9%. So notwithstanding the fact, when I've looked at the last several quarters on a year-over-year basis, again, particularly in the last couple of quarters, we've seen some deleverage of that.

And look, we want to drive sales, and we'll do that in the best ways we can, so -- but we recognize when we used to -- we used to get the question all the time, what comp number do you need to have 0 negative or positive leverage with SG&A. Recognizing there was no -- very little inflation back then. But we used to say somewhere -- who knows but somewhere in the 4.5 to 5 range. So we don't know exactly where it is, but we're certainly not going to change the level of service that we have. And we're certainly going to respect our employees in terms of what we've done with wage increases over time. That's what we do.

[Operator]

We'll take our next question from Chuck Grom with Gordon Haskett.

[Charles Grom, analyst]

Just sticking on the inflation topic here on unit elasticity, particularly in categories where you're seeing prices actually start to fall or compress. Curious what you're seeing on units, if you're seeing them improve at all to offset those price declines, if there's any examples in either food or in GM that you could talk about.

[Richard Galanti, executive]

Well, yes, I remember when we talked a few quarters ago about some of the slowness in big ticket discretionary. When we got hotter on prices, it did a little bit but not as much as we would have thought to start with. But again, that perhaps was the impact of what's going on with the concerns in the economy and everything else. We know that when we put hot buys in what we call TBDs, temporary price discounts, on items, even medium-sized ticket items, we do see the units increase, but there's -- it's not as predictable, I would say, as it used to be.

[Charles Grom, analyst]

Okay. Great. And I think you don't provide guidance, but I -- go ahead.

[Richard Galanti, executive]

It's a little easier on the food side to see that sometimes when we're taking the price of a meat item down.

[Charles Grom, analyst]

Okay. So you are starting to see some units increase as prices drop in certain parts of the business then.

[Richard Galanti, executive]

Sure. And by the way, even on big ticket, when we've seen $300 and $400 price declines because of freight and raw material costs on some big ticket nonfood items, we'll see some of the sales picking back up on that. But it's -- there's nothing guaranteed.

[Charles Grom, analyst]

Okay. All right. And I know you don't put out guidance, but I actually do remember when you did give some directional help back in the day. But are there any big puts and takes that we should be thinking about on the gross margin and SG&A line over the next 4 quarters that we should be thinking about? Clearly, the LIFO lap will be an obvious tailwind. But just curious, any other things that we should be thinking about from a modeling perspective?

[Richard Galanti, executive]

No, not really. I mean, LIFO is certainly one that was an impact over the last year and starting to -- started to slow down. Assuming that trend continues, there won't be much LIFO going forward for right now, but we'll see. Beyond that, no, we're still opening. We opened 23 net new units this past year. We're onboard to do something in the mid- to high 20s this year. But that's not enough to move the needle in terms of leverage standpoint or anything.

No, I'd say it's steady as she goes. And if anything, I look at the margins overall, given everything that's going on, including competition that we're doing pretty well there. We -- with some of the wage hikes that we've continued to do and sales being a little weaker than they had been a year ago, I think we're doing pretty well on that as well. We're optimistic about our future but we'll see what happens.

[Operator]

We'll take our next question from Peter Benedict with Baird.

[Peter Benedict, analyst]

Richard, just first one just on LIFO. I was just curious. I mean the $30 million charge is small, but I'm just curious why they were even [ to the last one ]. Can you give us a little more color as maybe what drove?

[Richard Galanti, executive]

Yes. Well, I think it was on things like -- well, gas was one. And then in some of the fresh food items, there was -- even though there was deflation in things like eggs and some dairy products, there was some inflationary trends in beef. Beyond that -- do you have that handy?

[Unknown Executive]

[indiscernible]

[Richard Galanti, executive]

Yes. It's really small, but on $16 billion of inventory, it's a lot. I mean it's still a small number, $30 million. I'm not -- but on...

[Unknown Executive]

[indiscernible]

[Richard Galanti, executive]

That's all -- I don't have the details beyond that.

[Peter Benedict, analyst]

That's fine. Yes. No, that's fine. Just in the context of broader disinflation and all the stuff, it's interesting to see that. And then just really turning to the international stuff, you talked about the renewal rates impact. Can you remind us maybe on the international membership trends? When you open up a new club outside the U.S., maybe give us some framework or some benchmarks around how many new members tend to sign up. How does that compare to what you would see, let's say, in the next club you open in the U.S.? And then what kind of renewal rates you tend to see year 1, year 2, just so we have a frame of reference there?

[Richard Galanti, executive]

I don't have the exact numbers in front of me, but generally speaking, in Asia, whether it's Korea, Taiwan, Japan or China, we'll open a new unit, including the 10 or 12 weeks of sign-ups prior to opening, went anywhere from 50,000 to 100,000 new members. We had a couple of extremes like when we first opened in Shanghai and Minhang of well over 200,000. Now some of that's looky-loos that don't renew.

And we -- usually in that first year of renewal and those types of outsized numbers, we might be as low as the mid- to high 50s and is -- and it takes a few years to get even to the mid-70s. But we see those numbers overall continue to increase every year.

And I don't -- I can't -- I don't -- I should probably go back to what it was in the first 10 years of our 40-year history with even the U.S. My guess, it wasn't that extreme, but we didn't have as many -- it wasn't national and local news events the day we opened. You had a lot of people coming in, in some of these markets that are signing up that maybe live too far away or choose not to come back. So we're seeing that continuing to grow. So even that simple, that slight 0.1% decline, it's around the area in the sense that if you opened up a couple of more units a year ago, that they were just renewing for the first time, that increases that number.

[Peter Benedict, analyst]

Yes. No, understood. Last question. I think I heard you say mid- to high 20s in terms of unit opening planned for fiscal '24. Can you give us a sense of how many of those are in the U.S. and then how many would be international?

[Richard Galanti, executive]

70-plus percent in the U.S. and Canada, mostly U.S. of course, which, in my view, we're finding more openings -- more opportunities in the U.S. to infill given our high volumes, and we've got plenty going on over the years overseas.

[Operator]

We'll take our next question from Rupesh Parikh with Oppenheimer.

[Erica Eiler, analyst]

This is actually Erica Eiler on for Rupesh. So I guess, first, I was hoping maybe you could give this a quick download maybe on how you're feeling about the health of your consumer right now. I mean obviously, some concerns out there on student loan impact starting to roll in here as those restart. So maybe any color you can provide on how you're thinking about discretionary from here, maybe some of those concerns out there? Anything on trade-down or private label? Anything of note on that front in terms of consumer behavior as well?

[Richard Galanti, executive]

Right. Well, look, first of all -- first and foremost, our traffic continues to do very well. Being up continually 4% and 5% on a year-over-year basis is great. And our renewal rates continue to be very strong. So that's a starting point.

It makes sense to us on big-ticket discretionary, that's where you'd see the biggest weakness. We see some of that in some areas going back. When we look at our numbers compared to MBD that tells us where we are versus our competitors, overall -- not in every category but overall, we tend to do better. And so even a negative number here is a lower negative number than elsewhere.

So -- and again, what do we do? We brought in some smaller ticket items that are impulse snack items to get an extra partial item in everybody's basket. So yes -- and newness, bringing those new items. And there's not been a whole lot in television. Again, our unit sales in TVs are pretty good, but the average price point has come down. As they do anyway, there's always deflationary when you don't have new technology yet, and that's just -- we haven't seen a whole lot of new stuff yet there.

[Unknown Executive]

Gaming is good.

[Richard Galanti, executive]

Gaming is good right now. And Christmas is good. I mean we're one of the -- not the only one but one of the few that are bringing in seasonal items early. Everything from decor to trees to toys, that's starting off well so far. But it's new. It's in the last few weeks.

[Erica Eiler, analyst]

Okay, that's really helpful. And then just -- oh, no, go ahead.

[Richard Galanti, executive]

I'm sorry, what else did you ask?

[Erica Eiler, analyst]

Yes. And then just shifting gears. So I just wanted to touch on retail media, so obviously, a significant focus on driving retail media at some of your peers. So just curious if you could maybe talk a little bit about what Costco is doing in this area and the bigger opportunities that your team sees here.

[Richard Galanti, executive]

Well, part of that is some of the things we're doing with digital and mobile and the app. And we're not giving out quantifiable numbers. But certainly, some of our competitors are talking about doubling these numbers in the next 2 or 3 years. In my view, there's some low-hanging fruit out there, and we're actively working on it. We've hired a couple of people that are helping us with that as well, and more to come.

[Operator]

We'll take our next question from Paul Lejuez with Citigroup.

[Brandon Cheatham, analyst]

This is Brandon Cheatham on for Paul. I just wanted to -- when you look at the retail landscape, I was wondering, how do your wages compare to your competition? Are you seeing similar trends in inflation pressure on the wage front? And anything that you can help us with what your plans are over the next couple of quarters?

[Richard Galanti, executive]

Well, first of all, we've always prided ourselves in providing the best hourly wage package out there, wages, benefits contributions to 401(k). I'm using U.S. numbers here but our average U.S. -- 90% of our employees, like many big retailers, are hourly. And our average hourly wage is approaching $26, is in the high $25s. That's on top of a very rich health care plan where the employee only pays around 11% or 12% of it, I believe, and on top -- a little less than that.

And on top of that, we -- irrespective of what an employee contributes to his or her 401(k), we contribute anywhere from 3% to 9% based on years of service. So you've got a 20-year cashier making, on a full-time basis, in the mid-60s with another $4,000 or $5,000 being contributed to his or her 401(k) plan with a very rich health care plan. So we stand apart in our view compared to anybody.

Our pressure comes from ourselves. In the last few years, as there had been wage pressure, starting with the frontline workers during the beginnings of COVID, we, like many retailers, added a 2% premium -- $2 premium rather. We kept it longer, to our knowledge, than most anybody for a full year. And at the end, we kept $1 in there. And since then, we've had at least 3 or 4 increases on top of the normal top-of-scale increase that we do every -- generally have done every year, we have done every year. So we'll -- in our view, the pressure comes from us, and we feel that we're way ahead of our competition in that regard.

[Brandon Cheatham, analyst]

Got it. That's helpful. And I think you mentioned the next iteration on the app. You're going to be able to scan barcodes. Is the idea that eventually the customer is going to be able to scan and go? And how could that help flow operations in your stores if that is the case?

[Richard Galanti, executive]

I don't think we're prepared for scan and go yet. We'll just go to scan, but they can't go. No, at the end of the day, the first order of business is getting the merchandise on there and have numbers that -- where a member even goes online and say, "Hey, you can also get this currently at your local location." So knowing what's in store when somebody wants to come out, I think that's going to be a big positive to start with. And part of the scan is to be able to get more product information on the item as well.

[Operator]

We'll take our next question from Greg Melich with Evercore.

[Gregory Melich, analyst]

I had 2 questions, Richard. First, I'd love an update, given the volatility in gas prices the last 1.5 years, as to where we are on penny profit. I know that it improved a lot, but I'm curious if it came back down in the last 12 months or if it sort of stabilized at that higher level.

[Richard Galanti, executive]

Well, we don't give specific numbers. Gas has been stronger for us and we believe all retailers in the last few years. In fact, it was Q4 last year, which I think was our strongest quarter, recognizing it's a 16-week quarter. This fourth quarter, it was still strong, down from its strongest year earlier on a weekly basis but nonetheless quite strong. And so it's part of the profit picture currently of all big retailers that sell gas, the supermarkets, the Walmarts, the Costcos of the world.

So it's still a profitable business. It's -- our view has been it used to be when prices -- given that we turn it so fast, literally almost daily, when profits are going up -- and I'm sorry, when the price of gas is going up, the guy down the street who's turning it every 8 or 9 days is paying a little less 4 days ago. And so we make a little less and we -- when sales went down -- gallons -- the price per gallon went down. We made a little more. I think that equation, while it's still true, is not the driver of the bottom line of gas.

Everybody seems to be wanting to make more in gas, which allows us, in our view, to make it a little more and still be even more profitable. We've seen our competitive spread versus our direct competitors at every location, on average, improve over the last couple of years to now be in the, I want to say, the $0.30 range per gallon, mid-30s is the average, which is up. It's an average and it can range from $0.10 to $0.45. But at the end of the day, we feel good about our competitive position. It's increased and we're still quite profitable, down a little bit from a year ago but nonetheless, quite profitable.

[Gregory Melich, analyst]

That's helpful. And then my follow-up is on cash. I think you finished it with $13.7 billion. I think the last time you got to $13 billion was when you had a special dividend in 2020. What are your thoughts on how much cash you need or want and especially now that there is a positive interest rate on holding cash? Does that make you more interested in keeping it, but then you pay more tax? Just how do you think about...

[Richard Galanti, executive]

Well, I think it's -- look, at the end of the day, we've done 4 special dividends in the past. It's part of our DNA. At some point, we may do that again. Again, it's somewhat like the answer to the other question about membership fees. It's probably a question of when, not if, but we'll let you know.

Certainly, with earning 5%-ish on that money instead of a [ 25%-ish ] on that money does make it a little harder to do. But we're not selling at the kind of earnings multiple. We are to earn 5% on our assets. So at some point, we'll do something, and we'll have to wait and see.

[Operator]

We'll take our next question from Kelly Bania with BMO Capital Markets.

[Kelly Bania, analyst]

Richard, just wanted to ask -- I think I've asked this many, many times, but it seems like another huge quarter for Executive Membership growth, almost 1 million more this quarter. And I was just curious if you could talk about the profile of that member today that's either upgrading or starting out as Executive. What's the characteristics of that customer? And any changes in how that Executive Member spend in their first year in that upgrade compared to the prior years?

[Richard Galanti, executive]

I was joking when I say, first of all, they're very smart to be an Executive Member. Look, I think we -- over the time, we've done a better job of communicating the value of the Executive Member, so we clearly get more people to sign up that way in advance. And we see that, over time, a regular member, over the first few years, will buy more every year. An Executive Member starts at a higher lever and will buy more every year from that higher level. So that's really the profile that we've seen.

I don't have any specifics on how old the member is. I know that when we look at age characteristics of new members, we're still -- everybody used to be concerned 10 years ago how are we going to get millennials when we have an older average customer and all that. And we did with things -- with items, with things like organic. We're doing the same thing now. We're still getting our -- whether it's Gen Z or Gen A or whatever the next gen is, we are getting our share of those new numbers when we look at the profile of our members.

[Kelly Bania, analyst]

And Richard, I might have missed this. But did you quantify the extra week impact in terms of EBIT or EPS or anything for us?

[Richard Galanti, executive]

No. It's -- I mean, the simple math would just say it's [ 16, 17 ] of our quarter is equal to a 16-week quarter. That's about as good as we could do. But in case that -- usually on net income, it takes the 16 or whatever percent number down to a 9 or something, and that's just simple math.

[Operator]

We'll take our next question from Oliver Chen with TD Cowen.

[Oliver Chen, analyst]

Richard, inventory seemed well positioned. What are your thoughts about where they are now and also how we will model them going forward relative to sales? And then as we look at overall ticket trends being negative, that compare starts to ease. So does that imply that will inflect on partly the nature of the ticket comparisons overall.

The same question for e-commerce. As you anniversary some of the headwinds, can we expect the comparison to help as well?

[Richard Galanti, executive]

Sure. Inventories, as I mentioned, we feel the merchants feel very good about our inventory levels right now. There are a few departments a little higher than they want, a few that did a little bit more [ sure ]. But overall, they're very good.

In fact, you look at -- our fiscal year-end inventory stood at just under $16.7 billion and payables stood at $17.5 billion. So I think this is the -- running above 100% on that simple ratio is something new. We used to be -- we used to enjoy running 90% to 95%. It fluctuates. But overall, we feel good about our inventories where they are now.

And in terms of supply chain, things coming in on time, we feel good about that as well. Now as it relates to -- as we anniversary the inflection of when we saw some weakness, I think a couple of quarters ago, I mentioned that, well, what will help your big ticket sales. I said, well, at least in a few -- several more months, we'll anniversary this weakness.

So certainly, that's going to help. I would like to think that it's not just that thing that's going to help, but -- and the same with e-commerce. I mean we're, again, one bright spot in this virtually all e-commerce -- not nearly all e-commerce, was the appliances that -- and I think we've done a better job also of showing the value of these items online, not just the price of the item, which, in our case, includes delivery and warranty and things like that more so than some of our competitors and showing great value there.

[Oliver Chen, analyst]

Just a couple of short ones. Would love any thoughts on Instacart. It seems like it's a really great partnership that you've had for a while. Also another question we had is will EV charging play a role in how you're thinking about future services for customers. Finally, China, any -- it's a smaller percentage of total, but it's an important market for the long term. What's happening there? Has anything changed the value proposition or the geopolitics?

[Richard Galanti, executive]

Okay. Yes, I had the second and third. What was the first question?

[Unknown Executive]

Instacart.

[Richard Galanti, executive]

Instacart. I know they just went public, so we've gotten a lot of questions. At the end of the day, they're good -- we're a good partner with them. They're a good partner for us. We use them throughout the U.S. and Canada. And sales are growing. We've added over the last -- during COVID, we added some nonfood items that still can be carried in the car if you will. And we're doing, I think, prescriptions with them now. And so no, it's a good relationship and has been for a while.

Yes. I might add, though, that with regard to those sales, we include that in our warehouse sales, not our e-commerce sales because it's their employee coming into Costco to shop, to purchase at the register and then take it to the customer. So that's not in our mobile or e-commerce sales.

As it relates to EV charging, we're testing it in a number of locations. Not a whole lot to be said. If there's a charge for it, it's going to be less at Costco. And we'll wait and see.

And then as it relates to China, no, we just opened a few weeks ago our fifth location. We have 2 more planned this fiscal year, both in the -- I think 1 in Shenzhen in early calendar '24 and 1 other 1 before the end of August, so we'll have 7 locations up from 2 1.5 years ago. And so far, our openings there have treated us well overall.

[Operator]

We'll take our next question from Scot Ciccarelli with Truist.

[Scot Ciccarelli, analyst]

Can you help us understand a bit better how the Costco Next process works? I mean is it similar to how your e-commerce business used to work where products were essentially drop-shipped from their vendors? And if that's the case, Richard, how do you control the quality of the product and delivery process? Because I thought that became an issue for you guys before you took over your own distribution for e-com.

[Richard Galanti, executive]

Yes. Costco Next is drop-shipped. We curate the items with these suppliers. And they're, for the most part, pretty well-known brands. And so far, we have not had an issue on that, recognizing they tend to be items that are easily shipped to a home. Yes, and we're doing -- we have all the tracking information as well.

So all I can tell you is you're right about that. That's a good point. Years ago when we did this, there was a difference. But so far, it's worked quite well for us. We've had very few customer issues as it relates to items purchased on costco.com or costconext.com.

[Scot Ciccarelli, analyst]

Okay. Understood. And then another inflation question. If we do wind up getting outright deflation, outside of improved traffic or unit velocity, are there ways to protect margin? Because it seems to me like that could wind up being a deflator to the margin if we're in a deflationary environment there.

[Richard Galanti, executive]

Well, look, that's what our business is about. We're -- we'll take a 10 pack and make it a 12 pack, I guess. But at the end of the day, if there's a little disinflation, it'll impact all of us. But again, I think it should be favorable with us because we'll show the best -- we'll still show the best value out there.

[Operator]

We'll take our next question...

[Richard Galanti, executive]

Before you do, another comment was made at the table here that if there is deflation or disinflation, we've got a $450 million, $500 million LIFO reserve that will be -- on a reported basis, will be part of a tailwind of that disinflation.

[Operator]

And we'll take our next question from Scott Mushkin with R5 Capital.

[Scott Mushkin, analyst]

I don't think we've talked about it. But what's competition like out there now that we're seeing inflation come down in volumes, particularly for some guys are on a negative? Just wondering if you -- what it looks like out there.

[Richard Galanti, executive]

I think, look, we've said this for a few years now, our competition with Sam's is the most direct, and we've seen improvements in parts of what they do from our perspective. They're tough competitors and so are we. And -- but I think they've continued to get -- to improve over time and as have we. I don't -- we don't really see a whole lot of other things.

BJ's, while we respect their model and what they do, it's a slightly different model, so there's not as much -- there's certainly -- when we are competing directly as a membership warehouse club, we're making sure we're sharp on pricing, particularly in fresh and things like that, supermarket items. Beyond that, yes, our view is on the nonfood side, we're gaining share, as evidenced by the numbers we see in some of these NPD results and the thing that I just called out on appliances and things like that, recognizing appliances is a, whatever, a $30 billion business. We're still a small piece of it but growing rapidly.

[Scott Mushkin, analyst]

And then I know it came up earlier about raising membership rates but kind of philosophical, like this recession, not recession, maybe there will be one. How does the company look at raising the membership fee if the economy is slow and fast? Does it matter? Does it factor in?

[Richard Galanti, executive]

I think it matters -- it does matter. And I think it really mattered as we approached kind of the 5.5 years post June '17, we were in the high -- the headline every day was inflation and economy. And so we're doing great. We've got great loyalty. If we wait a little longer, so be it. And that's kind of how we feel right now.

[Operator]

We'll take our next question from Chris Horvers with JPMorgan.

[Christopher Horvers, analyst]

So your core-on-core margins were up a lot in this quarter. Can you talk about what drove that? I think you mentioned food and sundries. Is that successful vendor-funded promotions? Is there anything onetime in nature about that gain that we shouldn't extrapolate forward?

[Richard Galanti, executive]

Yes. Well, aside from LIFO, markdowns were a lot less, I think -- quarter-on-quarter. So no markdowns was a big piece of it. Particularly on the nonfood side, that helped. Last year, we had -- it was a year ago that all of us, including Costco, I think our inventories on a year-over-year basis were up 26% for 2 quarters in a row. And of course, those have all come down. And so that was probably the biggest single thing in those numbers.

Yes. A comment that was made at the table here, we're back on track on seasonal in and out dates. So we're not having -- a year -- it was a year, 1.5 years ago where certain seasonal items came in late. And just to move them out, not to have to store them as much -- some we did store but to move them out where we thought was the best way to do it, we took extra markdowns. So that helped.

[Christopher Horvers, analyst]

And then a follow-up question around the consumer. You just came through the back-to-school season. There are some important electronics categories that are a big part of the basket during that time of the year that also become a big part of the basket around holiday. Are you seeing iPads and PCs and notebooks, are you seeing positive unit trends? And how does it make you feel about the upcoming holiday season?

[Richard Galanti, executive]

Gaming is up. Some of the Apple products are up. TV units are up but again, the average price points have come down some. Tablets are up and audio is up a little.

[Christopher Horvers, analyst]

But not notebooks and computers?

[Richard Galanti, executive]

No. Less down was the answer, yes.

[Operator]

We'll take our next question from John Heinbockel with Guggenheim.

[John Heinbockel, analyst]

So Richard, first thing, maybe just talk about how you look at cannibalization versus expanding the market in the U.S., right? And if you -- obviously, you can now put, it looks like, locations closer together. When you kind of look at the U.S. in total, is there a number, right, that you guys have in mind that's now possible given what you're doing with density?

[Unknown Executive]

We could add another 150.

[Richard Galanti, executive]

Yes. Yes. Our view is over the next 10 years that we could add easily another 150, and that's on top of however many business centers, call it, but just in the U.S. And that number keeps changing. If you had asked me 6, 8 years ago where we'd be today, I would say if we were 70-30 U.S. back then, we'd be 50-50 by now outside of the -- will be 50. And today, we're at 65, 70 in the U.S. still. So we're finding more opportunities here.

And it's evidenced by just the sheer volumes of the units that our units are doing today versus 3 or 4 years ago. It's much higher than we would have expected 3 or 4 years ago. So we think that there's still a lot of runway in that regard.

[John Heinbockel, analyst]

And then just a quick follow-up. The -- I know you guys haven't been particularly interested in BOPIS, right, for cost reasons. And I assume that's still the case. There's a consumer argument for it, but I think it's hard to make the cost side of it work. Is that still your view?

[Richard Galanti, executive]

That is still our view overall. In addition to the thing I mentioned a little bit with what we're doing with Instacart on some nonfood items as well, we are testing in-store some big-ticket items like TVs but on a limited basis to see what happens for buy online and pick up in store.

[Operator]

We'll take our last question from Joe Feldman with Telsey Advisory Group.

[Joseph Feldman, analyst]

I wanted to ask about, the CPG guys, are they funding promotions a little more regularly with you guys? I know you did something, I think, with P&G that seemed like a clever promotion, get a gift card back from them, it seemed. And I'm just wondering what you're seeing across the other vendors.

[Richard Galanti, executive]

Yes. Well, the CGP, actually, we did that last year as well. We've done it for a couple of years, and we will say if we did it again. It's growing. So yes. And once we do that with one, we want to share that excitement with others to see what other types of things we can drive that way. So yes, I'd say there's probably a little bit more increase on that type of promotional things and inventory available for those things because we can really drive sales of those items in a short period of time.

[Joseph Feldman, analyst]

Right. That makes sense, yes, the volume that you guys do. And then are you guys approaching holiday any different this year? I know you mentioned Christmas goods are off to a good start. But is that earlier than normal? I feel like you're about the same timing, but maybe you could share thoughts on the approach to the holiday season.

[Richard Galanti, executive]

If it's earlier, it's a week or 2 earlier and some things came in early and...

[Unknown Executive]

[indiscernible]

[Richard Galanti, executive]

Yes, yes. It's a little early compared to some of the supply chain disruptions we had, which screwed up a lot of things. But if you go back to where we were before COVID, we're probably at or very slightly earlier. And in terms of how we're approaching it, we're approaching it aggressively in terms of having stuff to sell to the member. But we want to be out, too.

Typically, this is nothing different here. Even on things like toys, we'll bring in a few things in the last couple of weeks before Christmas, that if they don't sell through, we're not at risk of having to mark them down dramatically because they're not unique just to Christmas.

Well, thank you, everyone. We're around to answer questions. And have a good holiday, and we'll talk to you soon.

[Operator]

That does conclude today's presentation. Thank you for your participation, and you may now disconnect.